Ratings & Reviews

These cookies were such a hit at my daughter’s first birthday party. They were absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing of course. Everybody loved them! Great customer service. Would highly recommend!

From start to finish she did an amazing job! She was so wonderful to work with. She helped with choosing a fitting design (a combo of a few that we had seen!) the detail was so well done and crisp! The colors were so vibrant. The flavor was really sweet but not over powering, and the cookies just melted with every bite. Thank you for such an amazingly pleasant experience!

MK’s Cookie Creations were a wonderful addition to our daughter’s first birthday celebration. The level of detail was outstanding!! MK took our inspiration photos and brought them to life! Everyone raved on how beautiful they were (delicious too!) and we happily shared who made them. We highly recommend and will definitely use again 🥰

I am so very thankful for MK Cookies. Our sweet Theo is our first grandchild and we were in a bind to find someone to bring a special touch to his 1st birthday. MK Cookies not only made time for us but put such a unique creative touch to our cookie order that I was brought to tears. Creativity and genuine care to the smallest details because it is all important to MaryKathryn. I’m excited for our next celebration and her special touch of sweet love! Thank you MK Cookies!

These came out just as I envisioned! So cute and very well made!! Everything was spot on, communication was easy and prompt. Definitely will be ordering again for future events!

I was very impressed with not only the beauty of the cookies I ordered but taste as well! My daughter loves Spider-Man and the cookies MK delivered did not disappoint. I’ll be ordering from her for all my kiddos birthdays and events!

Cookies were exactly what I asked for! They were not only beautiful, but tasted wonderful. The process was so easy to order. Definitely will be ordering from MK again!

MK went above and beyond to make the cutest cookies for my baby shower. She nailed it for my theme “we can bearly wait!” 🥰

Cookies exceeded my expectations. And she’s super responsive and accommodating.

I would like to provide full transparency that I am a hard person to please. These cookies were NOT ONLY BEAUTIFUL and EXACTLY what I asked for but they were DELICIOUS!!!! They were the most talked about treat of all the snacks at my event! I highly recommend 10/10 her services because she was not only kind but VERY professional and my timing was met to a perfect standard!! CANT WAIT to use her services again!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!

These cookies were as equally delicious as they were beautiful! They added the perfect touch to our baby shower and I couldn’t have been more pleased!

Beautiful cookies. Exactly what I wanted. Perfect touch to our baby shower theme 🩵

MK is just unbelievably talented! Everything looks so beautiful, clean and precisely done. I have no words other than perfection! She’s so kind and professional. 10/10 recommend her!!!

MK did an amazing job creating the cookies for our son’s first birthday. Our theme was based on the children’s book The Wonderful Things You Will be, and she brought it to life beautifully. The creativity, the attention to detail, and how well the designs complemented the theme were truly unmatched. We were so impressed!

Exceptional quality and impeccable detail. The custom cookies matched our baby-shower theme perfectly and arrived fresh and delicious. Fantastic work!

It was a pleasure working with MK’s cookies. Not only was her work stunning, her cookies were delicious. She made my cookie dreams a reality!

I ordered cookies for my wedding and to say I couldn’t be happier would be the understatement of the year! The cookies are so beautiful- they really are a piece of art! Thank you so much- we will be ordering more cookies in the future!

MK Creations has made cookies for my son’s 1st and 2nd birthdays, and most recently for my daughter’s 1st — and they never disappoint! Not only are they stunning, but they taste just as good as they look. Mary Katherine, the owner and creator, is so easy to work with and always brings my vision to life. If you need custom cookies, she’s your girl! Highly recommend 💕🍪

MK’s Cookie Creations is absolutely amazing! She went above and beyond my expectations from start to finish. She was so communicative and made sure every detail of my order was exactly how I wanted it. The cookies turned out even better than I imagined—beautiful, delicious, and crafted with so much care. Her prices are more than reasonable (honestly, she should charge more for the level of talent and effort she puts in!). If I could give her 100/10 stars, I would. I’ll definitely be ordering again and recommending her to everyone I know!

Got cookies for a Bach trip and they were sooo pretty! I’ve looked at 3 other people and they were gonna charge 2.5 times more. I am going planning on more orders and am so excited

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I ordered custom (girl) Winnie the Pooh cookies for my baby shower, and I couldn’t be happier with how they turned out! The amount of detail in each cookie was absolutely incredible you could tell so much time and care went into making them. Not only were they adorable and perfectly matched my theme, but they also tasted amazing! Everyone at the shower was talking about how cute and delicious they were. The packaging was neat and secure, and not a single cookie arrived broken. I highly recommend these if you want something special and memorable for your event they truly exceeded my expectations! ( just a note you’re probably not gonna want eat them because of how adorable they look) 💕

Absolutely love the designs for the cookies that we ordered for our baby shower. Can’t wait to eat them!

I can’t even tell you how perfect my order turned out. She exceeded my expectations in ways I cant describe. Communication was so easy with her, she promised me a time they would be delivered and was on the DOT. I sent her a couple inspiration pictures and told her to be creative and that is exactly what she did. I have never been happier and more excited over cookies than now! I highly recommend booking with her for any occasion you are having!

The cookies were so cute and also delicious! She worked with my inspiration photos and with my time constraints and was very communicative and friendly. Overall very easy and wonderful experience. Definitely recommend.

Thank you for these beautiful cookies. We cannot wait to celebrate our new addition to the family with these amazing cookies. Thank you again.

MKs cookies are the best in Jax! I provided an inspo picture and theme of the party, she nailed the design and colors! Can’t wait to have these at my daughter’s birthday party. Thank you!

MKS Cookie creation killed it! I sent her an inspiration picture from Pinterest and she incorporated all of the details and colors perfectly adding her own special touch. They look absolutely incredible. I will definitely be using her as my go -to cookie girl in the near future!

My expectations were exceeded again by year two of beautiful birthday cookies. Each one is a work of art and decorated with such detail! Highly recommend these cookies for any event!

I found MK on Instagram and her responsiveness to my inquiry and her openness to my design idea sold me and she did not disappoint! On the day of pick up, it was very convenient to find my cookies and they were a highlight of the party! Beautiful and delicious. I will definitely work with MK again for any future parties.

MK was so easy to work with and her cookies came out beautifully! So flexible for pickup and prompt in communications.

The cookies were perfect and a huge hit at our daughters baby shower 😍

My experience ordering with MK was a 10/10! She made me the most beautiful cookies that were even prettier than the inspiration picture I showed her! The cookies also taste great! She has top tier communication and is so sweet and easy to work with when it comes to creating your cookies! I already put it in another order because they are that good!

MK did cookies for my gender reveal party. I sent her an inspiration picture from Pinterest and the cookies were exactly what I wanted. They were absolutely gorgeous and delicious. My friends were asking where I got them from and who made them. She was quick to respond and even was able to accommodate me changing my pick up time to a day sooner. I will definitely be using her for all my events in the future. I highly, highly recommend.

Baker was very professional and timely. Baker is very talented and the cookies looked identical maybe even better than what I described. They were also tasty and aesthetically pleasing. Overall great experience. Definitely recommend!!!

Brought my cookies from a picture to life!! Was made exactly like what i asked for and looked perfect!!

MK’s Cookies are as beautiful as they are delicious! Each one is expertly crafted with stunning designs and amazing flavor. Perfect for any occasion.

In love with my cookie order. Provided what I wanted as far as design and what I received was even BETTER!!! If I could leave a review higher than 5 stars, I would!

These cookies are absolutely gorgeous—and the best part is, they taste just as amazing as they look! The customer service was outstanding, which made the whole experience even better. It’s a win-win for me! I can’t wait to place my next order.

This was our 2nd order from MK and they were somehow even better than the first time. The cookies are absolutely stunning and taste great!

The cookies looked amazing!!! Will deffinately be using again!!

The customer service to the cookies I have zero complaints. The end product always exceeds my expectations. I’m forever going to be a customer. An to make things even better delivery is available, which makes things easier when you’re preparing a party for your loved one. A 10 out of 10, I’ll always recommend

Cookies were beautiful made. Shortbread was nice and soft and icing yummy. Was a hit at the babyshower!

I ordered a batch of cookies from MK Connie's Creations for my husband's 41st birthday, and I couldn’t be happier with how they turned out! Mary perfectly captured my vision, creating beautifully decorated cookies that tasted just as amazing as they looked. Every detail was thoughtfully executed, and the flavors were absolutely delicious. Not only was the quality outstanding, but the entire experience—from ordering to pick-up—was seamless. I highly recommend her business and will definitely be ordering again in the future!

The cookies were absolutely beautiful and she was able to capture my vison perfectly. Everything was perfect and the response time was fantastic. I will definitely be ordering again.

These cookies turned out better than I imagined! She made the vision come to life and was so responsive when I had any questions. Thank you x1000!

MKs cookies are absolutely the best. My son begged for dirtbike cookies for his birthday celebration at school and Mks cookie creations nailed it! They were delicious and made the birthday boys day!! From the ordering, to the pick up, to everyone enjoying them was perfect. I can't rave enough about these delicious cookies! We will be ordering again for our next celebration/event!

This is my second time having MKs cookies! They always turn out beautiful and she creates your vision better than expected!

I was hosting a big Italian themed dinner party at my house and MK’s cookies came through with the cutest Italian themed cookies. Not only were they adorable but they’re also extremely delicious! Can’t wait to order more!

This is my second time ordering from MK’s cookie creations and ofc she never fails to amaze me😍😍 I recommend her to everyone i know!

These cookies were beautiful and so delicious! Mary is very talented and created the perfect cookies for my sister’s baby shower! I will for sure return to her for any of my future cookie needs!

Cookies are adorable and even taste delicious! Great communication and customer service. Will recommend to others and use again!

I recently purchased cookies for the Cardiac Sonographers I work with for Sonography week. I just wanted to say how easy Mary Kathryn is to work with! Not only is she super responsive, but her cookies turned out better than I could have imagined. I messaged her what I was thinking and she totally blew it out of the park! From looks to taste, we all couldn't stop raving about them and I look forward to working with her for future needs.

MK is our friendly neighborhood cookie dealer. We began using her when she first started out in the cookie business and I am so proud of how far she has come. Every order she does for our family gets better and better. Without a doubt, she is the first person I recommend!

The owner is so sweet and so professional! The pricing for the work she does is amazing honestly. She was able to fill my order and make them look exactly how I imagined within one week. Will for sure use her for future events!

I ordered cookies with the theme of Publix pharmacy and National Pharmacy Technician Day for my employees. The cookies turned out so cute and I got them on time! Can’t wait for my technicians to enjoy them!

The cookies were so beautiful and delicious!! Such great communication and very easy to order!! Highly recommend!!

LOVE these cookies - requested some amalfi inspired cookies and they were beautiful and delicious

These cookies were a huge hit at my husband’s party! They tasted great and I loved how the designs turned out. MK’s Cookie Creations was amazing to work with, from the initial consult up to the delivery date. She listened to my ideas and executed them perfectly! I will definitely be ordering more cookies 😁

We were so incredibly thankful for the beautiful cookies that were perfect and delicious. What was absolutely unique about this business is that they worked with our very tight deadline and delivered to us just in time for a special birthday celebration!

MK was awesome to work with! From the moment I reached out to receiving my cookies she was extremely responsive and helpful. She turned my order for my wedding around in less than 2 weeks and even drove to deliver them for me. They are perfect and absolutely delicious! I would totally recommend for any upcoming party or event to use her.

I reached out pretty early (over a month in advance). Throughout the month, we stayed in touch with good communication. She even managed to make them a week earlier when I had my party moved up by a week! The cookies are so cute. I received a photo when they were completed. I can’t wait for my guests to see them!!!

The cookies are amazing! She is truly an artist!

The birthday cookies were at hit! She paid great attention to detail and exceeded my expectations. And the cookies were delicious! Can't wait to order again

I am not a local to Jacksonville but have family here and visit often. We had a UNF graduation party and wanted to have cookies made local vs traveling with cookies from out of state. They were adorable and exceeded all expectations! They were delicious! The cookies wasn’t very sweet which was good because the icing was sweet (as it should be). They balanced each other perfectly! We all agreed that if we need more cookies in Jacksonville we know who to call! MK! Thank you again! 💖

From start to finish, MK offered great customer service. The cookies were easy to order and the communication was clear. The cookies are exactly the design I was hoping for AND they taste amazing too! Will recommend to everyone who is looking for a custom cookie!

Perfect cookies, amazing and fast communication, attention to details, and just such beautiful work! I was stunned when I picked up my cookies, worth every penny! Get these for your next celebration, you won’t regret it!

All around great experience when ordering custom cookies. Online order process was easy, I was able to upload an inspo image to give her an idea of the design I was going for and she went above and beyond! Responsive, friendly, talented and the cookies tasted GREAT!!! Will definitely be a repeat customer.

MKs cookies did such an incredible job on my daughter’s birthday cookies! She responded so quick when I requested a date & absolutely nailed the theme just based off my inspo pics. The cookies are freaking gorgeous & taste even better! I will 100% be ordering again!

The cookies for my daughter's 4th Birthday were beautiful, delicious and well packaged! Everyone at her party loved them! Thank you so much!

I made a special request for our company and could not believe how great these came out! It was exactly what I was looking for. Will definitely be ordering again soon!

10/10 recommend. Not only were the cookies a huge hit at my open house, they were also delicious. I placed an order on short notice and MK delivered the cutest assortment. I will definitely place future orders.

I can’t say how much I have enjoyed the process of ordering these cookies. Y’all were incredibly responsive in the ordering process. The cookies were works of art and they tasted amazing! Highly recommend this business!

Second cookie order- you are amazing! The love and thought you put into these orders is outstanding. Not only are they beautiful- they are delicious! I will order again and again. Thank you so much!!

Beautiful and delicious cookies! Excellent Communication from the moment you place the order to pickup! 100% Recommended

These amazing cookies exceeded our expectations! I loved that I could send her some inspiration and let her take the reins. Not only are they beautiful cookie art, but they taste so good! I was pleasantly surprised that even the ones with black icing are delicious and no weird black icing chemical flavor at all. 5 stars!!!

I ordered cookies for the first time from MK and they were absolutely amazing!! Her skill is undeniable and they tasted SO good!! Will definitely use her again!

Wow! We are so impressed by MK's talent. She crafted amazing Super Mario Bro themed cookies for our son's 3rd birthday party. Everyone loved them and they tasted delicious. Highly recommend!

Beautiful cookies! Excellent communication and such a pleasure to work with.

Our cookies were great! Would definitely order again. Thank you!!

Mary Kathryn was a pleasure to work with. My client had worked with her and I was so pleased I ordered my own cookies. She was so responsive and easy to work with. I can’t wait to refer our more business to her!!