Ratings & Reviews

Cookies were so cute. I provided inspo pictures and the cookies turned out exactly what I was looking for. The taste and quality of the cookies were delicious as well.

We had cookies made for a baby shower and they were so incredibly beautiful. We got exactly what we envisioned and couldn’t be happier. I will totally use you again. Thank you!

Cookies tasted great! Presentation 10/10

I was so happy with my order everything looked perfect and tasted really good! I received so many compliments on the cookies!

Wow, expectations were blown away! My son’s 3rd birthday theme was paw patrol and his cookies were beyond perfect. The characters were spot on and the taste just unreal! I had guests asking for cookie info because they were just amazing! Will definitely be a repeat customer!

I contacted Erin at Buttercream Bakery to make some custom cookies for my husband’s birthday. Right from the start Erin was awesome to work with! Kept in constant contact with me and my ideas. Giving helpful feedback. Her cookies turned out incredible!! Exactly what I envisioned. My guests were absolutely amazed at the work she did and the cookies were a hit!! Needless to say I will definitely be back for my next event. Thanks Erin for all your work on our party!

Erin made cookies for my daughter’s first birthday and I can say they were the most beautiful cookies I’ve ever seen! I was thrilled with how they turned out. I sent an inspo picture and she delivered better than I could have imagined. Plus they were delicious. Thank you for making my daughter’s day extra special.

The cookies were great The design was very detailed. I will definitely be ordering again.

We ordered custom Hot Wheels theme sugar cookies and they were AMAZING! Not only were they adorable and detailed, but they tasted just as good as they looked. So soft and perfectly sweet. Everyone at the party couldn’t stop talking about them. Highly recommend for any event!

So easy to work with and great product! Copied the inspo pictures exactly and was a joy to work with.

I loved how response and how much communication there was throughout the whole process! I had the best experience and the cookies were ADORABLE and delicious! I have already recommended to several friends

Erin did amazing capturing the theme for my baby shower. The cookies looked amazing, we didn’t want to eat them. But, they tasted just as amazing.

The cutest cookies that have incredible flavor!

Attention to detail is on point! Not only with the cookies, but with the packaging as well, which included the ingredients/nutrition info. You can tell Erin puts her heart into EVERY order. We cannot wait to try more!

The cookies were absolutely delicious and looked amazing! Will definitely order again

My mom’s birthday cookies turned out so good. As always! Erin does such a good job decorating and the cookies taste so good. My go to for cookies for any occasion!

These cookies are always a hit. Delicious flavor and texture and beautifully decorated.

This is my second order with buttercream bakery and both have been fantastic!! Erin is so kind and quick to reply, her ordering and pickup process is made easy and she always takes my ideas and makes them perfect! Her new gluten free cookies are amazing and we are so thankful for this option as quite a few people in my family have a sensitivity. We highly recommend buttercream bakery!!

The cookies for my baby shower were ABSOLUTELY adorable and Erin was so amazing every step of the way with communication and organization so I knew exactly what I was getting. The cookies also tasted so delicious and I LOVED the extra attention to detail to include the ingredients on the packaging of each cookie, an extra car cookie for tasting, and cookie care card. She made sure every little detail was PERFECTION! Will 10/10 recommend to everyone and be ordering again!

The cookies came out better than I could have ever imagined!!!!! And the cookies were delicious!! I am so thankful I found her just a few weeks before my event! Thank you!!! I highly recommend her!

These cookies were amazing! The details and the flavor all 10/10!! Will be ordering for more events

I’ve ordered from buttercream bakery twice and already have an order in for my moms birthday in a month! The cookies are beautiful and delicious! Erin has gone above and beyond with the design inspo and provides quality cookies and timely service! I am So happy I found her!

Cuuuuutest elf on shelf cookies! Kids enjoyed them! I will definitely order again!

The elf cookies I bought were amazing!! Not only was the design soooo cute and perfect but the cookies tasted amazing as well!!

The cookies and cupcakes are top notch and Erin is kind and professional.

Amazing!!! Will be ordering again!

The cookies were beautiful as well as tasty. Thank you for making our day special.

Not only are these the most beautiful cookies I’ve ever had but they tasted even better than they looked. Would re-order 10000000x❤️

Ordered custom printed cookies for an event with my daughter's theatre troupe and will ABSOLUTELY be a repeat customer! They looked amazing and tasted better!

Got Cars theme cookies for my son’s 3rd birthday, she did great on decorating them and they were also tasty! Def would order again(:

Ordered Dia de los muertos cookies. They came out beautiful and delicious. The design is exactly what I ordered, thank you.

i ordered 3 dozen cookies for my kids birthday party, they were SUCH a hit. we didn’t have any left over (💔) that’s ok they were bomb. spot on with the character designs and they were DELICIOUS 😋❤️

She made us THE BEST MOST DELICIOUS, CUTE COOKIES we could’ve ever imagined! Everyone loved my daughter’s 1st birthday cookies! I plan on ordering again 😍

Buttercream Bakery made the cutest custom sugar cookies for my twins 2nd birthday party, and I couldn’t be happier with how they turned out! The designs were exactly what I asked for — adorable, detailed, and you can really tell she puts so much care and creativity into her work. Not only were the cookies beautiful, but they tasted SO good. Perfect texture, not overly sweet, and everyone at the party asked where they came from. The whole process was super smooth, too. Communication was quick and friendly, and pickup was easy. I felt really taken care of from start to finish. She was also incredibly flexible and accommodating with design choices/color palette. I’ll definitely be ordering from Buttercream Bakery again. Highly recommend for any event!

We had an amazing experience with this bakery! They provided a super fast turnaround, the pricing was very fair, and the cookies were an absolute hit—they were the first thing to run out at our event. Highly recommend for both quality and service!

Loved the cookies so much

Erin is so easy to work with! She saved me with cupcakes for my daughter's graduation in May when someone else bailed last minute and I have been using her since! She did such an awesome job on the baby shower cookies and cupcakes I just ordered. Everyone LOVED them, they were all delicious!