Ratings & Reviews

At the 11th hour I was tasked with getting a cake for my daughter in law’s Sprinkle. Heather from Benny’s Bodega suggested calling To The Moon. Barbara was extremely helpful, following my suggestions and, under 48 hours later, handing me the most beautiful cake creation, not to mention delicious. My DIL was Over The Moon to say the least.

The cupcakes were very good, and the surprise jelly bite was wonderful. Thank you

I cannot recommend To the Moon and Back Cupcakery enough! She did an absolutely amazing job for my baby shower. She created a custom Ralph Lauren–themed cake, along with cupcakes and cookies, and everything was beyond perfect. The details on the cookies were flawless—you could tell so much care and precision went into every single piece. Not only did everything look stunning, but it tasted just as amazing. She was so easy to work with, super responsive, and truly brought my vision to life. The entire dessert display tied the theme together beautifully and received so many compliments from our guests. Thank you for making my baby shower extra special. I would absolutely use her again and highly recommend her for any event!

Barb is a true artist and you get your money’s worth. Definitely returning and recommending

Cannot say enough about how great not only the cookies were, but also Barb. She was so patient with me and helped me pick out the perfect cookies for my son’s engagement. Cannot wait to order again!!!

In love with my cake! 😍 Thank you so much! Such a great surprise! ☺️🥰

They were perfect. Many thanks! 🤠

Barb made my Pinterest dream cakes come to life! Absolutely loved them both and they were so delicious! Highly recommend!!

Everyone loved the cupcakes♥️🧁

Won the free birthday cake from Benny’s Bodega and I couldn’t believe what I picked up. I was expecting a basic birthday cake but Barb listened when I was talking about my daughter’s birthday and created a cake that matched her theme to a tee! I was so surprised I didn’t expect that. And it was so delicious too! If you get a chance to order from To The Moon and Back Cupcakery, just know you will not be disappointed!

I found To the Moon & Back Cupcakery by chance. Saw the reviews and knew I wanted my daughter's engagement cake to be from here. The cake was pure perfection in every aspect! Delicious, beautiful, so close to the inspiration photo and moist. And the icing? OMG! So incredibly delicious and not that super sweet concoction. Barb definitely uses quality ingredients & it shows!

In love with our cake! Thank you so much! 😍🥰

Barbara, your gorgeous cupcakes were a huge hit all around! You stepped up when I reached out last minute & I'm so grateful!

One word incredible . The presentation of the cake and cookies were not only beautiful but delicious . Everyone wanted to know who did the cake . I only hope she will now be able to do all my family events now that the word is getting out . Give her a try you will not be disappointed

The cake was absolutely beautiful!!!!

So I ordered myself a beautiful cupcake bouquet! It certainly did not disappoint! The cookie butter cake (my all time favorite) delicately covered with the most beautiful flowers adored these mouth watering beauties! I am blown away each and every time I order a special dessert! If I could add a picture to this post, you all would be amazed! Thank you Barb! This was the perfect gift from me to me!!

Ordered cookies for my daughter’s 7th birthday. The cookies tasted amazing and were exactly what I asked for! Will be ordering again

The cake was amazing and so was Barbara! Thank you again!

It was a pleasure working with Barb on our cupcake order. She is very creative and made cupcakes that fit perfectly with our theme, looked great, and everyone enjoyed them!

I am so glad I placed my order with to the moon and back cupcakery! These were perfect and so delicious! I definitely won't be ordering from any anyone else.

Everything was wonderful! Thank you!!!

Amazing cookies! Thank you!

The party was a success and thanks to you, the cake and cupcakes were as delicious as ever! Dessert was loved by each and every person! Thank you again Barb!

Okay, I have to talk about these s’mores macarons from To The Moon and Back Cupcakery… because wow. First of all, they’re gorgeous. But then you take a bite—and it’s over. Completely irresistible, 10/10. I’m already planning my next order!

Delicious and beautiful

I reached out to this amazing home bakery last minute—and when I say last minute, I mean “I-should-have-planned-this-a-week-or-more-ago” last minute. Not only did they say yes, but they knocked it out of the park! The cookies were perfectly decorated, the cake was stunning (and delicious!), and the whole process was smooth and stress-free. You would never know this order was a rush—everything looked thoughtful, detailed, and made with love. I’m beyond impressed and so thankful they were able to fit me in. If you need sweet treats that taste as good as they look, To The Moon and Back Cupcakery is the home baker to call—even in a pinch! Highly, highly recommend.

The cake was moist and delicious. But those flowers, truly amazing! Anyone looking for unique, delicious and beautiful baked goods should definitely check out this amazing lady. I promise you will not be disappointed.

Everything was beyond perfect. The cupcakes were fluffy and moist and the frosting was delicious - not overly sweet like most frostings are. And the cookies - we hated eating them as they were little works of art. If you’re looking for a baker who takes pride in her work and uses the best ingredients To The Moon and Back Cupcakery should be the only baker you call, once you have one of her treats you’ll never order from any where else

From design to flavor, everything exceeded our expectations. We ordered a 2 tier cake, cupcakes and decorated sugar cookies. You can tell everything is made with so much love and care. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this home baker a thousand times over. If you’re looking for beautiful and delicious treats that will wow your guests, look no further!

Barb is so easy to work with and the cookies look and taste great!!!

My daughter's dance studio used this bakery to sell cookies for their recital. The cookies came out great and look awesome! My daughter loved them!

I had ordered the custom cookies for the Dance Expressions dance recital. Great price and great taste! They were the cutest cookies as well!! Highly reccomend!

My daughter loved the dance theme cookies we ordered for the recital! They were so nicely packaged and delicious!!

Everyone raved about your cupcakes!

Barb did an amazing job on a rush order of cookies after I was disappointed with cookies from another baker. She was communicative, helpful, and took the time to make sure I would be pleased with the outcome of the cookies. Highly recommend!

Thank you again so much for such a beautiful cake and gesture. This means a lot. She loved it. 🥰 her first words were “it’s my favorite color” It was delicious wow.

I was one of the lucky people who got to take these delicious and gorgeous cupcakes home! The flavor and texture equaled the beauty. It might be hard to believe, but they were even more beautiful in person🩷🩵💛

Ordered a custom cake for my son’s 10th birthday. He woke up very sick the day before his party. He didn’t want to reschedule, but by midday, I made the call to delay the party by 2 weeks. Barb was so easy to work with rescheduling the party!! Had the party today…his cake was exactly what I had envisioned and was soooooo good!!! Highly recommend!!!

The cake Barb made was absolutely amazing. So beautiful we did not want to eat it. It was moist and delicious as well. She is very talented and professional and thorough as far as design input. will definitely order from her again next occasion. Thank you so much

I finally got to relax and sample one of the shower cookies. Just wanted to let you know that not only were they beautiful but they are also delicious! You never disappoint. Thanks again Barb 🩵🩷

Barbara made a custom Frozen-themed cake for my three-year-old’s birthday, and it was delicious and beautiful! Even my husband who hates frosting and isn’t crazy about cake in general (despite being a chef) said it was great!

They have exceeded our expectations!! Our guests cannot get enough of them!! Thank you🤍⚡️

The cake was absolutely delicious.!! My husband and I just ate another piece 😊 Thank you again!! I will definitely recommend you!!

Thank you for such a stunning cake! You really did an amazing job and I'm so thankful we chose you! 🤍

They were perfect!!Thank you!

My daughter and all of us enjoyed your cupcakes, both their beautiful design and taste. They were very special. Thank you

I will never order From anyone else! It’s always so difficult you will find a place that makes beautiful cakes and sweets, but they taste horrible or the decorating is not very good but they taste delicious. Honestly, this is the best of both worlds. Take my word for it!!

Thank you so much! Everything is beautiful! And Isla loves it!

Well! You never cease to amaze. Everything was wonderful! The cupcakes were outrageous! Not sure what you put in them but I should have ordered 2 dozen more!!! Such a success! Thanks Barb!! What a terrific 2nd birthday!!

The party was an absolute success! Our little mermaid absolutely loved her cookies and cupcakes! She said," look GaGa!, that mermaid is me!" I said, yes, indeed she is! Thank you, thank you, thank you, Barb!! Another successful party, thanks to; To The Moon and Back Cupcakery !! Can't wait for the Minnie party next! Lol

Cupcakes and cookies were awesome that I ordered from you.

To all those out there gazing at these beautiful creations, let me just tell you from my own experience, these desserts are absolutely, positively amazing!! The variety of cake flavors, fillings and the intricately detailed piping and decorations are so far superior than any brick and mortar bakery that I have ever experienced. I can promise, once you try it, you'll be hooked, just like we are!!! I cannot recommend To The Moon and Back Cupcakery enough! Everyone deserves some sweetness in their lives!! Live it up! Order a cake or two!

So cute and delicious!

Barb, again you totally amaze me and all our guests! The cookies were incredibly delicious and the cupcakes were devine!!! Our tiny dancer was so excited with them all! Thank you, thank you, thank you! Our dance debut was a success and the dessert finally was out of this world!

I ordered cookies for our daughter’s recitals and they were not only beautiful but so delicious! Even the packaging was gorgeous! Will definitely be ordering again in the future.

Gave these as a sweet reminder for daughter’s recital. Was very eloquently done. Could smell the sweet vanilla as soon as you opened box.

We ordered cookies for our daughters recital. They were delivered as promised. They looked even better than the pictures we chose from. They were also very delicious! Great job! And we will definitely order again!!

I ordered custom sugar cookies for a baby shower and asked for a unique flavor— lemon poppyseed. Beautiful, delicious, and totally memorable. Couldn’t have asked for more!

Exquisite and Delicious! The most beautifully made cookies for a special birthday celebration. Highly recommended!!

They were a hit of the Baby Shower!!!! Thank you so much!!! And delicious too!!!

Ordered baby shower cookies and couldn’t believe how adorable they were, matched exactly to the theme. And they were so tasty. Definitely recommend Barb for any of your custom baked goods!

To The Moon and Back Cupcakery, well, the party is over and a success it was. The cake was absolutely amazing! The flavoring was so incredible! We all enjoyed every bite. So, so glad we have more cake for tomorrow! Awesome job! I'm going to have to make-up more occasions, just to order another cake! Thank you, thank you, thank you!

I ordered a cake for Valentine's Day, and let me tell you folks, it is totally amazing. The taste is fabulous and the artistry and attention to detail is incredible. So, how do I know it tastes amazing? Well, I couldn't wait for Valentine's Day, so we had to taste test and luckily we still have enough left for tonight!!! Can't wait for dessert!! Thank you Barb! Our family has so enjoyed. They can't wait for another!! Kudos to you and wishing you much success!!

Just received a custom and rushed order of cookies. Fantastic service and price, beautiful, yummy cookies. Can't recommend highly enough.

A big thank you to Barbara of To The Moon and Back Cupcakery for these delightful cookies (I am so sorry I did not take my own pictures)! They were such a big hit at my granddaughter's "Two Groovy" birthday party. Barbara went the extra mile in making sure they would be just right! Highly reccommend! ✌️☮️

The cookies were beyond what I had expected. She is an amazingly talented artist. The packaging was above and beyond. Everything was perfect. I almost don't want to eat them they look like art. Sooo happy that I placed my order. Will definitely be placing more orders.