Ratings & Reviews

Caitlyn is literally so talented!! She has made cookies for all of my sons birthday parties and I will continue to use her services for every party that I host. Not only is she an insanely talented artist but the cookies also taste delicious. My mom says they are her favorite cookies ever and even requested them as her birthday present this year. Order from sky + oak bakery - you will not regret it!!

I have ordered custom cookies from four different places, and Sky + Oak Bakery is the final place because it checked EVERY box. You know how when you find the perfect spot you want people to know about it… but you also kinda don’t because you feel like it’s your own secret? Those are my feelings about these cookies! “Expert” is the word I keep coming to. They are expertly designed by an artist, with precision used in the decorating. And holy cow - the taste. These are NOT your grocery store sugar cookies. I swear, they are my grandma’s. Anyone can see from the photos posted on Sky + Oak’s social media that they look perfect, but you can’t see the perfect taste! You’ll just have to take my word for it … or place an order for any reason that you want to celebrate. My adult son was the most recent recipient of personalized birthday cookies and he loved them! Amazing taste + beautiful presentation + supporting a small business = perfection!

These cookies are hands down the BEST! I have ordered from Caitlyn twice now. Each time I am completely amazed with how her cookies turn out. Not only are they perfectly designed, they also taste delicious. Caitlyn is a pleasure to work with, she is thoughtful and works with you to design the perfect cookie for the occasion. I can’t wait to order more from her!

Not only do they look beautiful but they taste amazing as well!!

Caitlyn is amazing! I sent her a picture of what I was looking for and she exceeded my expectations with how beautiful the cookies turned out! These cookies taste delicious too!

I recently ordered custom cookies for my son's 1st birthday, and I couldn't be happier with the results! The attention to detail was impeccable, and the cookies were not only visually stunning but also delicious. The personalized designs captured the theme perfectly, making the celebration even more special. I highly recommend this custom cookie service for anyone looking to add a sweet touch to their events.

Consistently going the extra mile to create the most creative, delicious and beautiful cookies for any occasion. Highly recommend!!

I’ve ordered cookies from Caitlyn several times, and had them at multiple events and they are always absolutely delicious. Most “pretty” cookies don’t actually taste good, but hers are the exception. They’re so soft, delicious frosting, and just never miss. Her designs are next level and she’s always able to deliver exactly what you’re asking for. Absolutely would recommend her x 100 to anyone wanting cookies for a special occasion!

I just picked up my order for. Valentine's Day, and I couldn't be happier! The cookies are unbelievably adorable, the packaging is top notch, and it was all in a really nice gift bag with tissue paper, business card, and cute design on bag. Caitlyn has an eye for detail and it shows in every area of her business. I will definitely be ordering again.

Caitlyn does an exceptional job with these and is so meticulous. Her creativity takes these cookies to another level and they taste amazing too!