Meet The Founding Four
💜 The Founding Four
$40.00
click for description
Signature Squares
Peach Please!
$84.00
click for description
Pecan Perfection Signature Squares 12 Ct
$84.00
click for description
Banana Bliss Signature Squares
$84.00
click for description
Sweetie Pie Signature Squares | 12 Count
$84.00
click for description
The Pies & Surprise Experience
The Signature Experience
Starting at $500.00
click for description
The Celebration Experience
Starting at $850.00
click for description
The Grand Experience
Starting at $1,200.00
click for description
The Ultimate Pies & Surprise Experience
Starting at $2,500.00
click for description
About
Pies & Surprise LLC is a St. Louis dessert company and home of the Signature Square, where familiar desserts are transformed into bold, generously sized creations made to be remembered.
From our Signature Square collections to elegant cakes, corporate catering, wholesale, and the Pies & Surprise Dessert Experience, we create desserts for everyday cravings, celebrations, businesses, and unforgettable events.
Every creation is made with intention, flavor, and LOVES.
What you crave, I create
Capabilities & Pricing
Signature Squares
Signature Four | $35
The Founding Four | $40
12-Count Signature Squares | $84+
Elegant Cakes
6” Two-Layer Elegant Cakes | Starting at $75
Airbrushed Cupcakes
24-Count Box | $60
Dessert Experiences & Business Services
Dessert Cart Experience | Starting at $500
Corporate Catering | Custom Quote
Wholesale | Custom Quote
Additional flavors, quantities, delivery, and specialty requests may affect pricing.
What you crave, I create.