Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
Custom Sugar Cookies Personalized. Delicious. Almost too pretty to eat (but you totally should). These soft-centered, crisp-edged sugar cookies are made to match your theme, colors, or occasion—from birthdays and weddings to baby showers and everything in between. Each cookie is decorated by hand with care, creativity, and a whole lot of heart. Choose from classic almond vanilla, chocolate, or vanilla, with optional add-ons like airbrushing, embossing, or custom sprinkle colors. Custom orders require advance notice—because good things take time (and butter).
Starting at $62.00
click for description
Hi, I’m Vicky! A licensed cottage food baker and stay-at-home mom in Central Maine. 🍪 At The Frosted Crumb, I create cookies made for celebrating—custom decorated sugar cookies designed to make life’s special moments a little sweeter.
Most orders are booked at least 2 weeks in advance, so be sure to reach out early! I’m currently accepting just one custom order per week, and dates are reserved on a first-paid, first-served basis. Spots are not held without payment.
Custom decorated cookies start at $62 per dozen, with final pricing based on design complexity.
Invoices are due within 48 hours to secure your order.
Be the first to know about presales, last minute availability, and upcoming cookie drops… before they sell out. Subscribe to my newsletter.
Frostedcrumbcookies.eo.page
Choose the tier that matches your vision.
Bring on the colors and designs — that’s the fun part! I don’t charge extra for how many colors or designs you choose. Pricing is determined by the detail level of the cookies.
🍪 Classic Crumb - $62/dozen
Classic Crumb features clean designs with smooth icing and simple details — perfect for modern, minimal sets.
• Basic shapes
• Smooth flood icing
• Simple piping (dots, lines, minimal writing)
• Stenciled or printed designs
• 1–2 icing layers
Ideal for birthdays, baby showers, teacher gifts, and events where you want something polished, playful, and beautifully simple 🍪✨
—
🍪 Elevated Crumb - $75/dozen
Elevated Crumb includes layered designs, hand-piped detail, and subtle metallic accents — more detailed than simple, but not over the top.
• Layered icing designs
• Hand-piped details and textures
• florals, and icons
• Subtle dimension and pattern work
• Light gold painting or metallic accents
• 1-3 icing layers
Ideal for themed parties, milestone celebrations, and sets that feel polished, intentional, and just a little fancy ✨
—
🍪 Signature Crumb - $90/dozen
My most detailed and labor-intensive tier. Signature Crumb is where cookies become true statement pieces. This tier includes highly detailed designs, advanced techniques, and custom artwork that make your set the star of the table.
Signature Crumb cookies may include:
• Logo cookies
• Character cookies
• Intricate hand-piped details
• Painted elements and fine line work
• Metallics, airbrushing, and layered dimension
• 1-4 icing layers
Perfect for bold themes, character sets, and orders that call for a serious wow factor. ✨
Character cookies always fall under this tier.
—
ADD-ONS
- Filler cookies - Simple, 3" round cookies that complement your custom set. They're decorated in one solid color per cookie-using 1 to 3 colors from your set. $30/dozen
- Cookie bags tied with gift bows $6/dozen
🍪 Character cookies are available in half-dozen increments and can be paired with other cookie tiers. Signature Crumb detail pricing applies.
🍪 3 Flavors: Classic Almond Vanilla, Vanilla and Chocolate
🍪 1 dozen minimum order
A Sweet Surprise from The Frosted Crumb
The Birthday Batch is a fun way for The Frosted Crumb Cookie Co. to celebrate our local Maine community, one birthday at a time!
Each month, one local birthday person will be randomly selected to receive half a dozen decorated sugar cookies, completely free.
Know someone with a birthday coming up? Nominate a friend, family member, coworker, neighbor, or even yourself!
How It Works
Nominations open one month in advance.
For example, nominations for October birthdays will open during September.
The only requirement for nomination is having a birthday during the specified month.
There’s no special reason someone needs to be nominated. If they have a birthday that month and you’d love to see them receive some birthday cookies, that’s reason enough!
Each person receives ONE entry.
A nominee may be nominated by more than one person, but multiple nominations will not increase their chances of being selected. Each eligible nominee will be entered into the drawing once so everyone has an equal chance.
One recipient will be selected at random.
After nominations close, all eligible names will be entered into a random drawing. The recipient is not selected based on the number of nominations, or any other criteria.
🍪 What They’ll Receive
The selected birthday person will receive half a dozen decorated sugar cookies at no charge.
The Frosted Crumb will have creative freedom over the final cookie designs. The recipient may provide their:
• Name
• Age
• Favorite colors
• A few hobbies, interests or favorite things
These details will be used as inspiration, but specific designs, characters, themes or replicas of other cookie sets are not guaranteed. All themes and design requests must be appropriate and are subject to The Frosted Crumb’s discretion.
The Birthday Batch is a complimentary surprise and is separate from The Frosted Crumb’s regular custom-order service.
📍 Pickup
Local pickup in Winslow, Maine is required. The Birthday Batch cannot be shipped.
Cookies may be available as early as the first Friday of the birthday month. If the recipient’s birthday falls later in the month, I’ll work with them to arrange a pickup closer to their birthday when possible.
All pickups must take place on a Friday evening or Saturday morning at an agreed-upon time.
Cookies are individually heat sealed and remain fresh for up to two weeks when properly stored at room temperature. If the birthday is further away, freezing instructions can be provided so the cookies can be saved for the celebration.
🎂 Additional Rules
• The nominee must have a birthday during the month specified in the nomination post.
• Nominations must be submitted during the stated nomination period and according to the instructions on the nomination post.
• There is no purchase necessary to nominate someone or be selected.
• Self-nominations are welcome.
• Each eligible nominee receives one entry, regardless of the number of nominations received.
• The selected recipient must be able to arrange local pickup in Winslow, Maine.
• The Birthday Batch has no cash value and cannot be exchanged for cash, store credit or another product.
• The complimentary cookies cannot be applied toward or substituted for an existing custom order.
• The Birthday Batch cannot be transferred to a different birthday month.
• If the selected recipient cannot accept the Birthday Batch or cannot meet the pickup requirements, another eligible nominee may be randomly selected.
• The Frosted Crumb Cookie Co. reserves the right to decline any requested theme or design.
🤍 Most Importantly…
The Birthday Batch is simply a fun way to celebrate birthdays and spread a little extra sweetness throughout our local community.
If someone has a birthday that month, they’re eligible. That’s it. 🤍
Whether you’re nominating your best friend, your mom, your coworker, your neighbor, your kiddo or yourself, everyone goes into the drawing with the same chance of being selected.
One local birthday. Half a dozen free cookies. Every month.
A Sweet Surprise from The Frosted Crumb. 🎂🍪
The Birthday Batch is hosted by The Frosted Crumb Cookie Co. and is not sponsored, endorsed, administered by, or associated with Facebook or Instagram.