Favorites
Bliss Sampler Box
Our Bliss sampler box is the perfect way to try a little bit of everything. You get two cupcakes, including one banana pudding and one seasonal cupcake of our choosing, 2 cookie bites topped with buttercream, two cookie sandwiches of our choice and two buckeyes. This sweet sampler box is only $30.  if you have any particular preference on cupcake, cookie bite or cookie sandwich, please put it in the box at checkout. We will do our best to accommodate you.
$30.00
click for description
Biscoff Cookie Butter Cake 8 Inch
The biscoff cookie butter, 8 in. double layer cake starts with French vanilla cake and has a Biscoff cookie butter filling. Topped with vanilla buttercream and a Biscoff cookie drizzle and Biscoff cookies. 8 in. double layer serves approximately 10 to 14 guests. 
$65.00
click for description
Cookies & Cream 8 Inch Cake
Our cookies and cream cake has two options… A cookies and cream, white cake base with chocolate buttercream, Oreo cookie filling, and Oreo cookies on top. Or you can choose a chocolate fudge cake base with Oreo cookie filling, and chocolate buttercream with Oreo cookies on top. Please let us know which version you would like when placing your order. This cake comes in two sizes either a 6 inch double layer or an 8 inch double layer. The 6 inch double layer serves approximately 8 to 10 guest. The 8 inch double layer serves approximately 10 to 14 guests.
$65.00
click for description
Chocolate Delight Cake Shooters
Our chocolate delight cake shooters are layers of chocolate fudge cake with chocolate pudding baked into the batter, topped with vanilla buttercream and a milk chocolate bar and chocolate shavings. Our cake shooters are the perfect sweet treat for any upscale party or gathering! 3 ounce cups are filled with any of our cupcake flavor combinations and are layered with cake, buttercream, fillings, and toppings. These are served with a spoon. 12 for $50. These can be customized per order.
$50.00
click for description
Cookie Sandwich Variety Box!
Our cookie sandwich variety box includes six of our famous cookie sandwiches! Your box will include a variety of the following: oatmeal cream pies, sea salt chocolate chip cookie sandwiches, peanut butter Bestie cookie sandwiches, and our double fudge cookie sandwiches. If you have a preference on what variety you would like please add that to the box when you are ordering. We do our best to accommodate when we can. 
$25.00
click for description
Strawberry Lovers 8 Inch Cake
Our strawberry lovers cake starts with strawberry cake and has a strawberry pie filling. Topped with vanilla buttercream and white swirls with fresh strawberries. This cake is available in two sizes. A 6 inch double layer and an 8 inch double layer. Our 6 inch double layer serves approximately 8 to 10 guest. Our 8 inch double layer cake serves approximately 10 to 14 guest.
$65.00
click for description
Biscoff Banana Pudding Cupcakes (filled)
We had to jump on the latest TikTok trend of all things, Biscoff cookie! This cupcake, starts with our classic banana pudding cupcake, and it’s filled with cookie butter and topped with our homemade vanilla buttercream , cookie butter drizzle , cookie crumbs, and a Biscoff cookie!
$38.00
click for description
Caramel Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes per Dozen
Our caramel pumpkin spice cupcakes start with a spice cake that can be filled with Knox’s Artisan Table, pumpkin butter and topped with our homemade caramel buttercream and finished with a caramel drizzle. 12 for $38. 
$38.00
click for description
Coconut Cream Pie Cupcakes
Our coconut cream pie cupcakes start with a French vanilla cake that has coconut cream pudding, and real coconut milk baked right into the batter. Topped with vanilla buttercream, graham cracker crumbs, and toasted sweetened coconut flakes. 
$38.00
click for description
Chocolate Hazelnut Bliss Cupcakes
Our chocolate hazelnut bliss cupcake start with a chocolate fudge cake with a Nutella filling and topped with chocolate buttercream, Nutella drizzle and a Ferrero Rocher candy. The perfect chocolate indulgence! 
$38.00
click for description
Weekly School Pre-orders
Oatmeal Cream Pies 2 Pack
2 pack of our oatmeal, cream pies. Each pie consist of two of our soft and chewy oatmeal cookies and filled with a marshmallow buttercream. 
$7.00
click for description
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Our oatmeal cream pies start with two soft and chewy oatmeal cookies and are filled with a marshmallow buttercream. $4 each or 2 for $7. 
$4.00
click for description
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches 2 Pack
2 pack sea salt, chocolate chip cookie sandwiches with a vanilla buttercream filling. 
$7.00
click for description
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Our sea salt, chocolate chip cookie sandwich starts with two sea salt, chocolate chip cookies, and filled with our homemade vanilla buttercream. $4 each or two for $7.00. 
$4.00
click for description
Double Fudge Chip Cookie Sandwich
Our double fudge chip cookie sandwich includes two double fudge chocolate chip cookies with homemade chocolate, buttercream filling. 
$4.00
click for description
Double Fudge Chip Cookie Sandwiches 2 Pack
Double fudge chip cookie sandwich includes two double fudge chip cookies with homemade chocolate, buttercream filling. 
$7.00
click for description
Peanut Butter Bestie Cookie Sandwich 
Peanut butter Bestie cookie sandwich includes two peanut butter chip cookies filled with homemade peanut butter buttercream. 
$4.00
click for description
Peanut Butter, Bestie Cookie Sandwiches 2 Pack
2 pack peanut butter Bestie cookie sandwiches includes peanut butter chip cookies filled with homemade peanut butter buttercream. 
$7.00
click for description
Caramel Cutie Cookie Sandwich
Our caramel cutie cookie sandwiches start with two sugar cookies and are filled with homemade caramel buttercream. 
$4.00
click for description
Caramel Cutie Cookie Sandwiches 2 Pack
2 pack caramel cutie cookie sandwiches include sugar cookies filled with our homemade caramel buttercream.
$7.00
click for description
Variety Cookie Sandwich Box
Our variety cookie sandwich box includes a variety of six cookie sandwiches. If you have a preference on which sandwiches, please list it on your order. 
$25.00
click for description
Chocolate Hazelnut Cake Cup
Our chocolate hazelnut cake is layers of Nutella with chocolate fudge cake, topped with chocolate buttercream, Nutella drizzle, and a Ferrero Rocher candy. Pure chocolate indulgence! 
$6.00
click for description
Caramel Pumpkin Spice Cake Cup
Our caramel pumpkin spice cake cup is layers of pumpkin spice cake with pumpkin butter, caramel buttercream, and caramel drizzle. Perfect fall treat! 
$6.00
click for description
Biscoff Cookie Butter Cake Cup
Biscoff cookie butter cake cup starts with an 8 ounce cup with two French vanilla cupcakes and layers of Biscoff cookie butter, Biscoff cookie crumbs and topped with a Biscoff cookie. $6 each or two for $11. Discount to be applied at checkout. 
$6.00
click for description
Peanut Butter Bliss Cup
Peanut butter bliss cup consist of layers of chocolate fudge cake with homemade peanut butter buttercream and topped with chocolate drizzle and a reese peanut butter cup. 
$6.00
click for description
About
At Buttered Bliss, baking is more than a business- it's a family passion. I am a proud mom of 2 and a lifelong lover of all things sweet, baking side by side with my husband, Shawn, in our licensed and insured home kitchen. Every treat we make is baked fresh with love, rich butter, and a touch of southern charm. From classic favorites to fully customized creations, we pour our hearts into each order, making your special moments just a little sweeter.
Capabilities & Pricing
Order & Payment Policy
All orders are reviewed before confirmation. Once approved, an invoice will be sent back to you and must be paid in full via Square or Venmo to confirm your order.
Orders typically take 1–3 days to complete (longer for large or custom orders).
All payments are final.
Free local delivery or porch pickup is available— you will be able to pick your preference at checkout when you pick your payment method. Please provide a valid email, phone number, and address when placing your order. Thank you for supporting our small business. 
Current Specials!!!
BACK TO SCHOOL SPECIAL!!!📚✏️🚌✂️📓📌✏️📖
Get a variety box of cookie sandwiches on sale for a limited time:
6 for $20 or 12 for $34 (price will be adjusted once your order is placed)
Can’t decide what to order? Check out our Bliss sampler box! It’s the perfect mix of sweet treats so you can try a little bit of everything! $30.