Ratings & Reviews

The cookies for my baby shower were absolutely perfect! Not only were they beautifully decorated and matched our theme so well, but they also tasted amazing. So many of our guests complimented both the design and the flavor. You can truly tell how much care and attention to detail went into every single cookie. They made the dessert table extra special and memorable for our celebration. I would absolutely use her again and highly recommend her to anyone looking for stunning and delicious custom cookies!

"I cannot recommend Savannah highly enough! She came to my home for my birthday to teach a group of eight ladies, and it was hands-down one of the best experiences we’ve ever had. If you are tired of the monotony of the typical birthday dinner this is exactly what you need. Savannah is incredibly well-prepared and professional, but also so warm and welcoming. She teaches in clear stages that are very easy to follow, making sure everyone feels comfortable regardless of their skill level. Not only was the decorating fun, but the cookies themselves are absolutely delicious! You can tell everything is made fresh. We did an Edgar Allan Poe 'The Raven' theme, and it was such a joyful blast! It turned a simple get-together into something truly meaningful and worthwhile. Whether you are celebrating a milestone birthday or just want a unique function to get your friends together, Savannah is amazing. If you want an event that your guests will actually remember, she is the one to call!"

The initial ordering process and responses were fast and efficient. I sent over a few inspiration photos and SHE NAILED IT! This was my first time ordering from The Cookie Case and she did not disappoint. The cookies were absolutely perfect. I will definitely be ordering again!

The cookies looked beautiful and they tasted just good!

She always does such a good job with my cookies. Perfect every time!

These cookies are absolutely perfect and delicious! She took the time to ask questions specific to my order to ensure I got exactly what I envisioned. She even hand delivered them to my home when we found ourselves in a time crunch. 100% recommend and will order from her again.

The cookies exceeded my expectation. They were decorated beautifully and tasted awesome! I will purchase again.

Beautiful and delicious cookies! Owner is very professional and helpful. Thank you!

Absolutely wonderful cookies! Every one at the party was asking where they could get them. My sister loved the taste and was completely surprised with the decoration.

That's the question I get every single time I bring Cookie Case cookies! They always turn out stunning. Taste amazing and have a beautiful crumb. Kids and adults enjoy alike. I will be ordering for all my events as I have been!! It's always a joy to work with Savannah to bring my vision to life in cookie form!!

We couldn’t be happier with the beautiful, personalized cookies you created for our daughter’s graduation! Every detail—from the colors to the custom designs—was absolutely perfect and made the celebration even more special. The heart you put into making these is remarkable! Thank you for helping us add such a meaningful and memorable touch to this big milestone. Your creativity, professionalism, and care truly showed in every cookie. We’re so grateful and will absolutely be ordering from you again!

I’ve been a customer with the Cookie Case for over 2 years now, the talent, experience and love that goes into each one of the cookies is AMAZING. The cookies look beautiful and taste even better. Every year my cookie platters are empty within minutes!

I have ordered cookies twice now from Savannah, both times we had a wonderful experience. The cookies were exactly what we asked for and delicious!

I had SO much fun taking this class!! I wanted to learn how i can incorporate sugar cookies into my business and this helped me get the basic understanding of decorating! I will be taking another class in the future!!

The cookies were amazing! The looked perfect and tasted even better. 🩷🩷

I ordered custom cookies for my daughters gymnastics team and they turned out amazing!!! The artwork was amazing and they tasted amazing! Ordering was easy as well as picking them up!! Thank you and I can’t wait to order more for the next event I have!!

The cookies look so amazing and also taste amazing. Always a great job.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

We absolutely loved the custom cookies from The Cookie Case for our client closing gift! The detail, quality, and presentation were top-notch! Thank you for adding the perfect sweet finish to a big milestone! We’ll definitely be ordering again! Better with Baron Team

I just ordered my first (and it definitely won’t be the last) batch of cookies from Savannah at The Cookie Case. Needless to say, I’m totally impressed! They are beautifully designed and a great size, professionally packaged and make the perfect gift!

I have been ordering cookies from The Cookie Case for several years now. For anything from birthdays to graduations to congratulations. Every time I am blown away by the level of detail that goes into each cookie/set I’ve ordered. I tell her my theme for the cookies and she works her creative magic. The Cookie Case communicates through the entire process. You can tell she truly loves what she does. It shows in her work. If you are ever looking for amazing detailed cookies, you’ve found the place!

These cookies did not disappoint. The theme we chose was exactly what we wanted and packaged up in a cute little white box with black ribbon to match this theme. They have the perfect amount of sweetness (not too sweet) and are still soft at day 3 because they are vacuum sealed.

The Cookie Case made my son's 4th birthday party all the more special with her amazing Baby Shark cookies. Not only were they beautifully made, but they tasted incredible. Both children and adults thoroughly enjoyed these beautiful treats! Highly recommend The Cookie Case to elevate your special occasion!

We couldn’t be happier with our gymnastic themed cookies! They were beautiful and very yummy! This is our third order from Cookie Case and it will not be our last! Perfection!!

I contacted Savannah about this order and she called me while on vacation at a waterpark with her family to talk details! Even went out of her way the day of pickup to deliver them Instead so we would have them In time! They were so delicious and the absolutely perfect way to commemorate our undefeated season!! As talented as she is, it pales in comparison to her customer service!! Will for sure be ordering more cookies for our future events!

I ordered some cookies for a baby shower at the last minute. She was quick to respond and fulfill my order last minute. They were so perfect and cute! The details on them were so beautifully executed and to top it off they tasted wonderful as well! These cookies were the perfect addition to this sweet baby shower and the talk of it as well!

The cookies were not only perfectly designed, but delicious 😋 With only a tiny bit of knowledge of the book, she gave us exactly what we needed for our book club meeting. Delivered on time in a beautiful window box

I had the pleasure of working with The Cookie Case, and I am extremely impressed by their professionalism and kindness throughout the entire process. They were respectful, understanding, and went above and beyond to ensure that I was completely satisfied. Their customer service is top-notch, and it’s clear they genuinely care about providing the best experience. I highly recommend them and will definitely be returning in the future

We had New York themed cookies made for a girls trip and was not disappointed! Great communication a great tasting cookies. Love love love and highly recommend 🤩