Ratings & Reviews

We had a great experience with Sugar Magic. We reached out to order for Teacher Appreciation Week & she jumped right in, ready to support us and our staff. The cookies she made were adorable, packaged with care, and great quality. She was reliable and communicated through the whole process, making pick up a breeze. We definitely recommend Sugar Magic for your sweet treat needs.

Sugar Magic makes the most amazing treats! The cookies are not only beautiful, but delicious too, which is nothing short of incredible. The other treats I’ve tried like snickerdoodle cookies, banana bread, and chocolate covered pretzels have also been super yummy. No matter what sweet you pick from Sugar Magic, you won’t be disappointed! Delicious!

Simply tops in taste and technique- We just love the detail and deliciousness in each treat!

The cookies from Sugar Magic are perfection! The flavors are absolutely delightful and the decorating is flawless with whimsical flair. I recommend to them to anyone for parties or just because!

I ordered Taylor Swift cookies for her big album release and Ashton did an absolutely amazing job on them. Each delicious, beautiful, and fresh in their individually wrapped packages. The hint of lemon flavor really put them over the top perfection! I will definitely order from her again. Highly recommend!

These are the most amazing cookies! The attention to detail and care that go into these cookies is outstanding!! The other baked goods are so delicious and are truly a treat to eat!!

Sugar Magic is out here doing the absolute most. These cookies are so stunningly beautiful I almost felt guilty eating them. Almost. The flavor is a total knockout, and the artistry is unmatched. It’s clear they put their entire heart into this craft. 10/10, no notes, just pure magic! 🍪🔥

You don't often find a gorgeous and detailed sugar cookie that fits your theme perfectly that you actually want to eat, but DANG these hit the mark! You can tell Ashton's passion is to serve others through the attention to detail she has with your order and it's clear that this started as a love to give her family a tasty treat because these cookies are flavor filled and the perfect combination of structured to hold the shape and decoration and melt in you mouth, chewy, sugar cookie goodness. Now I know she makes other delicious treats too, but let's focus on the fact that when your cookies are this perfect you don't need to offer anything else!

Professional and amazing.