Ratings & Reviews

We have tried so many things from this shop and everything has been incredible. You can tell everything is such great quality and packaged very well. Carolyn has been so easy to work with and is incredibly kind, my kids love visiting her shop! If we absolutely had to pick a favorite, I think the cinnamon rolls would be our winner. So glad she opened so close to our house!

The eggs are so fresh and the pancake mix is my kids favorite! We’ve tried the various breads, hand pies and brownies. All so delicious!

Carolyn was so informative and so fun!! I absolutely loved taking this class. My bestie and I have always wanted to learn how to make sourdough bread and came across Carolyn on Instagram. Her home was beautiful, her class was educational, and the bread was seriously the best bread I’ve ever had.

Met Carolyn in Spring 2026 at Cumming Farmers market. She is just a wonderful woman with true southern charm, She taught a sourdough 101 class and did a tremendous job.Very detailed and even supplied attendees with their own starter. Take the class and learn how to cook your own bread! Thanks Carolyn

I thoroughly enjoyed the sourdough 101 class with Carolyn. She was very welcoming and I could tell she puts a lot of thought and care into everything she does including this class! I went knowing absolutely nothing about making bread let alone sourdough and left feeling so excited to start my journey. She shared her 100 year old family sourdough starter with us (I named mine Doughlene) and I thought that was so amazing. I brought the dough we were taught how to make home and baked her and it was very good! I'm excited to do it again at home. Thank you so much Carolyn!

Everything is delicious and packaged so nicely! Thank you!

Initially bought items at the Cumming City Center Farmers Market and later placed an online order. Communication was excellent, the ordering process was easy, and everything was delicious. Highly recommend!

We met Carolyn at the farmer's market and first tried the lavendar-infused maple syrup, pancake mix, and relish. Everything was so delicious that we immediately thought of her a couple months later when we were brainstorming for local goodies to make as thank-you gifts. Her pancake mixes are easy to make, and are perfect for early mornings with the family. We also enjoy her savory bakes and pickles. She has an amazing talent and great creativity! We are always looking forward to trying something new at her farmstand! 🤤

Im so happy I found this little farm stand. It's worth it just for the fresh eggs, but Carolyn also sells cookies, bread, salsa, and so many other great homemade recipes! Me and my family have loved everything and we will definitely be coming back for more!

The eggs are delicious! Im definitely coming back as much as I can. I have been looking for a place like Cottage Mill farm for a long time and I am so happy I found them.

I can’t recommend Carolyn/Cottage Mill Farm enough! She curates every item beautifully with whole foods in mind, from her milled flours to her artisan sourdough bread. Her pantry products are a wonderful addition to any cleaner, healthier kitchen. She never compromises on quality every homemade items is made with the finest ingredients, and you can truly taste the difference. On top of that, her customer service is exceptional thoughtful, responsive, and genuinely caring. If you want delicious, wholesome baked goods, clean pantry staples made with love and the very best ingredients, please try any of her unique products!

Love the fresh, local, family farm products. Our local source for wonderful farm fresh sweet treats, soup/dinners starters, top notch farm fresh eggs, fantastic ground ancient grain flours, farm made jams and jellies, and many other clean, organic baking ingredients. Cottage Mill products are tasty and fresh, special orders gladly accomodated.

Fast shipping, fresh ingredients, prompt communication with seller

Carolyn has amazing customer service and the products are always top quality and delicious! Love the farm stand. Highly recommend this local farm!

I can say that Carolyn is the best. She went above and beyond to get me my merchandise. The products are fabulous! I highly recommend.

So easy to order and great service - right to my front door. Will definitely order more from this great small business!