Delivery Subscription
Receive a weekly or bi-weekly delivery of sourdough baked goods for a one time monthly payment. Order can be customized with any menu item. Pay only for the baked goods, delivery is free! Tuesday deliveries -Craley -New Bridgeville -Windsor -Red Lion -Dallastown -East Prospect Friday deliveries -York -Hellam -Wrightsville -Columbia -Cooper Booth Wholesale
click for description
Plain Traditional
Medium(1.1lbs) - $6.50 Large(2lbs) - $10.00 Ingredients: Organic Bread Flour, Water, Organic Starter(Organic Bread Flour, water),Organic Whole Wheat Flour, Pink Himalayan Salt An Organic Sourdough Loaf is a naturally leavened bread made with high-quality organic ingredients, resulting in a wholesome, flavorful, and nutritious loaf. With a crisp, golden-brown crust and a soft, chewy interior, this artisan bread boasts a complex depth of flavor, balancing mild tanginess with subtle nutty and earthy undertones. The long fermentation process enhances both taste and digestibility, promoting gut-friendly probiotics and a satisfying texture. Made with only organic flour, water, and salt, this loaf is free from additives and preservatives, ensuring a pure and authentic sourdough experience. Perfect for toast, sandwiches, or enjoying with butter and jam, it’s a versatile staple that embodies simplicity and tradition.
$6.50
click for description
Sandwich Loaf
Medium(1.1lbs) - $6.00 Large(2lbs) - $9.00 *COMES SLICED* Ingredients: Organic Bread Flour, Water, Organic Starter, Olive Oil, Pink Himalayan Salt, Honey. Our Sourdough Sandwich Bread is the perfect fusion of traditional fermentation and everyday comfort. Made with a natural sourdough starter and slowly fermented for flavor and digestibility, this loaf offers a soft, tender crumb and a mild tang that complements sweet or savory fillings alike. The crust is golden and thin—easy to slice through—making it ideal for sandwiches, toast, or grilled cheese. Free from commercial yeast and preservatives, it's a wholesome, artisanal take on a classic staple. Whether you're packing lunch or crafting the perfect breakfast, this sourdough bread is your new daily go-to.
$8.00
click for description
Whole Wheat Sandwich Loaf
Medium(1.1lbs) - $8.00 Large(2lbs) - $11.00 *COMES SLICED* Ingredients: Organic Whole Wheat Flour, Organic Bread Flour, Water, Organic Starter, Olive Oil, Pink Himalayan Salt, Honey.
$8.00
click for description
Pumpkin Cookies
Made with fresh roasted pumpkin. This cookie is soft and cakey. It's like a handheld pumpkin pie cake!
$6.00
click for description
Pumpkin Spice Loaf
Made with fresh roasted pumpkins and spiced like a pumpkin pie. Perfect for french toast or sweet sandwiches like peanut butter and jelly.
$9.00
click for description
Real bread. Legendary flavor.
Welcome to Mythical Sourdough, your fresh, made to order sourdough bread delivery service. Communities around East York such as Windsor, Wrightsville, Hellam, Columbia, Red Lion, Craley, East Prospect and more can receive fresh baked bread weekly with no hassle!
Miles are determined by distance from 704 Taylor Rd.
Delivery Fees(Subscription)
0-5 miles- FREE
5-10 miles- FREE
Delivery Fees(One Time Delivery)
đź’«First order comes with free deliveryđź’«
Within 2 miles- FREE
2-5 miles- $2.00 OR $15 order minimum
5-10 miles- $4.00 OR $20 order minimum
10-15 miles- $6.00 OR $25 order minimum
3 basic ingredients, fresh baked every Tuesday and Thursday!
Follow Mythical Sourdough on Facebook for updates, extra baked goods available on demand, and more
2-day lead time. Pre-payment required before order is baked.
Delivery Days/Hours
Monday: CLOSED
Tuesday: 12pm-4pm deliveries to South of Windsor
Wednesday: CLOSED
Thursday: 12pm-4pm deliveries to north of Windsor
Friday: CLOSED
Saturday: October 17th pickup Red Lion Farmers Market
Sunday: CLOSED