Ratings & Reviews

Received my 2nd order and just like the first one, everything was excellent. I'm hooked on the banana pudding and now also on the Strawberry Cheesecake cupcakes. They are very timely and orders have been ready at the time I requested. Very friendly and to me nothing beats good customer service EXCEPT great food. They have both!!!!

I highly recommend the banana pudding. I've tried many over the last 30 years since my grandma passed (I'm 67 now), and all were disappointments. This BP was sooo damn good I had to force myself to stop eating it. The process was easy to order, to pay, and I elected to pickup as I live on the Southside of St Louis. You're able to choose the date needed and she was on time at the time promised and she delivered a fantastic product. I will be ordering more and no more chain store puddings and pies for me. On a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the highest, this was a 12. Let me get just one more bowl tonight to make sure I didn't miss anything lmao!!!

First time I ordered from Pies & Surprise and it was a fantastic experience. I wanted to bring a special dessert to Thanksgiving and everyone was wowed! I was expecting the pie to be in a pan, but instead it was beautifully made - like art work - where the crust IS the pan. It was not only delicious, but it looked beautiful. I would highly recommend!!

I ordered some Cookie Monster browning cookies and got so upset at how fast I ate them!!! They were so good I couldn’t stop myself from grabbing another. She surprised me with a few extra cookies as well and the service and delivery time was great and quicker than I expected. Well order more soon.

The Dessert Is Very Delicious Here I Order My Niece Cake And The Party Went Crazy Love For It. Never Seen A Cake Disappear at a party The kids really ate it all... The Owner Was Very Polite. Love The Serves NO Delays And Every Order Was Made On Time. If Your Looking For A GOOD TREAT I'd recommend Trying PIES &SURPRISE. THANK YOU- Miss PIE

I order a dozen of chocolate chip cookie cupcakes. They were professionally made and decorated so cute🥰 The cupcakes were moist and tasty. I also order a dozen of lemon cupcakes for next week , I can't wait until next week🤤🤤🤤

That cake was so delicious I didn't share it with anyone, it was gone in 3 days...

One of the best cheese cakes I've had in long time I recommend for people to go and get the dessert of their choice.

Paulette bakes and cooks from the heart. She is a wonderful woman. I was blown away when she did my daughter’s cake ANNND she did it last minute. Her banana pudding lil pies are AMAZING and that’s coming from someone who HATES anything banana. Sure lots of people can bake but Paulette puts LOVE into her cooking/baking.