Sugar Island Bake Shop

Hi, I'm Nicole, the self-taught baker behind Sugar Island Bake Shop. What started as a family tradition of decorating Christmas cookies has grown into a full-fledged business thanks to the encouragement of those around me and my own desire to take on new creative challenges.

At Sugar Island, I focus on attention to detail, creating custom cookies that don’t just look beautiful — they wow guests and get people talking. Whether you're planning a birthday, baby shower, holiday party, or any special occasion, I design each set with the goal of making your event unforgettable.

In addition to custom cookie orders, I offer hands-on decorating classes for all ages, helping others discover the joy of creating something beautiful (and delicious).

Select "Custom Decorated cookies favors" in the drop down menu for more details.

I am unable to take orders for characters or 3D florals at this time.