Ratings & Reviews

Holly is so amazing to work with and so talented! She not only brought my vision for custom Teddy cookies to life for my baby shower, but she made them gluten free and absolutely delicious!!! I already can't wait to order more cookies for my next party!

Holly is incredibly talented. The designs are always so cute! I ordered cookies for my sister in law’s baby sprinkle, I just told holly a basic idea of what I wanted and she went above and beyond! They were so adorable and tasted amazing. Everyone loved them, huge hit.

I’m so impressed by the artistry in the cookies we purchased for my baby shower. Holly was so pleasant to work with and understood the assignment. I sent her some inspiration and she knew exactly the aesthetic we were going for. They exceeded my expectations and then some. Not only were they stunning but delicious and a crowd pleaser. I’ll be looking for reasons to use soft belly cookies again for any future events.

Everyone in my family was obsessed with these cookies!!! They turned out so perfect! Will def be using holly for all my future cookie needs!!

Holly has made several cookies for me and has slayed every time. She’s very good with inspiration boards and when you give her an idea she really comes through with the most aesthetically pleasing cookies. I could not recommend her more if you want that wow factor at your event!

Holly is incredible! Not only is she the most talented woman I’ve ever met the cookies tasted AMAZING! The talent and care she puts into her work BEAMS with love! I will keep coming back! Go holly!!!!

I found SoftBellyCookies recommended by a friend in a Facebook group and nothing but 5 stars for the entire experience!! The cookies were beautiful and exactly on theme for an Alice in Wonderland Bach weekend, the communication, presentation and delivery was prompt and organized, and they tasted delicious - way better than decorated treats often do. Would recommend Softbelly to ANYONE needing cookies for a special occasion!

I recently had ordered a cookie cake for my birthday, and it was absolutely incredible! The cake had the perfect balance of soft, chewy texture and a slightly crisp edge, just the way I love it. The decorations were beautiful as well, with a thoughtful touch of mini sugar cookies on top that made it feel extra special. I couldn’t have asked for a better birthday cake!

Holly was super attentive and kind! My order was perfect, definitely will be ordering again and recommending🩷

Holly took my random ideas for birthday cookies and straight up created works of art. I was so excited to gift these to my brother who fell in love with them. Highly recommend the funfetti but warn you all her work is not gonna wanna be consumed, it’s that freaking perfect!!

Wow doesn’t even begin to describe how wonderful my experience with Holly was. From the first message, to the idea sharing all the way to the delivery, everything was so easy and everything I asked for. The cookies were masterfully crafted and inclusive to the diets and needs of my guests and I’ve already scheduled my next cookie order! Thank you so much Holly for everything!

Holly is incredible from the initial convo through to pick up everything was perfect. The cookies are exactly what I imagined and I’m so happy with how they came out. I’d recommend soft belly to anyone!

We absolutely loved our cookies! Incredibly delicious and so beautiful. We had a variety of traditional, gf, and vegan and were impressed by the taste of all 3. We’ll definitely be ordering from Softbelly again!

I had the best experience with Soft Belly Cookies! I reached out to Holly about a custom order of cookies for a bachelorette party and she worked with me from start to finish to ensure my vision came to life. I shared inspiration pictures with Holly and she discussed her thoughts with me. I felt that the price she quoted me was fair and reasonable. The cookies truly came out better than I could have imagined. It was so clear the amount of love, time and effort that went into hand painting each cookie, and she even put a few extra cookies into my order. The best part was that they tasted as good as they looked. I would recommend Soft Belly Cookies to anyone.

I'm so grateful to Softbelly Cookies for creating a lovely thank-you gift for my partner. They were fun, delicious, well-made, and beautifully packaged. Would order again!

These were amazing and delicious cookies. The artistry that went into them was thoughtful and terrific. Will definitely be stuffing my face with these cookies again!

Exceeded my expectations. Cookies are delicious. Designs are SO good. The perfect gift. Amazing turnaround time, communication, and service. Will def be getting more!!

My cookies were amazing!!!! Looked so great and cute almost too good to eat! But I did and they were absolutely delicious!

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! Such a great customer experience, she really went above and beyond. So incredibly talented and the cookies looked and tasted amazing!! My friend loved them so much it was such a great gift. I got the vegan cookies and they were delicious, everything was so well thought out even the packaging was beautiful!

Holly is AMAZING!! Such a sweetheart and she really took my vision for these cookies and brought them to life not to mention they were BOMB and a hit!!!

Amazingly tasty and beautiful work as always. Thank you so so much!

Every detail of these cookies were perfect, the packaging was beautiful, the cookies themselves were delicious and insanely detailed. I loved all the designs. I was so happy with my purchase, I immediately placed another order. Highly recommend

I've ordered multiple batches of cookies from Holly and not only are they delicious, but she consistently impresses me (and everyone else) with her creativity, kindness and punctuality. Side note: the pricing is VERY fair and worth every penny!

I got pet cookie portraits and they were so adorable and accurate to my cats! Will definitely be ordering again for other events.

The cookies are amazing. Works of art. It was hard to eat them but when we did they tasted fantastic. It’s hard to impress an eighteen year old boy but he was taking pictures to show his friends I plan to buy again for sure!!

absolutely perfect cookies! they tasted as great as they looked!

Holly has yet to disappoint. I’ve ordered from her 5 times! And everytime it’s been so special and amazing. I am grateful for our delicious treats for our holidays and birthdays ❤️🫶🏻 and for fun!

I requested a set of Sailor Moon cookies and they literally looked perfect! My friends who I gave them to said they tasted amazing as well. Holly is great at what she does and very easy to communicate with, definitely will order again :)

I ordered 3 different sets of cookies friendsgiving, Thanksgiving (2 different themes), and baby shower and each of them were just extraordinary. If you're looking to wow your host (or as a host) this is the move.

Ah!! Such yummy and creative cookies! The DragonballZ ones I got were beyond awesome! Funfetti for the win!

I ordered a 2 dozen batch of custom cookies from Holly for my sisters baby shower and they came out beautiful! She was recommended to me through the Philaqueens FB page and I am so glad because everyone loved them! They were so cute and delicious. Holly is super sweet and easy to work with and her prices are great too! Definitely would recommend for any of your party or celebration needs😊

Ordered multiple styles as holiday gifts for our staff. Everything from communication, to quality of cookies was exceptional! They tasted great, looked like the photos provided for reference, and were packed really well. Everyone loved them, will def be ordering again!!

INCREDIBLE cookies!! And so much fun collaborating with Holly on the design! However she took my idea and SURPASSED all expectations!

OMG ! My cookies were perfect ! I ordered a little last minute, and the turn around was fast. Pick up was super easy to coordinate. Holly is so sweet just like her tasty, beautiful cookies !

Absolutely perfect!

Wowwwww what an incredible experience. I gave Holly a very loose idea for some Grey’s Anatomy cookies to surprise my girlfriend on her birthday. Holly took my idea and elevated these cookies beyond anything I could have thought of. She did her homework, incorporating fan favorite characters and catchphrases and the artistic details she was able to create with icing was impressive to say the least. Holly made my girlfriend happy and made me look like the man in front of all her friends. What more could you ask for? Thanks Holly!!!