Custom Orders
Custom Cookie Cakes
$55.00
click for description
Custom Cookies: Standard Size
Starting at $50.00
click for description
✨ Party Pack! Cookie Cake + Mini Cookies
$95.00
click for description
Custom Cookies: Mini/Small Size
Starting at $50.00
click for description
Custom Cookie Mix: Standard + Mini/Small
$90.00
click for description
About
✨ Welcome! The Cookie Cakery by Shay, LLC specializes in custom artisan cookie cakes and cookie sets.
📸To see my work, check out my gallery in the drop down menu at the top of this page.
Capabilities & Pricing
🍪$55 per custom cookie cake.
🎨 Starting at $50 for a custom cookie set. (Pricing on cookie sets varies with number of colors, complexity, etc.)
📆 Deposits due within 24 hours of accepting quote.
💵 Final payment due within 1 week of order pickup.
📦 🚫 I do not ship cookies/cookie cakes
💡 Have an idea for something that you don’t see on my site? Drop me a note for consideration!
🍪 All cookies come heat sealed, which maintains your cookies’ freshness for up to 2 weeks at room temperature. Keep that in mind when you select your pickup date. Cookie cakes are best served within a day of delivery.
🚫 I do not make character cookies. I am happy to create something to match your theme, but do not create cookies that look like a character.
🏠 My products are produced in a private residence that is exempt from state licensing and inspection. My products may contain allergens. Contact me if you need details.
Policies
About Shay
My dad called me “Shay” and since his passing, I sure miss hearing that. So, I incorporated my dad's nickname for me into my business name. I’ve been making cookie cakes for family and friends for many years, and opened up my shop, The Cookie Cakery by Shay LLC, in 2024. In addition to baking, I am a dyslexia therapist. Therefore, my availability is a tad more limited during the school year. I love to create themed special treats, and bake as much as I can handle!