Ratings & Reviews

I purchased a 4” smash cake for daughter’s first birthday. It was beautiful designed and fit the theme perfectly. It was yummy, soft, and just the right amount of sweet. I am repeat customer and I will keep coming back!

Loved my cake! Ordered for a photoshoot and the cake turned out amazing. Sarah made communication super easy and was able to help with bringing my idea to life!

Cake was absolutely amazing, decorated beautifully. Sarah was so nice and communicated amazingly. Would definitely recommend and will be ordering cakes and deserts from her again!

I ordered a smash cake and cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday. The ordering process was so easy! Sarah made sure she understood my request and absolutely nailed it! Everything is so pretty and turned out amazing. I definitely recommend The Cupcake Cottage!

Sarah at Cupcake Cottage surpassed our expectations with a vintage heart cake for our daughter’s 14th birthday. The details and color matching were spot on and beyond what we hoped. Our family highly recommends her work and professionalism. She is easy to work with and took our inspiration cake and made it so much better! We couldn’t be happier with what we received.

They were delicious! Wonderful customer service with easy pick up! Just ordered chocolate covered strawberries and can’t wait to eat them! So nice to have a baker that focuses on dye free wholesome treats I can feel good about giving to my kiddos!

Sarah did an amazing job on making my daughter’s Barbie cake. She only wanted this cake and Sarah made her dream come true. Thank you. Definitely recommend her

Sarah is the best! You never have to sacrifice taste for icky ingredients with her. Her treats are so delicious and you would never guess they are dye free! Her gluten free options are just as delicious too!

Very efficient to work with and so yummy! Those Christmas tree cakes are to die for! Thank you!

100% recommend. Tasty and so cute!

I ordered cupcakes for my 16-year-old daughter’s birthday. They weren’t just beautiful, but they were delicious! Definitely, we will be ordering again! Thanks 😊

Sarah made amazing cupcakes that had an adorable Rice Krispies lawnmower on top of a cupcake with icing that looked like grass. The guests loved it and I can’t wait to buy from her again!

thank you for making my vision come to life and for being so kind! will definitely be back ❤️

I ordered 2 dozen cupcakes for a baby shower and they did not disappoint! All I had to do was send photos of the theme and decor and the cupcakes matched perfectly. They tasted great and were nice and fluffy cupcakes. They were the perfect amount of sweetness after a nice savory dinner. Sarah is just the sweetest too! She reached out to me directly and kept me informed all throughout the process. Making payments was very easy and worth every cent! I definitely recommend her services and look forward to working with her in the future! <3

Absolutely adorable easy to work with understood my vision guests are already asking for her information!

I had an urgent need for a very specific cake and she had it ready the following day for me! It tasted amazing and looked amazing too.

These cupcakes are the MOST absolute AMAZING cupcakes I’ve EVER had!!!!!! You’re missing out if you don’t order from The Cupcake Cottage!!!!! Thank you SO much for bringing our vision to life!

I ordered a vintage heart cake for my roommate's engagement party and it was even prettier than what I initially sent in as an inspo pic. And it tasted delicious!!! Sarah was so sweet and an amazing communicator, will order again!

Amazing customer service and the cake is beautiful!

Just found out I was allergic to dairy and have been trying to find someone who makes dairy free treats and these did not disappoint! They are so GOOOD!! they taste like regular cinnamon rolls, I wouldn’t be able to tell a difference with ones with dairy. 10/10 recommend!!

The cupcake cottage made everything so easy and smooth for my daughter’s birthday. The cupcakes were so cute. They turned out better than the inspiration.

We ordered so many cupcakes for our business and Sarah did not disappoint! Amazing quality and flavor!

This cake was spot on for my daughter’s 13th birthday celebration! Sarah nailed it as always! As a mom I loved that it was made with dye free and the taste was still sweet and savory!

Absolutely amazing!! Delicious! Everyone raved about it. Can’t wait to get more. Love love LOVE! Made our special day even more sweet

The little bear cake Sarah made for my son’s first birthday was incredible! She is so kind and responsive and just an absolute joy to do business with. Cannot recommend her enough! Will for sure be ordering another cake from her!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Go get your sweet treats ASAP!! I recently ordered cookies from The Cupcake Cottage and they were a hit with the whole family! The peanut butter cookies were my personal favorite — soft, flavorful, and dye-free, which I really appreciated. My kids absolutely loved them! The chocolate chip and cookies & cream flavors were also amazing — perfectly baked and full of that homemade goodness. The adorable treat boxes were such a fun bonus and made everything feel extra special. Highly recommend The Cupcake Cottage for anyone looking for delicious, thoughtful treats!

We loved our cupcakes and smash cake and they came out soooo beautiful!!

Everyone loved them! And they were so pretty! Thanks so much to Sarah for putting time into the cupcakes

We got a cookies and cream cake for our daughter’s birthday and it was incredible! We had it decorated with some cute vintage florals and everyone loved it!

I ordered for my daughter’s birthday and the cake and cupcakes were a huge hit! I am looking forward to ordering for our next event!

We got the mini cupcakes and regular sized as well. It was a last minute order, and Sarah was wonderful! She worked with me to get our vision right for our themed birthday party! She was communicative, helpful, accommodating, reasonable, and so awesome! Plus the cupcakes were delicious! 5/5 stars ✨ highly recommend! We will be repeat customers for sure :)