Featured Products
One Dozen Cookies (2 Flavors)
Get the best of both worlds by selecting up to two flavors of our featured cookies! (Price ranges from $30-$36 depending on your flavor choices.) *Ingredients for each flavor can be found within their own section of our menu. *All cookies contain allergens: eggs, wheat and dairy *Our cookies are NOT gluten, sugar or dairy free.
Starting at $30.00
click for description
Oreo Crumb
This fan-favorite is an Oreo lover’s dream! It is infused with crushed Oreos, then packed with even MORE chopped Oreos. Ingredients: Flour, granulated sugar, brown sugar, Oreo cookies, butter, eggs, corn starch, baking soda, salt, vanilla extract Contains wheat, eggs and dairy *Our cookies are NOT gluten-free, dairy free or sugar free *All cookies weigh 2oz.
$30.00
click for description
Cookie Butter
Our white chocolate chip cookie packed with crushed biscoff cookies, and drizzled with creamy cookie butter! Ingredients: Flour, granulated sugar, brown sugar, white chocolate chips, Biscoff cookies, Biscoff cookie butter, butter, eggs, corn starch, baking soda, salt, vanilla extract Contains wheat, eggs and dairy *Our cookies are NOT gluten-free, dairy free or sugar free *All cookies weigh 2oz. each
$36.00
click for description
Classic Chocolate Chip
A CLASSIC… & my personal favorite cookie! Our semi-sweet chocolate chip cookie is simple, but so, SO good! Ingredients: Flour, granulated sugar, brown sugar, semi-sweet chocolate chips, butter, eggs, corn starch, baking soda, salt, vanilla extract Contains wheat, eggs and dairy *Our cookies are NOT gluten-free, dairy free or sugar free *All cookies weigh 2oz. each
$30.00
click for description
White Chocolate Churro
Our best seller! This is a cinnamon cookie packed with white chocolate chips and dusted with cinnamon sugar. Ingredients: Flour, granulated sugar, brown sugar, white chocolate chips, cinnamon, butter, eggs, corn starch, baking soda, salt, vanilla extract Contains wheat, eggs and dairy *Our cookies are NOT gluten-free, dairy free or sugar free *All cookies weigh 2oz. each
$30.00
click for description
Banana Pudding
Our seasonal cookie flavor, banana pudding, isn’t your grandma‘s traditional dish! It’s a banana pudding-based cookie, infused with Nilla wafers, packed with white chocolate chips, drizzled with more white chocolate, and topped with a whole Nilla wafer. It’s truly the cookie of our cookout dreams and will be the star of any family gathering! *Only here for a limited amount of time. 🍌🍪* Ingredient list: granulated sugar, brown sugar, flour, butter, Jell-O banana pudding, Nilla wafers, white chocolate chips, corn starch, eggs, vanilla extract, baking soda and salt (Cookies are 2oz each)
$36.00
click for description
About
Hi! My name is Megan Kozell and I am the owner and head baker of The Sugar Reserve. ✨🫶🏼🍪 I’m so glad that you’re here! I am a proud wife, dog mom, Christian & School Social Worker in addition to being a cookie baker. ⭐️ What started out as a creative outlet has now turned into a full-blown business! I love to bake, but I love hearing the words “This is the best cookie I’ve ever had!,” even more.
Thank you so much for your order and for supporting my dreams! I am so grateful!
Capabilities & Pricing
*Cookies are sold by the dozen, starting at $30.00 per box, unless we are running a special promotion. Single cookies can be purchased at pop-up events, Echo Coffee in Pensacola FL , and local vendor markets.
*Order forms must be submitted by Monday to get your cookies by Wednesday. Orders placed after Monday will be fulfilled on the following Wednesday. Full payment is due upon receiving the invoice.
*Pace or Pensacola pick-up every Wednesday unless previously discussed. (We are not able to offer shipping at this time.)