Cookie Tower Gift Set (Pink)
Beautiful Pink Nested Cookie Tins This holiday gift set features a charming set of keepsake cookie tins. They showcase a soft, pastel-pink color scheme, adding a modern twist to traditional holiday packaging. Each level is filled to the brim with freshly baked seasonal favorites. Limited supply for shipping, pickup, or delivery available. Pre-Order now for November or December. 📦 Image displays sugar cookies, sugar and spice, and oatmeal ginger (gluten friendly).
$90.00
click for description
Apple Caramel Tea Ring (Serves 8-10)
The Apple & Caramel Ring is a beautiful, show-stopping sweet bread. Perfect for sharing with friends and family. Topped with a drizzle icing and is nut free. *Gift wrapping available. Available for shipping, pickup, or delivery. 📦 *Shipping Note: The 1929 ring shipped will arrive unfrosted and include an icing packet. You will be able to warm your ring in the oven, then frost it with the frosting packet that is included. Allergen: Contains eggs, soy, and dairy.
$30.00
click for description
8” Naked Cake (Serves 20 Guests)
A rustic and simple palette ready for your topper or florals. Flavors are white cake with white buttercream in three layers. Available for pickup or delivery. Allergen: Contains eggs, soy, and dairy.
$150.00
click for description
Sourdough Flight - Charcuterie Blend 🔥 (Fan Favorite)
Can decide on one type? Now you don’t have to. Four adorable mini loaves in a variety of flavors. Put your taste buds to the test. 🤗 * Pepperoni & Mozzarella * Three Cheese * Artisan * Jalapeno & Cheddar
$25.00
click for description
6” Naked Cake (Serves 12 Guests)
A rustic and simple palette ready for your topper or florals. Flavors are white cake with white buttercream in three layers. Available for pickup or delivery. Allergen: Contains eggs, soy, and dairy.
$110.00
click for description
Cake Lollipop (Dozen) 🔥 ( Fan Favorite)
Chocolate, funfetti, carrot, strawberry, or vanilla. Made to order and hand dipped in white or dark chocolate. Please indicate two chocolate colors. It would be helpful if you included a party invitation and/or provided the theme inspiration. This includes a simple drizzle, sprinkle, and boxed. Customization with accessories (chocolate molding for frames, objects, letters, numbers, edible glitter, etc.), marbling, individual wrapping, glitter or clear sticks, specialty bows, flavored specialty cake (funfetti, carrot, lemon, etc.), and chocolate inclusions (cookies & cream, candies, la choy, marbling, etc.) are an additional cost. Available for pickup or delivery. Not suitable for shipping.
$65.00
click for description
Monthly Cookie Club (One Dozen)
A bakery box stuffed with 8 bakery style cookies per box (seasonal + regular menu items)! 🍪 No commitments, cancel anytime. Automatically billed monthly.
$55.00
click for description
Cherry Cheesecake Loaf 🔥 (Fan Favorite)
Enjoy for breakfast, brunch, or dessert and pairs perfectly with coffee or tea. Its rich composition helps it stay fresh and moist, making it convenient for the recipient. * Give wrapping available if added to order. Available for shipping, pickup, or delivery. 📦
$20.00
click for description
Sourdough Flight - Fall Blend
Can decide on one type? Now you don’t have to. Four adorable mini loaves in a variety of flavors. Put your taste buds to the test. 🤗 * Kalamata Olive & Rosemary * Chocolate Chip * Artisan * Walnut & Cranberry
$25.00
click for description
Cookie Tin Gift
Beautiful Nutcracker Cookie Tin This holiday gift features a charming keepsake cookie tin filled to the brim with freshly baked seasonal favorites. Perfect for hostess gift or gift exchange. Limited supply for shipping, pickup, or delivery available. Pre-Order now for November or December. 📦
$60.00
click for description
Peach Marmalade (Pectin-Free)
We slow-simmer juicy, peak-season Georgia peaches with California navel oranges, organic sugar, and Florida lemons. Perfectly sweet with a spreadable, chunky texture, it is an elevated addition to your morning toast, charcuterie, or a grilling glaze. Canned for a long shelf life. Refrigerate after opening.
$15.00
click for description
Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Loaf 🔥 (Fan Favorite)
It can be enjoyed for breakfast, brunch, or dessert and pairs perfectly with coffee or tea. Its rich composition helps it stay fresh and moist, making it convenient for the recipient. * Give wrapping available if added to order. Available for shipping, pickup, or delivery. 📦 Allergen Information: Contains eggs, soy, nuts, and dairy.
$20.00
click for description
Cinnamon Roll Glazed (4 Jumbo Size)🔥 (Fan Favorite)
Freshly baked cinnamon sweet rolls are a comforting treat, and Polly’s is no different. They are known for their soft, fluffy texture, a rich aroma of warm spices, and a gooey, buttery cinnamon-sugar filling. They are topped with a luscious sweet glaze. Available for shipping, pickup, or delivery. 📦 *Shipping Note: Cinnamon rolls shipped will arrive unfrosted and include an icing packet. You will be able to warm your cinnamon rolls in the oven, then frost them with the frosting packet that is included.  Made with organic ingredients, including; flour, sugar, cinnamon, & eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs
$18.00
click for description
6” Groom’s Cake (Serves 12 Guests)
Golf themed cake available in three flavors. The golf ball is molded out of white chocolate. The Pin/flag is not edible. Available for pickup or delivery. Allergen: Contains eggs, soy, and dairy.
$110.00
click for description
Sourdough Starter (Dehydrated)
From the mother, a very active starter was dehydrated at precisely 95°F, so the yeast would be perfectly preserved for your kitchen. Complete instructions are included with a food safe bag of starter. It should take 5 days from reactivating until the beginning of your sourdough journey. Polly has personally tested this starter and it took her three days to get to an active starter consistency.
$20.00
click for description
Game Changer! Nostalgic With Organic Cinnamon & Raisins Sourdough
Sourdough with organic cinnamon and raisins is a popular variation of a classic sourdough loaf that combines the signature tangy flavor and chewy texture of naturally leavened bread with the warm, aromatic spice of cinnamon and bursts of sweetness from plump, juicy raisins. The natural fermentation process of the sourdough starter provides a subtle, complex tang that acts as a sophisticated counterpoint to the natural sweetness of the raisins and the warmth of the cinnamon. The addition of cinnamon infuses the entire loaf with a cozy, inviting aroma and flavor, which is enhanced when the bread is toasted. The loaf features a classic sourdough crust that is golden, crunchy, and craggy, sometimes with a slightly reddish hue from the organic cinnamon. The interior is soft, airy, and chewy, studded throughout with plump raisins that offer occasional pops of a soft, juicy texture. Serving Suggestions This versatile bread is a comforting treat for any time of day. It is often enjoyed: - Toasted and slathered with butter or cream cheese. - Eaten fresh as a snack. - Used to make exceptional French toast or bread pudding. - Overall, cinnamon raisin sourdough is a harmonious blend of savory and sweet, offering a heartwarming and wholesome eating experience that makes a kitchen smell amazing while it bakes.
$15.00
click for description
Chocolate Covered Oreos (One Dozen) 🔥 (Fan Favorite)
Please indicate two chocolate colors. It would be helpful if you included a party invitation and/or provided the theme inspiration. personalized icing sheets are a six week minimum prepaid order. Available for pickup or delivery. Not suitable for shipping.
$55.00
click for description
Sourdough Chocolate Chip Banana Bread (Mini Loaf) 🔥 (Fan Favorite)
Freshly baked banana bread with chocolate chips has a moist, tender texture and a rich, fragrant aroma. The classic, comforting flavor of ripe bananas is elevated by the sweet, gooey pockets of melted chocolate chips found in every bite. Available for shipping, delivery, & pickup. 📦 Made with organic ingredients. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs
$10.00
click for description
Honey & Oat Sourdough
Honey oat sourdough is a hearty, flavorful bread that blends the characteristic tang of a sourdough starter with the subtle sweetness of honey and the wholesome texture of rolled oats.
$15.00
click for description
Ginger Oatmeal Cookie (Half Dozen) (Gluten-Friendly, Nut Free, & Sourdough)
A soft and chewy oatmeal cookie infused with the flavor of fall. Disclaimer: Our cookies are made using gluten-free ingredients, but they are prepared in a shared kitchen that also handles wheat. We cannot guarantee a 100% allergy-free environment for individuals with severe celiac disease. Available for shipping, delivery, or pick up. Allergen Information: Eggs & dairy.
$20.00
click for description
Cupcake Bouquet (3, 7, 12, or 19 Cupcakes)
🌸 The Cupcake Floral Bouquet Give a gift that tastes as beautiful as it looks. Our floral bouquet features standard-sized cupcakes transformed into a breathtaking arrangement of realistic buttercream blossoms. It is the ultimate show-stopping gift for birthdays, milestones, and seasonal celebrations. The bouquet comes in an arrangement of three, seven, 12, or 19 cupcakes. The cupcakes are $10 each. Please add the number of cupcakes you would like in your order. Unfortunately, due to their delicate nature, this item is not shippable. But they are available for delivery or pick up. 👟🛻
$15.00
click for description
Pumpkin Spice Tea Ring (Serves 8-10) 🌟 (Seasonal Favorite)
The pumpkin spice ring is a beautiful, show-stopping sweet bread. Perfect for sharing with friends and family. The drizzle is a lovely maple icing (nut free). *Gift wrapping available. Available for shipping, pickup, or delivery. 📦 *Shipping Note: The 1929 ring shipped will arrive unfrosted and include an icing packet. You will be able to warm your ring in the oven, then frost it with the frosting packet that is included. Allergen: Contains eggs, soy, and dairy.
$30.00
click for description
Bread Bundle & Gift Set
This gift set included a freshly baked loaf of your choice, a bread knife and cutting board, and a bread bag, all beautifully displayed in a reusable basket. Pickup, delivery, or shipping available. 📦
$50.00
click for description
Funfetti Birthday Cookie
A buttery cookie loaded with Funfetti. You can’t help but smile. 😊 Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs
$6.00
click for description
Gingerbread Snickerdoodle Cookie 🌟 (Seasonal Favorite)
The comfort of cinnamon and gingerbread in cookie form. It is stuffed with cinnamon cereal and white chocolate chips. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Dairy, Soy, & Eggs
$6.00
click for description
Rosemary & Roasted Garlic Sourdough
Roasted garlic and rosemary sourdough is an aromatic, savory artisan bread that combines the classic tangy flavor and chewy texture of natural leavened sourdough with the mellow sweetness of roasted garlic and the fragrant, earthy notes of fresh rosemary. Polly’s loaf boasts a crispy, golden, and crackly crust that often makes a distinctive sound when sliced into. Baking in a Dutch oven helps achieve this texture. The inside is soft, airy, and chewy, characteristic of well-made sourdough, and is dotted with chunks or mashed pockets of the soft, caramelized roasted garlic and specks of green rosemary leaves. The slow fermentation process of the sourdough starter provides a subtle, complex tang that complements the savory additions. The garlic, when roasted, loses its sharp pungency and develops a sweet, mild, and creamy flavor that permeates the loaf. Fresh rosemary adds a woodsy, herbaceous, and slightly piney taste and aroma. Serving Suggestions: This versatile loaf can be enjoyed in many ways. - Warm with a simple spread of butter or a drizzle of olive oil. - Alongside hearty dishes like beef stew or pasta. - Used for gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches. - Toasted as part of a charcuterie board. The bread's robust flavor profile makes it a popular choice for entertaining or elevating everyday meals.
$15.00
click for description
White Chocolate Chip Cookie (Gluten-Friendly, Nut Free, & Sourdough)
A white chocolate chip cookie stuffed with white chocolate cream. Disclaimer: Our cookies are made using gluten-free ingredients, but they are prepared in a shared kitchen that also handles wheat. We cannot guarantee a 100% allergy-free environment for individuals with severe celiac disease.
$6.00
click for description
Pumpkin Spice Cookie 🌟 (Seasonal Favorite)
All the flavors of fall and winter wrapped up in a cookie, stuffed full of chocolate chips, pumpkin purée, cinnamon, and pumpkin spice. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Flour, Soy, Dairy, Nuts, & Eggs
$6.00
click for description
Cream Filled Sandwich Vanilla (Half Dozen)
The most scrumptious cakes with fluffy frosting between the layers and hand-dipped in white chocolate then garnished with Funfetti. Available for pickup, or delivery. With the Florida heat, we are unable to ship.  Allergen: Contains eggs, soy, and dairy.
$36.00
click for description
Frosted Brownie (8”x8” Pan)
Polly’s sourdough brownie with creamy ganache frosting is a deeply decadent dessert that balances intense chocolate richness with a subtle, tangy complexity. Made with melted butter, Dutch-process cocoa powder. The ganache is a rich, glossy coating that sets over the brownie, adding another layer of creamy texture to the fudgy base. Made with organic flour, organic sugar, & organic eggs. Allergen: Wheat, Soy, Dairy, & Eggs
$25.00
click for description
From the Arctic to Your Table the Story of Polly Carter
Polly Carter's sourdough isn't just bread —it's a legacy born in the remote village of Nome, Alaska. Raised with the rhythms of Inupiaq subsistence living, Polly's childhood was defined by the seasons: ice fishing in the winter, berry picking in the summer, and the constant, comforting aroma of fresh sourdough.
A Heritage of Resourcefulness
In a place where supply barges arrived only twice a year, "store-bought" wasn't an option. Polly learned the art of sourdough from her mother, who was born in a tent outside Noorvik. Together, they turned simple flour, water, and salt into the essential nourishment that sustained their family through long Arctic winters. From those early "bake days" filled with giant sweet rolls to years spent pressure-canning fish and picking tender willow leaves for salad, Polly developed a deep respect for food that nourishes both the body and the soul.
Honest, Wholesome Ingredients
Today, Polly carries that same spirit of resilience and tradition into every loaf she bakes. Her commitment to real food means:
• No Preservatives: Only ingredients you can actually pronounce.
• No Shortcuts: Hand-mixed and slow-fermented for authentic flavor.
• Time-Honored Techniques: Artisan methods passed down through generations.
"Baking is more than bread—it's legacy, tradition, and a gift shared from my table to
yours." - Polly Carter
Shipping, Delivery, or Pickup Available. 📦
Homemade with real ingredients by a real person. We are committed to using organic ingredients whenever possible. We use imported Italian flours shipped directly from Italy. 100% Italian grains, Non-GMO, Glyphosate-Free!
Bread:
🥖Sourdough Loaf ( perfect for grilled sandwiches & toast)
🥖Sandwich Bread
🥖Brioche (perfect for French toast)
Sweets:
🧁 Sweet Breads
🧁 Cakes & Pies
🧁Cookies
Pantry - From our Kitchen to your Table
🛒 Jams & Marmalade
🛒Pancake & Waffle Mix
🛒Dehydrated Starter
🛒Herb Dipping Seasonings
All pricing is in US currency (USD).
Shipping via USPS. Some menu items may not be suitable for shipping. Shipping cost based on weight and size of box.
The pickup window is Friday from 1pm-7pm. If pickup is not completed by date indicated, order is considered forfit.