Ratings & Reviews

I purchased cookie boxes from The Crafty Cookie to gift to my colleagues for Christmas. Everyone has said they are delicious and I’ve been asked by several people where the cookies were ordered from. I also appreciate how beautiful the intricate designs are and the fact that the owner took the time to put the cookies in pretty boxes with tulle ribbons — I am big on aesthetics and I really appreciate the attention to detail. I will definitely be ordering again!

Beautiful cake absolutely amazing work definitely put 100% into the order. Definitely amazing and will definitely order from her again

It was as beautiful as it was delicious! 10 out of 10 recommended! It was a last minute order and we could have asked for a more perfect cake!

Delicious and decorated for Christmas packaged beautifully. A nice gift for any occasion.

Her imagination is amazing Cake Amazing Customer Service Amazing This was the easiest cake ordering and pick up I’ve ever had.

I have tasted several of crafty cookie delicious desserts, cakes, cookies and more. Not only are they beautiful they are delicious 😋 I highly recommend them for every occasion 😋

We have princess cookies, cake, and cupcakes and Peter Rabbit cake, cookies, and cupcakes! Everything was AMAZING and sooo beautiful! Too cute to eat, almost!!

Everything is always wonderful to taste and beautiful to look at

Jennifer did an amazing job on our custom baby shower cookies! I shared a Pinterest inspiration photo with her, and she recreated them perfectly. They looked exactly like what I had envisioned. The attention to detail was incredible, and the cookies were just as delicious as they were beautiful. Her pricing was very reasonable, communication was great, and everything was delivered exactly as promised. I couldn’t have been happier and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for custom cookies for a special event!

I ordered cookies, cupcakes, cake pops and a sheet cake for my parents 60th anniversary party and very thing was beautiful and taste amazing , Jennifer was so easy to work with I definitely recommend and will be ordering again soon

The cake was beautiful and done as I asked per a picture I showed her! The taste was great too! Everyone loved it! Thank you soo much!! We appreciate you, especially during the holiday to get the cake done for us!

Love it! Just like the picture and as always, tastes great!

All are fantastic!

The cookie cake was amazing! So pretty and tasted even better! Would recommend to anyone and everyone!

I had ordered a cake for my grand daughter’s birthday. I know it was going to be difficult, but the crafty cookie done an amazing job! The cake is beautiful. The cake was so moist and delicious! Thank you for the amazing cake.

I sent an inspiration photo a grinch cake for my 2 year old daughter. The cake we received looked way better than the picture I sent in. And the taste of the cake was absolutely phenomenal! We will definitely be a repeat customer!

My daughter's 18th birthday cake tasted so good and looked so elegant thank you so much will definitely order more in the future

I purchased cookies for my daughter’s baby shower. We were able to customize the cookies with the colors of her theme which came out perfect. The detail was amazing! They were beautiful and tasted great!

Everything was so beautiful and tasted even better The cookies were printed and flawless end the cake was so moist and delicious

The cake was absolutely amazing, so moist and delicious and looked even better then my inspiration photo. I definitely recommend the crafty cookie for all your cakes I will definitely order again.

it was really good

The wedding cake was absolutely beautiful. Had it made for my grandson. They did a wonderful job.

The cake was absolutely delicious! The Biscoff cookie cream in the middle was so so good. The cake was also very moist. The cupcakes were a huge hit too! Everybody loved the cupcakes with honey drizzled on them. I will be ordering again in the near future!

The cake was identical to the picture I sent. It is perfect for my little girl’s birthday!

I have had several orders now from Jennifer and they are always beyond expectations in both flavor and presentation

The Crafty cookie does an amazing job. Thank you.

I cannot say enough amazing things about The Crafty Cookie!! We had a last minute cancellation for our order just before our baby shower and they were more than accommodating!! She pulled an all nighter just to fulfill our order. They are not only delicious, but could not have been more perfect!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!!

I was coming from out of town and needed a cake and was so pleased with how the owner worked in my order on such short notice. She also took time to ask me about how she could best personalize it so it was special for my loved one. The website was easy to navigate and I was very happy with cake!

Delicious and so well done!

Absolutely the best tasting cupcakes with cute designs just like I asked! Fast and great communication as well!

I just want to get on here and say that I highly recommend The crafty cookie, AKA Jennifer, for making our Wedding Cake. The cake she did for us was absolutely beautiful and it was delicious, so moist & the icing was perfect. She was also very sweet & easy to work with. I know that we were totally satisfied with her cake. Give her a try, you won’t be disappointed.

Highly recommend The CraftyCookie for any celebration you may be having. Jennifer goes up & beyond to please everyone on your special designs. The cookie we ordered is amazing. You will be pleased with all her specialties.

I have known Jenny for years. The cookies she made are beautifully done. I am so excited to share them with my church family.

100% recommend choosing the Crafty Cookie for your cake needs. Not only was the cake gorgeous it was absolutely delicious!

Delicious and beautifully decorated! Exactly what I ordered

We were referred by a friend and absolutely so please everything exceeded my expectations by far and was so delicious, I highly recommend the crafty cookie for all your goodie needs

The Crafty Cookie went above and beyond on our order for my son's first birthday! She was willing to change details last minute, easy and fast to communicate and the cake and cookies for absolutely delicious! Almost to pretty to eat!

She did it again. We have ordered from The Crafty Cookie numerous times and every time it is absolutely beautiful and absolutely the best tasting cake ever I highly recommend The Crafty Cookie.

The cake was absolutely breathtaking. Jennifer was wonderful.

Everything from ordering to pick up was great, the cake was amazing and very tasty, my son loved it.

This cake is amazing as usual, We have got several cakes from the crafty cookie all different flavors and all were delicious and absolutely beautiful the crafty cookie never disappoints she is a very talented person and so easy to work with. I highly recommend The crafty cookie for all treat needs

This cake was absolutely stunning and delicious! Every detail was amazing and so lifelike. I highly recommend The Crafty Cookie’s cakes.

She did a amazing job we love her work

Everything was wonderful and very accommodating to my needs!

Thank you! The cake and cooking look amazing! You are amazing!

I found out about the Crafty Cookie at the last minute and she was so helpful. I needed a cake for our class reunion and she did an excellent job. We are so happy with our cake and cupcakes

Beautiful cookies and cupcakes tasted great! She loved them!

Had a garden themed bridal shower and the custom cookies she made were beautiful! Exceeded my expectations. She listened to each thing I wanted and executed it perfectly.

Jennifer ALWAYS provides a top notch product, no matter what you are asking for. She goes the extra mile, even getting in a last minute request for a 2 tier cake for me.

Jennifer was very helpful in helping me figure out what would be best for our girls 1st birthday! She made two perfect smash cakes that our little girl devoured! I loved the array of cake flavors that she offered! Excellent work and price! Honestly, she could charge more!

Jennifer is the best! I sent her a design and the cookies were absolutely perfect!

I had a retirement cake made for my husband and it was exactly what I wanted. Not only was it perfect, it was delicious.

Jennifer made a ton of dessert items for our wedding including customized s’mores, pretzels, rice crispy treats, cake pops, m&m’s, and SO much more. They were such a hit we did not have a single one left at the end of the night!! Jennifer worked perfectly with our theme to make creative treats for our big day. Everyone is RAVING about the taste and appearance of the cocktail hour desserts. I cannot recommend the Crafty Cookie enough!

We were a little hesitant because she said she had never done this type cake before, but she blew it out of the ball park And made it look even better than the inspiration pic from Pinterest. 10/10 recommend and I'll definitely be a return customer.

This is a beautiful cake!!! We are very pleased.

Best chocolate cake I’ve ever had! Everyone at the party loved it!

If you are looking for an original one of a kind, amazing cake crafty cookie is who you want to do your cake not only do they taste so delicious. She can do practically anything you want. I have had three cakes made so far and everyone was beyond my expectations

Not only did the cake look amazing, it tasted AMAZING. Would definitely recommend! #supportsmallbusinesses

Cake turned out beautiful. Icing tasted like it had almond extract in it which wasn’t my favorite so will be sure to ask and make sure it’s plain vanilla buttercream for future orders.

The cookie cake is so delicious and the design was perfect!

This was the most beautiful cake I got so many compliments on the looks and the taste I highly recommend

Jennifer (Aka Crafty Cookie) exceeded all of my expectations & then some. Her site is very easy to follow and she’s great at communication and making sure everything turns out the way you want it. Our princess cake is the most STUNNING cake I’ve ever seen and who doesn’t love a cute crown to go with the special day! Will absolutely be ordering again in the future. Highly recommended her for your cakes and goodies ❤️

Jennifer does amazing work. This cake and others I've gotten have been beautiful and they taste great too.

This is the second time I've gotten cupcakes for my granddaughters to take to school for their friends for their birthdays, and they have been beautiful and tasted amazing both times I highly recommend The Crafty Cookie

She was able to exceed our expectations for a last minute cake for our son’s preschool graduation! The detail was amazing and tasted good as well!!

I contacted Jennifer last minute for a graduation cake for a reception at our church. This cake is absolutely beautiful. She went above and beyond to make it truly spectacular.

The cake was beautiful and was yummy!!

The cupcakes are beautiful! Would definitely order again

Loved the cupcakes. She does beautiful work. Highly recommend

These are absolutely amazing as everything I've ever got from The Crafty Cookie. Everything is always so beautiful and tastes so yummy.

The cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted even better! The cake topper and decorations were absolutely amazing!

Thank you the beautiful birthday cake and cupcakes they are amazing you do such a wonderful job

The cake was gorgeous and tasted so good , I will definitely be ordering again soon , highly recommended

Love this cake! It looked and tasted great. Would recommend the Crafty Cookie 100%

The cake was perfect!! It was just asking i ordered and my grandson loved it!! Highly recommend ordering a cake

The cake was fabulous!! Beautifully decorated, tasted even better! The photographer commented on how great it smelled and the kids even ate it after the baby smashed it they couldn’t resist. Highly recommend

Best cupcakes and cookies ever! Highly highly recommend! The owner was so kind and exceeded our expectations!

I have ordered from the crafty cookie several times and I have never been disappointed. She takes so much time to make sure everything is perfect, she gets the details so perfect and everything tastes so yummy . I highly recommend the crafty cookie for your special occasions.

My beautiful cookies were a hit at a local open house! Everyone was impressed with style and taste. I can't thank you enough! Dark N Dusty Mobile Bar Service.

She does a fantastic job! The frozen theme she did turned out so beautiful! My little girl was in awe and absolutely loved it!

My son is turning 4 this year, and every birthday I have had the best cookies, beautifully decorated to each theme I had for his party. I highly recommend!!!

My grandson's 1st birthday party was the talk of the town, once the cookies and cake were given out. I wish I had listened to myself and purchased more.

Jennifer is nothing short of amazing! With almost no notice, she created the most breathtaking Wicked-themed birthday cake for my daughter. It was a perfect blend of Elphaba and Glinda, capturing both the dark and the light in a way that was truly spellbinding. The cake needed a crown, and Jennifer was determined to find the perfect one. She searched everywhere—when nothing was quite right, she made one herself. And let me tell you, it was better than anything we could have imagined! It was the perfect final touch, making the cake look like it belonged center stage on Broadway. What truly sets Jennifer apart is her heart. She messaged me almost every day, not because she had to, but because she genuinely cared. She worried about letting us down, when in reality, she was creating something beyond perfect. Her dedication and passion were felt in every detail. The cake was more than just a cake—it was a showstopper. It looked stunning, tasted incredible, and left my daughter completely in awe. Jennifer didn’t just bake a cake—she created a memory we will never forget. If you want a baker who pours her soul into her work, Jennifer is the one!

Crafty cookie has become my go to for family occasions, birthdays, holidays, or just a treat for the family. I am always impressed with the presentation and the amount of work put into the items purchased. Not just the looks, but these creations always exceed expectations in taste as well!! Definitely getting the whole package when you do business with the Crafty Cookie! I’m already planning my next orders! Thank you, J, for all the hard work and love you put in to what you do.

I got exactly what I asked for and the quality and price was great!!

These cookies were so beautiful!

Amazing cake design! We love it

Once again you have knocked it out of the park with the decorated sugar cookies. They are so cute, taste great, and the kids love them.

I messaged the baker at the very last possible minute with a Christmas request and she was able to complete my order without issue. Everything was packed and beautiful and it tasted perfect. I think she is excellent and will definitely order from her again. Just perfection.

Jennifer did such an amazing job! Will make my holiday table spectacular!

I ordered bread, cookies, a pie and cupcakes and all were unbelievably delicious and beautiful

I ordered cookies , donuts and a cake from The Crafty Cookie everything was delicious and absolutely beautiful beyond my expectations and I have to say I have tried so many peoples cookies. Probably everyone in the county that makes them over the past three years and these are the only ones that I can say I actually liked a highly recommend, The Crafty Cookie

Her cookies were absolutely amazing!! I sent her a picture of what I liked as a reference and asked if she could try a new flavor! She did and did an awesome job ☺️

Thanks for making her day amazing I got cake, cake pops, donuts and everything was beautiful and taste amazing. I highly recommend the crafty cookie

Amazing job as always!!!

This was our third order with the Crafty Cookie! I had a large order of 3 dozen cupcakes, 1 dozen cake pops, and an 8 inch two tier cake all with large amounts of detail. She not only did a great job on all the designs and detail but the cake tasted great too. We received tons of compliments on both the looks and taste of everything! People even took some home with them.

Not only was this cake breathtakingly beautiful it was so delicious 10/10 recommend

I’ve ordered from crafty cookie multiple times and she always does amazing. Her cookies are not only beautiful but they taste so good!!

I gave her free Raynes and oh my goodness she made the cutest light up cake topper I have ever seen

This cake was amazingly delicious and so beautiful, she blew the inspiration photo out of the water 10/10 recommend

The cookies turned out so beautiful! So excited for my guests to see them at the shower!

She did a wonderful job on our girl’s birthday cake! Beautiful and delicious!

Booked last minute the cake was amazing and beautiful and tasted great also.

Wonderful and taste amazing

Jennifer printed photo cookies for me and they literally looked like photos , I am beyond pleased with these. I highly recommend the crafty cookie and printed cookies

The cake and cupcakes were beautiful and so tasty! Definitely recommend and will be buying from her in the future!

Guests said gluten free cupcakes were the best they ever had eaten! Moist not dry at all. Cake, cookies and cupcakes were just beautiful!!

As usual the crafty cookie amazed me so also exceeds my expectations but this time it was beyond amazing tasting and absolutely gorgeous. I highly recommend the crafty cookie

Jennifer knocked it put of the park! The cookies she made for my son’s birthday were wonderful! I gave her full creative freedom and she made them better than I could have imagined!

This cake was beyond my expectations, and delicious to boot we have a happy 5 yr old , I highly recommend the crafty cookie for all your treats

I sent a picture of a cake and Jennifer produced almost an exact replica and it was delicious she always makes us happy I will continue to order and highly recommend. For cookies and cakes

Jennifer always goes above and beyond when she creates cookies for me.

The cookies were beautiful and delicious!

Wonderful experience, fantastic cookies! Custom orders and fast service.

Jennifer was super sweet, helpful, and the cookies were exactly what we were looking for!

We got her white cake. Delicious!!! Highly recommend.

Cookies were exactly what I wanted and tasted great! Highly recommend to anyone needing made to order cookies!

Outstanding quality and service! She Aces it everytime!!

This and all other items by the crafty cookie have been not only beautifully decorated but the best tasting, of all I have tried hers are always the best. She always pleases us

The Preschool Graduation cookies were to cute. Everyone loved them.

Always beautifully done and they taste great!

Jennifer is always so helpful and delivers just as desired! Thank you!

She was able to design the perfect cookies on such a short notice. They are beautiful and I can’t wait to share them.

Not only do her cookies look great, they are delicious too! Highly recommend!

The Crafty Cookie always does an amazing job no matter what the event. She has done birthdays, anniversary, classroom cookies, and now created a couple “election” themed cookies for me. Give her an idea and she will come up with a cookie or treat to fit your need.

She does an awesome job! She even got my order in last minute! Highly recommend!!

Cookies are delicious, and exactly what you ask for! Amazing quality, and easy to order!

Have ordered several times and have been beyond happy with every order. She does an outstanding job! Highly recommend. 😊

Grapes were very good thank you. We put them in the freezer.

The best cookies around!

Great service highly recommended

Absolutely love! Very professional

These strawberries was delicious soo was the cotton candy grapes!

Consistently beautiful work!

Efficient service and easy to place order. The sugar cookies were delicately decorated with special detail, tasted sweet and were everything you’d want in a traditional, iced sugar cookie!

Jennifer did an amazing job with my sons ninja turtles cookie for his birthday. Absolutely going back. 10/10 recommended!

Thank you for the hard work you put into the items. Love the personalization and attention to detail- made a very special occasion even more memorable.

Once again Crafty Cookie has exceeded expectations. Everyone loved the sweets and every item looked amazing!

Every order placed has exceeded expectations. Very pleasant experience and every item was delicious. Will order again!

The cookies for my grandsons birthday were delicious and adorable. Highly recommend!!

I have ordered from The Crafty Cookie several times now and she never disappoints. My neices and nephews expect cookies for their birthdays now that match the theme of their party. Everyone loves them and they are yummy.

The Crafty Cookie did an AMAZING job on my order. All 150 flower cupcakes and wedding cake.