Featured Products
All Purpose Ambrosia
$20.00
click for description
Basic Batch
$30.00
click for description
Classic Colors
$40.00
click for description
Delectable Delights
$50.00
click for description
Enticing Eats
$60.00
click for description
Frosted Finesse
Starting at $80.00
click for description
About
Cookies On Call was born from a love of baking and caregiving. Inspired by family recipes and work as a nurse, Caitlin started sharing handcrafted cookies to bring comfort and joy. Today, we deliver sweetness for every occasion.
Capabilities & Pricing
Cookies are sold by the dozen, and pricing ranges from $20-$80 per dozen, depending on number of colors of icing, piping detail, lettering, specialty embellishments, and fully custom sets.
❤️🍪❤️
Deposits & Final Payment
A 50% non-refundable deposit is required to secure your cookie order and confirm your spot on our schedule. The remaining balance is due in full no later than 48 hours before your scheduled pickup. If payment is not received by the deadline, your order may be canceled.
Thank you for understanding! This policy helps us ensure each order is made with the care and attention it deserves.
❤️🍪❤️
Policies
FAQs
⸻ Thank You for Supporting Cookies On Call! We’re so glad you’re here! Below are some quick answers to common questions to help make your cookie ordering experience as smooth (and sweet) as possible. ❤️🍪 ⸻ 1. How do I place an order? Simply browse our menu, select your cookies, add any inspiration photoschoose a pickup date, and check out—all right here on Bakesy! 2. How far in advance should I order? We recommend placing your order at least 2 weeks in advance to guarantee availability. Need cookies sooner? Feel free to message us and we’ll do our best to make it happen! 3. Where do I pick up my order? Pickup is in West Greeley. The exact address will be shared after your order is confirmed and your deposit is received. 4. Do you offer custom or bulk orders? Yes! For custom designs, party platters, or bulk orders, please message us directly through Bakesy or contact us via email (cookiesoncallnoco@gmail.com). 5. Are your cookies nut-free or allergy-friendly? Some of our cookies contain nuts or are made in a kitchen that handles common allergens. Please check individual product descriptions or reach out with specific allergy concerns before ordering. 6. What payment methods do you accept? All payments are handled securely through Bakesy. Major credit cards, Apple Pay, and Google Pay are accepted. 8. Can I cancel or change my order? Cancellations or changes must be made at least 48 hours before your pickup time. Please message us as soon as possible if you need help with your order.