Ratings & Reviews

I planned a last minute baby shower and knew I needed the frosted cookie jar’s cookies for guests. You won’t be disappointed with these custom cookies! Not only were they executed perfectly for the theme but they are delicious! Katie is so responsive, flexible with last minute orders and is so easy to work with! Highly recommend!

Best chocolate chip cookies ever! they are thick and very good and i cant eat just 1! lol so yes i have 2 at a time!

The cookies that Katie put together for my son and future daughter in laws engagement exceeded my expectations! The colors, design and quality of the cookies were top notch. I highly recommend her and plant to order again in the future! 💍

All I can say is WOW! The design, taste, customer service was all amazing. We will be ordering cookies for all future events. They were a hit and so amazing. I recommend ordering from Katie!!!

10/10 I will be using frosted cookie jar again the taste was amazing and so was the design I’m so happy with how everything turned out:)

Highly recommend going with frosted cookie jar for custom cookie needs. I was a maid of honor in charge of a joint summer camp themed bachelor/bachelorette. Katie was so easy to work with and the cookies were a show stopper!

Working with Katie was easy and our cookies came out looking EXACTLY like her mock ups. They were gorgeous and we couldn’t have been happier with them! Not to mention they are delicious!

First time ordering custom cookies for an event and Katie was great to work with! Final product turned out better than I could have expected and cookies were so yummy! Loved that Katie provided mockups and let me pick my designs, which was a plus as someone who doesn’t love surprises. All the mockups were inline with the inspo photos I provided! Will be ordering again in the future!

Cookies were tasty, fresh neatly designed, Katie is detailed, my order was finished on time and she is flexible. I was late to pick up due to heavy traffic ( was from watching a World cup game) and luckily she understood. Overall I will be ordering again

The cookies exceeded my expectations! Thank you so much!

I had these cookies ordered for my friend’s bridal shower, and I could not be more thrilled with the outcome of the design. My interactions with Katie how easy it was to pick up an order the way that she brought the inspiration and vision I had for these cookies to life is absolutely astronomical plus delicious! Would recommend for any special events or just a fun dinner with gals Katie was absolutely a dream to work with and will definitely be coming back!

Not only were these cookies tasty, they were decorated so beautifully!

The cookies were gorgeous and tasted amazing.

Katie creates beautiful masterpieces for your special occasion. I've used her multiple occasions and each time the guests have thoroughly enjoyed the cookies. The frosted sugar cookies don't just look good but taste absolutely delicious as well. The sea salt chocolate chip cookies are very tasty, leaving you wanting another one. Highly recommend.

The cookies were so realistic and exceeded my expectations! They were neatly packed and became the talk of the party. Would definitely order again. Thank you ❤️

I had been looking forward to this special order, and it exceeded all of my expectations. The cookies were absolutely stunning—some of the most beautiful and detailed cookies I have ever seen. Every single one was decorated with incredible care and attention to detail. Not only were they gorgeous, but they tasted amazing as well! Everyone at the party loved them. Honestly, they were so beautiful that I almost felt bad eating them. Thank you for your talent, creativity, and dedication. I highly recommend your work and will definitely order again in the future!

We got a lot of compliments from our friends about the sugar cookies! Katie made sure she made exactly what I wanted through lots of communication, and it was all so beautiful and delicious. I almost wish it wasn’t made of food so we can keep them all :) I highly recommend working with Katie, she is so talented and took away a lot of the stress that we felt around planning the baby shower!

Absolutely loved the Winnie the Pooh cookies for my baby shower! They were beautifully decorated, tasted amazing, and were a huge hit with all of our guests. Thank you for helping make our special day even more memorable. Highly recommend!

I have used Katie twice to make cookies for my elementary school staff. Both times she was communicative, quick to respond and the cookies were not only adorable, but delicious! I would definitely use her again.

KATIE. LITERALLY AMAZING!! First off - I feel like I’ve experienced sugar cookies not tasting great in the past BUT THESE - SOOOOOOO GOOD. Rich and creamy and melt in your mouth. I’ve even frozen a few and pulling one out once in awhile it still tastes the exact same! Secondly - the design and care that went into creating my set for my girls first party was immaculate. The vibrancy of the colors and multiple designs! Katie, you are so unbelievably talented and I will forever reccomend you <3 MY FAV SUGAR COOKIES

Katie was so easy to work with and brought my vision to life!! 🥹 Everyone at my shower loved the cookies and thought they were delicious 😊

My husband stopped by the valentines pop up and picked up a bucket of mini conversation heart cookies for our kiddo and she absolutely loved them! They were adorable, repeat customer!

We got our first cookies from the valentines pop up and wow! They are so good! We got mini confetti cookies. They were beautifully decorated and delicious. Can’t wait to place an order!

I stopped by Katie’s stand to pick up some goodies and they were incredible! Her designs are SO CUTE! 10/10 recommend.

These cookies are fantastic! They taste amazing and she really brings your vision to life. I worked with the Frosted Cookie Jar numerous times now and will always find a way to work them into any event I need. They are that amazing!!

My son has been obsessed with K-Pop Demon Hunters from Netflix, and we wanted to surprise him with themed cookies for his birthday party. They turned out PERFECT! This was our 3rd order from Katie and our favorite yet. Katie hadn’t seen the movie, but the attention to detail on the cookies was still outstanding and so true to the film. The cookies were a huge hit for his party. Thank you!

These cookies are beautiful and delicious. Couldn’t wait to eat these with the my grandchildren. I ordered special Mount Rainier Scenic Railroad cookies. The railroad was an excellent experience and custom cookies to celebrate was the perfect “cherry on top”! Everyone needs these cookies in their life!

The cookies turned out SO cute and so good. Katie is super easy to work with and makes sure everything is how you want it. Katie did an amazing job.

Katie’s cookies are always 5 ⭐️! They have been such a hit at every party we’ve ordered for. She’s super easy to work with and has implemented our design ideas to a T! Highly recommend!

We ordered custom Dino cookies for our twins first birthday! Safe to say they were a huge hit!! Katie goes above and beyond with her communication and to ensure every detail is perfect. We have also gone out of our way to pop up stands to buy more goodies and they were all delicious! We are definitely gonna keep going back for more!

I ordered spa and nail polish themed cookies for my daughter’s birthday party. The cookies were fabulous, adorable and delicious. The kids and parents loved them!! We worked together to create some fun designs. I will order for every event

100% recommend ordering custom sugar cookies from The Frosted Cookie Jar! Katie is so professional with her communication and does a great job with ensuring you are happy with all the little details that go into her designs. She was so kind to accept a late cookie order for my niece’s Two Sweet birthday party & absolutely killed it! We were so happy with how they turned out. Will definitely be ordering from her again!

We had the pleasure of working with this amazing local micro bakery for Sultan High School's production of The Addams Family musical, and they truly went above and beyond! On very short notice, she created a batch of beautifully decorated cookies that absolutely wowed our cast, crew, and audience. The designs perfectly matched the spooky, whimsical theme of the show—every detail was thoughtful and incredibly well-executed. Not only were the cookies stunning to look at, but they were also delicious. You could tell they were made with care and quality ingredients. The Frosted cookie was a dream to work with—friendly, responsive, and totally committed to making sure everything was just right. We’re so grateful for her support of the arts and can’t recommend them highly enough! Thank you again for your talent and generosity! We will be returning customers.

I have gone to The Frosted Cookie twice now for cookies and they never disappoint!

First of all, Katie does an excellent job with communication, professionalism, and more! Her cookies are absolutely outstanding. We have gotten a few from her now and they are got devoured instantly! Her creativity is amazing and she consistently blows us out of the water with the ideas she comes up with. We can can’t wait to have her do our daughter’s cookies for her birthday in July!

Katie went above and beyond with her cookies, beautiful presentation, tasty and delicious.

The Frosted Cookie Jar exceeded all of my expectations for my order. The communication was excellent. The taste of the cookies was amazing. But the design far exceeded my expectations. 10/10 recommend ordering from them!

I will be ordering again, these are so delicious and I highly recommend to anyone that is wanting yummy cookies! The designs are awesome, and the cookie flavors are the best!!

Cookies were very fresh! great flavor! and looked beautiful! I would recommend to everyone for all holidays, birthdays, weddings! will order again!