NOW ACCEPTING ORDERS THROUGH MAY 2026. Visit the custom decorated cookies page to see pricing details and request an order OR email me directly at orders@sugarislandbakeshop.com Please submit your invitation copy for inspiration + color-matching.

Monthly Specials Custom Cookie Favors Cookie Platters EASTER Gallery Reviews Contact

Ratings & Reviews

3 Ratings

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

The best!Stephanie

5 months ago

Nicole has the most delicious and adorable cookies! I have purchased them many times as gifts as they always receive rave reviews. My children love her DIY kits. Highly recommend!!!

Cookies are amazing Christina Anassis

5 months ago

Best cookies !! I order all the time and everyone compliments how tasty they are !!

The best!Colleen D. Multari

5 months ago

Sugar Island is my go to for cookies. I know they'll always be delicious, pretty and packaged beautifully! Highly recommend!