Bakery closed for fall planning and recipe testing in August.
×

Sourdough Cookies & Bars

We rotate our cookie selection frequently. If you don’t see your fav listed, check back. ❤️ Sourdough cookies and treats are available for pickup, delivery, or shipping. 📦
Banana Pudding Cookie (Sourdough)
Banana Pudding Cookie (Sourdough)

A favorite of the south. Stuffed with Nilla wafers and white chocolate chips. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Blondie Cookie (Sourdough)
Blondie Cookie (Sourdough)

White chocolate and Golden Oreos. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Blueberry Lemon Cookie (Sourdough)
Blueberry Lemon Cookie (Sourdough)

Blueberry blonde cookie stuffed with a burst of flavor otherwise known as a lemon cake pop. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Brookie Cookie (Sourdough)
Brookie Cookie (Sourdough)

Made of Dutch processed cocoa powder, the brownie is first homemade and then stuffed into a blonde OG cookie. Yummm Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Candy Bar Cookie (Sourdough)
Candy Bar Cookie (Sourdough)

Chocolate chip cookie stuffed candy bars and garnished with candy. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Campfire Cookie (Sourdough)
Campfire Cookie (Sourdough)

A graham cracker base, surrounded by a buttery golden crust filled with chocolate chips. Polly stuffs this cookie with marshmallows, Hershey chocolate and tops the cookie with a cookies and cream bar. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Cookie Butter Cookie (Sourdough)
Cookie Butter Cookie (Sourdough)

This bakery-style cookie features a thick, golden-brown dough infused with the deep, caramelized flavor of speculoos, resulting in a soft, chewy texture with crisp, buttery edges. Topped with whit chocolate and garnished with a Biscoff biscuit. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Cookies & Cream Cookie (Sourdough)
Cookies & Cream Cookie (Sourdough)

A rich dark chocolate base filled with chocolate chips and Oreo cookies and is stuffed with cookies and cream. Polly tops the cookie with a cookies and cream chocolate bar Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Cowgirl Cookie (Sourdough)
Cowgirl Cookie (Sourdough)

This bakery-style cookie features a blend of gooey caramel bits, rich chocolate chips, & coconut is folded in. Stuffed with coconut cream and topped with a generous dusting of toasted coconut shreds. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Double Chocolate Mint Cookie (Sourdough)
Double Chocolate Mint Cookie (Sourdough)

Two types of chocolate and peppermint come together for the ultimate flavor combination. All you’ll need is a comfy blanket and a good book. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Dubai Cookie (Sourdough)
Dubai Cookie (Sourdough)

A tender chocolate cookie filled with chocolate chips, & stuffed with pistachio cream & kataifi. Polly tops it off with even more toasted pistachios. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, Nuts, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Funfetti Sammie Cookie (Sourdough)
Funfetti Sammie Cookie (Sourdough)

A buttery cookie loaded with Funfetti and stuffed with white chocolate cream. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Gingerbread Snickerdoodle Cookie (Sourdough)
Gingerbread Snickerdoodle Cookie (Sourdough)

The comfort of cinnamon and gingerbread and stuffed full of white chocolate cream. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Hazelnut Cookie (Sourdough)
Hazelnut Cookie (Sourdough)

A hazelnut cookie stuffed with hazelnut cream and topped with a Ferrero Rocher. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, Nuts, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Midnight Snacker Cookie (Sourdough)
Midnight Snacker Cookie (Sourdough)

Stuffed with chocolate chip and Oreo cookies and garnished the googly eyes. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Mint Madness Cookie (Sourdough)
Mint Madness Cookie (Sourdough)

The Mint Madness cookie is a thick, chewy light green dough stuffed to the brim with Oreos and peppermint. The center is stuffed with peppermint cream and topped with Andes Mint candy. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie (Sourdough)
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie (Sourdough)

A hearty steel cut oatmeal stuffed with dehydrated grapes and stuffed with cheesecake. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
The OG Cookie (Sourdough)
The OG Cookie (Sourdough)

A brown butter, chocolate chip bakery style cookie is a gourmet, elevated version of the classic cookie, characterized by a deep, complex flavor profile and a superior texture. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Peanut Butter Delight Cookie (Sourdough)
Peanut Butter Delight Cookie (Sourdough)

A fudgy chocolate cookie and the iconic peanut butter and chocolate flavors of Reese's. It features a deep-cocoa base, and stuffed with peanut butter cream. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, Nuts, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Pumpkin Spice Cookie (Sourdough)
Pumpkin Spice Cookie (Sourdough)

All the flavors of fall and winter wrapped up in a cookie, stuffed full of chocolate chunks and pumpkin spice cream and topped with toast pecans. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Flour, Soy, Dairy, Nuts, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Rock Concert Cookie (Sourdough)
Rock Concert Cookie (Sourdough)

Chocolate chips, M&M’s, peanut butter cream, & Peanut M&M’s Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Flour, Soy, Dairy, Nuts, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Rocky Road Cookie (Sourdough)
Rocky Road Cookie (Sourdough)

A chewy chocolate dutch process cookie, loaded with marshmallows and nuts. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Flour, Soy, Dairy, Nuts, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Salted Caramel Cookie (Sourdough)
Salted Caramel Cookie (Sourdough)

This decadent salted caramel cookie features a soft, buttery brown sugar base that encases a surprise caramel center and stuffed with salty crunchy pretzel pieces and chocolate chips. Topped with a salted caramel. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Flour, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Triple Chocolate Cookie (Sourdough)
Triple Chocolate Cookie (Sourdough)

Three types of chocolate come together in one perfect bite. Made in honor of all chocolate lovers. Stuffed with white chocolate cream. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Flour, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Velvet Tuxedo Cookie (Sourdough)
Velvet Tuxedo Cookie (Sourdough)

This decadent bakery-style red velvet cookie features a thick, chewy base with white chocolate chips and stuffed with cheese cake. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Walnut Cookie Chocolate Chip (Sourdough)
Walnut Cookie Chocolate Chip (Sourdough)

This bakery style walnut chocolate chip cookie is a decadent, oversized treat designed with a thick, "mountain-like" profile that yields a soft, gooey center and perfectly golden, crispy, outer edges. Stuffed with cheesecake and topped with toasted walnuts. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Nuts, Dairy, & Eggs

$5.00
click for description
Bakery Box Assortment (12 Bakery Style Cookies)
Bakery Box Assortment (12 Bakery Style Cookies)

A bakery box assortment of one dozen cookies features a curated selection of 3–4 different flavors, arranged to provide a mix of colors, flavors, and textures.

$55.00
click for description
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies (Half Dozen) (Sourdough)
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies (Half Dozen) (Sourdough)

A warm chocolate chip cookie just out of the oven! Fresh and baked to order. Expect a golden-brown cookie with darker, crispier edges and a softer center. Melted chocolate chips will be visible, some still soft and gooey. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, & Eggs

$18.00
click for description
Frosted Brownie (8”x8” Pan) (Sourdough)
Frosted Brownie (8”x8” Pan) (Sourdough)

Polly’s sourdough brownie with creamy ganache frosting is a deeply decadent dessert that balances intense chocolate richness with a subtle, tangy complexity. Made with melted butter, Dutch-process cocoa powder. The ganache is a rich, glossy coating that sets over the brownie, adding another layer of creamy texture to the fudgy base. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$18.00
click for description
Buckeye Brownie (4”x 5” Pan) (Sourdough)
Buckeye Brownie (4”x 5” Pan) (Sourdough)

A delicious fudgey brownie base, followed by a layer of peanut butter goodness, then topped with a layer of chocolate. Amaze, amaze. Available for pickup or delivery. Unable to ship due to Florida heat. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs

$15.00
click for description
Seasonal Sugar Cookie Decorating Kit
Seasonal Sugar Cookie Decorating Kit

Let Polly do all the work and you make all the memories! Everything you’ll need for this fun cookie decorating activity will be included in this kit. The freshly baked cookies are made with organic flour and no preservatives. You will receive: - sugar cookies in various seasonal cutout shapes - edible painting card in seasonal colors - paint brush - Decorating Instructions Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat & Dairy

$12.00
click for description

Follow us!