Ratings & Reviews

Delicious cookies! 10/10 recommend

Megan’s cookies are the best you will ever have, hands down. I’ve ordered for my office twice now, and they rave about them!

My first order from The Sugar Reserve did not disappoint. They are dangerously good!! You can literally taste the love that is baked into them ... soft, chewy, rich, thick, delicious 😋 Every flavor is so good its impossible to pick a favorite. These cookies went FAST! Highly recommend - you will not be disappointed!!

Delicious! I can’t decide which kind is my favorite. Cookies are so moist and tasty!😋

Megan’s cookies are absolutely amazing. My kids love when I surprise them with a special treat and they get to try and new flavor! Our personal favorite is the Oreo!

I really just wanna leave this review to say, somebody has to find a recipe! There is no way these cookies supposed to be this good! The craftsmanship is already there, but for you to have a consistent ingredient where I can taste every flavor and every bite is beyond me! Cookies Butter and White Chocolate Churro! I will be ordering more flavors! I know there’s a calling on your life Megan🙌!

Every cookie I have tried has been absolute perfection, but the churro cookie? That thing is to die for. I will slap a decrepit grandma for that cookie. I highly recommend this company. Flexible timeframes, the cookies are consistent and always amazing. Chef’s kiss!

I honestly don’t know where to start but to say that if you order 12, beware because you’re probably going to eat all 12 in one sitting. These cookies are absolutely delicious. The white chocolate churro are especially chefs kiss. I honestly skipped a lunch just so I could justify eating more cookies. Just get them! You won’t be disappointed.

Serious, these are the best cookies. I unfortunately could eat a dozen in one sitting 😂 her seasonal flavors are to die for 🙌🏼

Megan does not mess around with her cookies. It’s impossible to stop at one cookie. There are toppings and deliciousness in every bite. Place the order!!

I got these cookies for Valentine’s Day and they are by far the best cookies I have ever had. They are the perfect combination of ingredients… a must have for sure

I ordered cookies from The Sugar Reserve for my son’s teacher’s Valentine’s gift, and they were DELICIOUS!!! Not only were they delicious, but they were packaged beautifully. Megan is a joy to work with! 🤍

I ordered a dozen Valentine cookies from Megan and they were amazing!!! My family loved them. The texture and flavor was the best from the first bite to the last. I highly recommend you order from The Sugar Reserve. You won’t regret it!!!

Happy Valentines Day I couldn’t have been more pleased with my purchase I ordered two dozen cookies to share with friends for Valentine’s Day they were all individually wrapped and the taste was amazing I will definitely be ordering again on many occasions

The Sugar Reserve truly has some of the best cookies I’ve ever had. They’re soft and literally melt in your mouth. Every flavor I’ve tried has been delicious, and I honestly can’t pick a favorite. The owner is just as sweet as the cookies she bakes — kind and clearly passionate about what she does. If you love a really good cookie, you should definitely try The Sugar Reserve.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ If I could give **The Sugar Reserve** more than five stars, I absolutely would! Megan, the owner, is truly one of the sweetest, most genuinely kind people you’ll ever meet—she has the biggest heart and is so professional from start to finish. And then there are the cookies… WOW. I ordered **two mixed dozen boxes** and tried the Oreo, cookie butter, king cake, and white chocolate churro cookies, and oh. my. goodness. My taste buds were living their best life. The *texture alone* screams “perfect cookie,” but the flavors she creates take it to a whole other level. Every single bite was AMAZING. These cookies are next-level good, and I will 100% be ordering many more (and telling *everyone* I know to do the same). If you’re thinking about it—this is your sign. **Contact Megan today and order from The Sugar Reserve. You will not regret it!** 🍪🤍

The king cake cookies are amazing, they taste so good and look great too!

Megan did an outstanding job, from the beautiful presentation to the incredible flavor of the cookies. They were truly the best cookies I have ever had!

The Sugar Reserve has the most incredible cookies! I got the chocolate chip- a classic that are so elevated, and the cookie butter which are to die for! They’re also husband approved, so of course I’ll be reordering. You need to order some now before Megan gets too busy!

Not only was pick up so fast! The cookies were the most delightful treat ever! They were full of flavor, soft texture that was mouth watering! Also the packaging was so fancy!

These cookies are absolutely amazing! I am a connoisseur of cookies! I love to make them & eat them! Megan’s cookies were a big hit at Christmas! She had all the combinations perfect! A flavorful cookie, so moist, and such a variety of flavors, all packaged so professionally! My favorite was the chocolate chip cookie & I dare say it was the best I had ever eaten! You will want to sample them all & then come back for more!

These are the absolute BEST cookies I have EVER had. They are so moist and fresh tasting. They outshine crumbl cookies every day of the week! With so many amazing flavors to try, they keep me coming back week after week. Megan was so easy to work with regarding making choices and answering my questions. Can’t recommend The Sugar Reserve enough!

At our family gathering, these cookies were an absolute sensation—relatives were slyly stashing them away in their purses, worried they’d vanish before anyone could grab more. That’s the ultimate testament to how incredibly delicious they are!!! Do yourself a favor and order the cookie butter and also the chocolate chip! Those are my personal favorites!!

First of all, this is seriously the best cookie I’ve ever had. If you love a churro, GET IT. These are a churro in cookie form, but honestly way better than a churro. Don’t think, just add to cart☑️

You may be thinking this is just your basic chocolate chip cookie… think again! This cookie is better than your granny’s homemade chocolate chip cookie. I’m not even over exaggerating y'all! My husband is picky about cookies and he said, “This is by far the best chocolate chip cookie I’ve ever had.”

I have tried every single flavor, and they are all seriously next level! I have always placed my next order. Don't think, just order!

Dense, moist, and delicious!!! The chunks of chocolate, the little crunch from the biscoff cookie bits, and the drizzle on top.. these cookies are perfection; can’t wait to see what other flavors she comes out with! 10/10