Meet the Founding Four, the Signature Squares that define Pies & Surprise. Your collection includes one of each: Sweetie Pie Sweet Potato Pie Square Pecan Perfection Pecan Pie Square Peach Please! Peach Cobbler Cake Square Banana Bliss Banana Pudding Cookie Square Four different personalities. Four signature flavors. One box made to introduce you to the heart of Pies & Surprise. What you crave, I can create.

I’m the Blueberry Pie Signature Square made for the person who likes dessert bold, thick and worth the plate. I bring a rich blueberry center, a buttery baked base and enough flavor to stand out at birthdays, office celebrations, family gatherings and every table tired of ordinary dessert. One order includes a full pan of 12 Blueberry Pie Signature Squares, all one flavor, ready to serve, share and have people asking who made them.

I’m the Strawberry Pie Signature Square you bring out when regular dessert will not do. I’m thick, fruity, rich and made to hold my own on the table. I belong at birthdays, family gatherings, office celebrations and every moment that needs something people will actually remember. One order includes a full pan of 12 Strawberry Pie Signature Squares, all one flavor, ready to serve, share and disappear faster than you planned.

I’m the Peach Cobbler Signature Square that shows up warm, buttery and ready to steal the table. I’m made for the person who wants that familiar peach cobbler feeling without needing a bowl and spoon. Bring me to birthdays, family gatherings, office celebrations or any event where people expect dessert to actually feel special. One order includes a full pan of 12 Peach Cobbler Signature Squares, all one flavor, ready to serve, share and have people reaching back for another.

I’m the Sunshine Key Lime Signature Square made for the person who wants dessert bright, creamy and impossible to ignore. I bring a thick, chewy cookie base, a cool key lime layer and a graham crumble that gives every bite the right balance of sweet and tangy. I belong at summer gatherings, brunches, celebrations and every table that needs something fresh between all the heavy desserts. One order includes a full pan of 12 Sunshine Key Lime Signature Squares, all one flavor, ready to serve, share and have people asking where you found me.