NOW ACCEPTING ORDERS THROUGH MAY 2026.
Visit the custom decorated cookies page to see pricing details and request an order OR email me directly at orders@sugarislandbakeshop.com
Please submit your invitation copy for inspiration + color-matching.
×
Custom Cookie Favors
1. Choose your pricing level + quantity 2. Choose your pickup date 3. Input any specific details, text, dates, colors, etc. 4. Submit a photo of your event invitation and inspiration photos (if you have any), event decor, etc. 5. Submit for availability approval + invoice. *All cookies come individually wrapped in ribbon-tied bags. *FULL ORDER DETAIL IS AND PAYMENT IS REQUIRED TO BE CONFIRMED ON MY CALENDAR.
Custom Decorated Cookies - LEVEL 4
Character cookies+
2 dozen minimum - 1 character per dozen minimum
$114.00
click for description
Custom Decorated Cookies - LEVEL 3
5+ designs/colors or high detail, florals, heavy hand-painted metallics, simple hand drawn logos, stencil work, printed images.
Price is per dozen with a 2 dozen minimum.
$96.00
click for description
Custom Decorated Cookies - LEVEL 2
Up to 4 designs, 4 colors MAX, medium detail, minimal lettering.
Price is per dozen with a 2 dozen minimum.
$78.00
click for description
Custom Decorated Cookie Favors - LEVEL 1
1 icing color (plus white, if needed), single layer of icing. No additional top details.
Price is per dozen with a 2 dozen minimum.
$60.00
click for description