Ask about our all-inclusive cake design—your one-stop shop for all your cake needs! 🍰 no hidden fees
×

Ratings & Reviews

55 Ratings
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
royal blue birthday cakeshana
Verified Order
15 days ago
Omg I don't know where to begin!!! Shenny far exceeded my expectations!!! She definitely delivered!!! The cake was not only esthetically pleasing, but it was divine!!! my husband who is not very fond of cake devoured a whole slice, and my mom who is very particular, was extremely impressed. There were whispers throughout the room inquiring who made the cake and how delicious it was. I also have to add how patient she was with me. I was very indecisive regarding the flavor and the decorations, but nevertheless, shenny was able to decipher and execute exactly what I had envisioned ,with style and elegance.
My daughter's Golden Birthday Sheena
Verified Order
17 days ago
The first time I saw Shenny's work she had done a red and black heart cake for my sister in law's 30th birthday. I immediately knew I wanted her to do my daughter's 17th golden birthday cake and guess WHAT? She didn't disappoint..... the moment I reached out to place the order to the moment she delivered we were in constant communication. Then she sent the PICS!!! I swear she didn't miss anything matter fact it was so much more than I expected but when we cut into the cake and tasted it..... DELICIOUS!! The cake itself was moist, not too sweet the buttercream filling was just right. The cake didn't just look good it tasted amazing and that's how you know you've found the right baker! Believe the hype!
Nice girlsJOSE
Verified Order
26 days ago
We loved 😍 so much in the cake so delicious 😋
Best cake I’ve had!!Sydney
Verified Order
28 days ago
From ordering to delivery, the process was seamless! Everyone at my event RAVED about the cake! It was absolutely delicious. I’m already planning my future event orders. Recommending Elegantly Baked to all my family and friends.
Happy 13 th Birthday CakeSharlene
Verified Order
29 days ago
Elegance! Beautifully executed! The girls were surprised and they loved the colors and the design of the cake. Thumbs up!!! 💝
Birthday CakesLeonie
Verified Order
about 1 month ago
I ordered 2 cakes from Elegantly Baked. 1 princess cake from my 17-year-old granddaughter and 1 for her father (my son). At the party everyone admired the beautiful princess cake, it was elegantly baked with pictures around the heart-shaped cake with pictures from different eras of her life, and the rich red icing sparkled with a tiara sitting on the top. It was breathtaking, you don’t want to cut the masterpiece. My son’s cake was a man’s man's cake made looking like a bulk of money with a rubber band wrapped around it. While both cakes were on the table and the guests were admiring them to my pleasant surprise I didn’t know that most of the guests did not know that my son's cake was a cake and that everything was eatable. The tease was amazing, so mouthwatering that everyone came back for seconds. The overall experience was satisfying, I have no regrets. 👍👏👏👏💯🎉
Immaculate Petre-Ann
Verified Order
about 1 month ago
I must say that the cake was beautiful to look at but the true test of any cake is how it tastes, and when I tell you that I could literally taste all the flavors in my cake I mean all of them. Cake was very dense and moist also rich in texture. Must say baker took her time to make sure cake was loved with each and every bite taken. Baker was super great to work with, loved how she took all my ideas and brought it to life with my cake. Thank you Elegantly Baked for an overall lovely cake and an easy experience from placing my order to upon delivery. Your the best.
Yummy cakes Debralee
Verified Order
about 1 month ago
Beautiful works of art, just the right sweetness and flavors. Keep bringing in the goods.
Creative genius !Natalie
Verified Order
about 2 months ago
Beyond amazing is an understatement! I was so pleased with how the cake design turned out especially because I did not provide an inspiration pic. Her level of creativity is unmatched! And as always, tasted amazing. Customer service is always A1, even with the most difficult customers (myself). Forever a returning customer :-)
Burn away Cake Aleia
Verified Order
2 months ago
Creativity design great customer service and flavor
My daughters 13th birthday Reese
Verified Order
2 months ago
Returning loyal customer ! My daughter’s cake design was so amazing and so nice !!!! Fit for a teenage girl. Of course the cake was moist as always and tasted good. My 4th order with Elegently baked and she never disappoints.
Luscious Cakes and Cup cakesChristine
Verified Order
3 months ago
Last week I purchased a cake from Elegantly Baked. When the cake was delivered I wanted to eat the entire cake! I brought it home and the entire cake was devoured by my family within the hour! My daughter took a few slices home to her husband who is a picky eater! She called and asked for more. Sorry it was too late! We also have my two dogs a taste and that were beyond happy! On Valentines Day I ate the best cupcake ever which she had made. BETTER THAN NYCs Magnolia Bakery❣️soooo amazing plus the very best chocolate covered strawberry I have ever had in my life! This girl can bake! She is amazing!!! Thank you for the experience! I'll be ordering some birthday cakes in the next few months. The photos of her fancy cakes look amazing ❣️
Greatly appreciated Diamond
Verified Order
2 months ago
Yall the way the cake has been executed with a days notice, im in love and the request was complicated but Shenny did the Deng thang! Thank you so much. Place your order today! Don’t wait.
Valentine Day Angeneque
Verified Order
3 months ago
Oh my God, this was such a spectacular treat me and my spouse enjoyed it greatly. It was filled with sweet and moist and just perfect thank you for making our night just as delicious
Sweet 16 Kristina
Verified Order
3 months ago
Out of all the Red velvet cakes I have eaten this cake is one of the best I ever had I would definitely recommend Elegantly Bake by Shenny to anyone and I will continue to use her in the future for more events to come 🥰🍾🩸🙏❤️🎉
Sculptured cake for my son birthday Tracy Anson
Verified Order
4 months ago
Blessed to have good friends in your life and aunts and uncles who love your children! I was surprised at getting this cake from Shen Lewis of Elegantly baked. She made this cake for my son Christopher who turns 10 tomorrow. I didn't expect it! Thanks a million Shenny! If ever you are in the Hudson Valley and you need a cake for a special event, Elegantly baked should be your number 1 choice!
Rum Bundt CakeTracy-Ann
Verified Order
4 months ago
A quarter of the cake is left, in less than 4 hours lol it was so good “Me a go hide it it so we can have piece tomorrow“ lol I love it
Infused Cupcakes and Strawberries Alexis
Verified Order
3 months ago
My order was placed and ready promptly. The Size of the cupcakes were immense. The texture was moist, the icing wasn't too sweet it was the perfect balance. and the chocolate covered strawberries were very tasteful. The packaging was very cute and a perfect depiction of a Valentine’s day theme. I was more than satisfied and would definitely order again.
Blue berry Bundt Cake Janelle
Verified Order
4 months ago
I enjoyed it very moist was good
Cupcake & Chocolate-covered Strawberries Tracey-Ann
Verified Order
3 months ago
Ordered cupcakes and chocolate-covered strawberries from Elegantly Baked for coworkers on Valentine's Day. Let's just say, everyone devoured them and was asking for more. The cupcakes were moist and super delicious-10/10.
Cupcakes Sharon
Verified Order
3 months ago
My cup cake was amazing 10 outta 10 for me 💯💯💯💯
In love!!!!!Chole
Verified Order
3 months ago
Not only are any orders done in a timely fashion but my goodies are always phenomenal and just beautiful!!! They always taste superb and anytime I have an event I will always order from here!!!!!
Sharon
Verified Order
3 months ago
Paw Patrol Cake Cole Kimler
Verified Order
3 months ago
Cole’s birthday cake was pure perfection. It was just the right amount of sweet and the amount of time and detail that went into it showed. It was truly delicious.
Beautiful cake and delicious tooChristina
Verified Order
3 months ago
The cake turned out to be everything my daughter wanted. She was so happy.
Burn away birthday cake Tiffany
Verified Order
3 months ago
What a beautiful cake ! I enjoyed my vanilla cake so much, it satisfied my sweet tooth.
I wanna say thanks to shan you've done a great job.....the best on the hudson valley!!! Nakia
Verified Order
3 months ago
Cocomelon theme cakeChevona
Verified Order
3 months ago
The cake was amazing and beautiful. The decor was truly better than I imagined.
Daughter 2nd Birthday - 2 Tier CakeJillian
Verified Order
4 months ago
The cake was absolutely gorgeous and elegantly decorated ❤️! Sheneille was easy to work with, I am so lucky to call her a friend!! I sent in an inspiration picture and she made it to the T and AMAZING! The cake was moist, delicious, and easy to transport. When it came to cutting the cake there was a detailed card that came with directions on how to cut the cake, which was lovely since I am unfamiliar on cutting a big cake like this. It made the cake cutting process so much easier.
Exceptional ⭐️TerryAnn
Verified Order
5 months ago
I couldn’t be happier with the incredible cake I received for my birthday! The design was stunning, and the attention to detail was unmatched. Not only did it look amazing, but the flavor was absolutely delicious—moist, rich, and full of flavor. The entire process, from placing the order to delivery, was seamless and professional. I highly recommend elegantly baked for any occasion; they truly exceeded my exception
My Awesome OrderKimberly
Verified Order
4 months ago
I ordered a red rum Bundt cake and pink champagne cupcakes. The aesthetics and presentation was exceptional but most importantly the cupcakes and Bundt cake were full of flavor and moist. Sweet but not overly sweet and that is what my family and I look for. Thank you Shenny!!!!
Red velvet rum bliss Natalie
Verified Order
4 months ago
I don’t even know where to start this cake was so good lol . Soaked in rum. Nice and moist and the red velvet flavor was amazing !
The Unexpected FiFi
Verified Order
4 months ago
I had no idea how my cake was going to turn out, but I knew what it should look like. The cake was a lot more than I anticipated; it was absolutely perfect and bursting with delicious flavors. Thanks elegantly baked for your unwavering delivery on expectations.
RIP 20s heart cake Natashia
Verified Order
5 months ago
When I say perfect I mean perfect! From the beginning to end! ✨🖤🖤
My son 10 year old birthday party Stacyann
Verified Order
5 months ago
The cake was wonderful and tasted absolutely delicious. Everyone in the party was drooling for the cake and had more than one piece. It was truly upto the mark and my expectations. Will truly recommend this Cake baker to everyone i know.
Visionaryodain stephenson
Verified Order
5 months ago
Professional, attention to detail, total visionary . The staff is amazing. My go to for all special event . They come highly recommend
Red velvet rum bliss Kk
Verified Order
5 months ago
Love the flavor and the decor is on point
Best cakes Tichina
Verified Order
5 months ago
One of the best icing I've tasted is from elegantly baked, very moist and soft highly recommended for any occasions for the best results.
Beautiful and Delicious Christina
Verified Order
5 months ago
Birthday SpectacularTracy-Ann
Verified Order
5 months ago
A beautiful blue cake with all the perfect trimmings was personally delivered by Shen on my special day! It was truly elegantly baked. The taste and texture was just right. All I did was to express the color I wanted and Shen delivered. The cupcakes from Elegantly baked are amazing as well!
Tracy-Ann
Verified Order
6 months ago
ABSOLUTELY STUNNING Alisa
Verified Order
6 months ago
If you’re looking for a AUTHENTIC FRESH, delicious AND marvelous looking cake this is the right bakery I can definitely tell it’s crafted from scratch from the first bite I took. It’s fluffy and soft as a cake should be. All my guests devoured everything and asked for more. The service surpassed what I expected plus more and my dream cake and cupcakes for my daughter was brought to life!
Vanilla Cake Tiffany
Verified Order
5 months ago
Beautifully crafted cake in celebration of my newborn child. It was definitely elegantly baked. You absolutely nailed it.
Beautiful Karine
Verified Order
6 months ago
The cake decor was absolutely gorgeous and the taste was delicious. You did a fantastic job. Happy and satisfied customer.
Cupcakes and 🎂 CakeLeonie
Verified Order
6 months ago
For my mother's 86th birthday I purchased a birthday cake from Elegantly Baked hoping it will be just a nice small cake with no big expectations. I was pleasantly surprised with the decor of this fancy cake and not to exaggerate but the tease was everything to talk about. My mother, my son, my granddaughter, and I and the dog (4 generations) enjoyed eating every bit of that cake 🎂 👍 👏
35th Birthday Natalie
Verified Order
6 months ago
When I say my birthday cake was amazing !! It was amazing ! I told her my vision and she executed every detail. I was brought to tears seeing how beautiful my cake was and you can tell it was made with love :-)
Birthday Reese
Verified Order
6 months ago
The design was beyond amazing! Shenny has a special gift of design and has an eye for elegance. She goes above and beyond any expectation. Cake always tastes good and moist !
Delicious Fifi
Verified Order
6 months ago
I ordered these pull apart cup cakes for a special person, and it exceeded my expectations. The decor, the taste, and the overall presentation was remarkable. Thank you Bakesy for doing your big one on these cup cakes!!
Glam cupcakes Matt
Verified Order
7 months ago
Honestly the best tasting cupcake I’ve ever had! The owner was very responsive and understanding to my needs, and very fast! I would recommend this business to anyone who needs a beautiful cake or cupcakes.
Bailey’s cupcake Abi
Verified Order
7 months ago
The cupcakes were phenomenal and not to mention they were not overly sweet. We got our cupcakes on time and Shenny was so helpful and attentive to details.
Amazing job on my mother’s birthday cake! Natalie
Verified Order
6 months ago
The design alone with beyond amazing ! I gave her the colors I wanted and she delivered with the design. Cake tasted amazing as well ! Not too sweet and not dry. Very professional and proficient
CupcakesGarfield
Verified Order
7 months ago
Thanks again the order was amazing at a great price and the kids really loved it.
CakeComile
Verified Order
7 months ago
Elegantly baked I just wanna say continue to do the good works on your cakes first let me say this Me and my family is not a cake person. We would always order cakes for birthdays. and we would make sure that it’s all done but this time around I order a cake from elegantly baked and it was not like that I find myself storing the cake in container. The cake was so good. It was not too sweet and was just so perfect. so if you’re looking for A cake for any event I’m telling you this cake is highly recommended
Valarie
Verified Order
8 months ago
Stacyann
Verified Order
8 months ago

Follow us!