Ratings & Reviews

The cookies were absolutely wonderful,fresh, delicious, and beautifully made! Everyone loved them. Working with Kaytlyn was a pleasure. She was friendly, professional, easy to communicate with, and made the whole process seamless. I highly recommend her and will definitely order again for future events!

Wish we ordered more of these amazing cookies! They were a hit at our graduation party! They were fresh and delicious! Kaytlyn is always so accommodating, especially with deliveries! She is our cookie lady! Hands down the best cookies around! Can’t wait to place our next order! Thanks again Kaytlyn!

This is the second time I’ve had Katelyn create cookies for an event - She makes your vision come to life! The process is easy and she’s always responsive. Highly recommend her and her talent!

I got five dozen of the most perfect Taylor Swift themed graduation cookies. Everyone commented on how beautiful they were and how delicious. Thank you!!!

Cookies were absolutely perfect AND they tasted amazing! Please share on you page.

I've gone to Kaytlyn a few times for her delicious cookies for either the kit for families to decorate or to have personalized cookies for whatever occasion. Kaytlyn does not disappoint!! She is very accommodating for delivery and she delivers with a smile. Every. Single. Time. I know where to go for delicious cookies and I love the fact I'm supporting a local business!!

Kaytlyn always is up for a challenge and I have given her a few! From a puzzle cookie to the villain cookies she made for a small getaway with my daughter and grandkids! She is amazing in all that she does!

The cookies were a huge hit. Not only are they absolutely beautiful, they are delicious. Perfectly packaged, and she delivers them right to my house. Her prices are also extremely fair. Thank you so much for being able to squeeze us in during such a busy time of year!!!

Cookies were both gorgeous & delicious! kaytlyn is awesome. Great communication, very fair pricing. AND she delivers! All around great experience. Will be ordering again from her & recommending to friends and family!

Kaytlyn’s cookies exceeded expectation, they were precious and delicious! We were all so thrilled, and they were boxed and presented so beautifully too! Thank you for making our event so special!❤️

I ordered 2 dozen cookies for a baby shower. Not only were they cute, they were yummy. The theme of the shower was baby cowboy and Kaytlyn matched it perfectly. I will be ordering cookies again for sure.

These cookies were almost too pretty to eat… The details were unreal, every design was so perfectly done.They taste even better than they look. Soft, flavorful, and absolutely delicious!

I placed my order and it was simple we stayed in contact and she delivered right to my work! They were exactly what I wanted.

I had cookie and cake pops made for my daughter's bridal shower. They came out better than I excepted! Everyone commented on them! I would highly recommend.

Kate made cookies for my friend’s bachelorette weekend! I wasn’t sure what I wanted but we had a theme and her wedding colors. Kate, as always came through with beautiful (and delicious) cookies. The bride loved them!!

I ordered and received the most perfect stitch cookies for a birthday. Thank you so much!

Thank you for your phenomenal work as always!!! Our staff loved them!

Everyone raved about how delicious & perfect the cookies were. Kaytlyn never disappoints, I recommend her highly!!

Kaytlyn’s decorated cookies look like beautiful works of art that you are almost afraid to eat but they are to delicious not to! Cookies have become a staple at all our parties and holidays!

Kaytlyn’s a miracle worker! I ordered unicorn and rainbow themed cookies for my 3&5 year olds’ party and they were incredible, elevating the theme of the party and bringing smiles to everyone’s faces. I also had a special request and Kaytlyn really knocked it out of the park with that one!

Kaytlyn always does an amazing job! She does great detail work on each design. Everyone commented on how great the cookies were. She even gave me a thank you cookie with my order to eat.

The cookies were a hit! The designs were immaculate. Pleasure to work with as always!

I was looking for custom cookies for my son that was graduating high school from a welding program. Kaytlyn came up with a great design and everyone at the party was so amazed by them. They tasted great too!

Kaytlyn always goes above and beyond to ensure my vision for the cookies is just how I imagined! They’re beautiful and taste great too!! I can’t wait to order more for upcoming events!

As always Kaytlyn goes above and beyond to accommodate each year’s theme! She is also always willing to work with us when it comes allergies and dietary restrictions. Her cookies are always a hit!

I contacted Kaytlyn on the recommendation of some friends, for custom birthday cookies for my daughter. I gave her the theme (Sesame Street) and a couple of the characters to include, but left the design up to her. She knocked it out of the park! The cookies were adorable and delicious. The designs were amazingly done - you could really tell how much time, effort and care she put into making them. We will definitely be coming back for our future cookie needs and recommending her to friends! Thank you Kaytlyn!

I can't say enough good things about Kaytlyn's cookies! My husband is absolutely obsessed with the chocolate-covered Oreos. The chocolate is rich and smooth, and the Oreos inside are perfectly crunchy. We also ordered the Christmas cookie platter, and it was equally delicious—so festive and full of flavor. We've ordered multiple times, and every batch has been consistently amazing. If you haven't tried them yet, you're missing out on a true treat! Highly recommend!

We ordered the holiday cookie kit and it was everything it promised to be. The kids loved decorating with the frosting and sprinkles and they were delicious to eat after. The kit was delivered right to our door making it easy and convenient. We will definitely order from Kaytlyn again.

I keep coming back to Kaytlyn’s sugar cookies for special occasions because they remind me of the cookies my grandmother used to lovingly bake and decorate for every season. Not only are the cookies tasty and beautiful, deliveries are prompt and the packaging is impeccable. DIY decorating kits offer this busy family everything we need a to skip the hassle of baking and still make sweet holiday memories custom decorating delicious sugar cookies.

I ordered the chocolate chip & M&M cookie cake for Halloween and it was so delicious! I have ordered from Katlyn many times and am NEVER disappointed, her desserts are always a crown pleaser.

Kaytlyn always does such a great job! I’ve ordered a handful of times and the cookies are always a hit with everyone and she does such a great job doing whatever theme I throw at her. Highly recommend!

Awesome product, super affordable!

Kaytlyn’s cookies are the best! I have ordered a few times from her and she does an outstanding job! The cookie to frosting ratio is spot on. They are not to sweet but sweet enough. Highly recommend

We got custom cookies for our wedding and they were fabulous! Totally exceeded our expectations and made our weekend so perfect!

I ordered farm themed cookies for my son’s birthday and the cookies looked AND tasted amazing. Everyone loved them. Would definitely order again for future events!

She outdoes herself every single time i order !! Always exceeds my expectations! She’s truly a creative genius with cookies! And theyre SO delicious!

Huge success! She did a phenomenal job bringing ideas to life! I said run away with it and she nailed it! The delicate time and care she takes making each individual cookie is an art and i commend her for that! HIGHLY recommend for ANY idea for cookies you have!

Amazing product and designs! Delicious! Kaytlyn is great to work with! Highly recommend and will use again!