What’s Popular?
Large Bakery Style Cookies
1 dozen large bakery style cookies (4 oz)
$36.00
click for description
Cupcakes
$36 a dozen $46 a dozen for deluxe Includes 2-3 colors Add special piping for +$5 per dozen Add cupcake toppers starting at $10 per dozen Add mini sugar cookie toppers starting at $36 per dozen Includes basic sprinkles/glitter 1 flavor per dozen
Starting at $36.00
click for description
Cookie Cake (8 Inch)
cookie cake with buttercream frosting. Can personalize with different colors, and can add either mini sugar cookie toppers or full sized sugar cookie toppers to personalize. Mini sugar cookie toppers: $3 per cookie Full sized sugar cookie toppers: $4.50 per cookie Comes with buttercream frosting border (naked) or can cover top in frosting no additional charge Thick cookie Cookie cake: $35 Can do either circle or heart shaped, 8 inch. Add a second tier for additional $20 Servings: 8-10
Starting at $35.00
click for description
Custom Sugar Cookies
Handpiped custom sugar cookies for any occasion! 3.5-4 inches Prices starting at $50 per dozen (refer to pricing sheet in my highlighted section or message me for better guidance) Individually wrapped and heat sealed with ingredients labeled on back
Starting at $50.00
click for description
Smash Cake (6 Inch)
Simple, 1-3 colors Two tier Feeds 4-6 Add cake topper starting at +$10 Includes basic sprinkles, glitter if desired No designs, simple frosting and border
Starting at $45.00
click for description
Mini Ghost 4 Pack
Mini ghost 4 pack 4 mini ghost cookies in a cute cookie sleeve Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$12.00
click for description
Cafe Style Cookies
1 dozen cafe style cookies (standard size) 2.5 oz
$24.00
click for description
Mini Cupcakes
$36 per 2 dozen $46 per 2 dozen for deluxe Includes 2-3 colors Add special piping for +$5 per dozen Add cupcake toppers starting at $10 per dozen Includes basic sprinkles/glitter 1 flavor per 2 dozen
Starting at $36.00
click for description
Cookie Cake (9x13 Rectangle)
cookie cake with buttercream frosting. Can personalize with different colors, and can add either mini sugar cookie toppers or full sized sugar cookie toppers to personalize. Mini sugar cookie toppers: $3 per cookie Full sized sugar cookie toppers: $4.50 per cookie White chocolate lettering included to personalize/add message Cookie cake: $55 Rectangle Add a second tier for additional $40 Cake can have frosting around the border (naked) or entire top frosted Servings: 15-20
Starting at $55.00
click for description
Mini Custom Sugar Cookies
Handpiped custom sugar cookies for any occasion! Mini 2-2.5 inches 2 dozen minimum if only ordering minis Prices starting at $36 per dozen (refer to pricing sheet in my highlighted section or message me for better guidance) Individually wrapped and heat sealed with ingredients labeled on back
Starting at $36.00
click for description
Spooky Cookie
Spooky Cookie Long cookie in a cute cookie sleeve Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$7.00
click for description
100% Printed Sugar Cookies
100% printed sugar cookies using my edible ink cookie printer - prints directly onto cookies Great for logos or photos! No handpiped details, must be all printed 3.5-4 inches Individually wrapped and heat sealed with ingredients labeled on back
Starting at $45.00
click for description
Cookie Pops
Buttercream frosting Chocolate chip only 1-3 colors Simple drizzle/sprinkles/glitter
Starting at $48.00
click for description
You’ve Been Boo’d
You’ve been boo’d single cookie Festive cookie in a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$6.00
click for description
Cookie Cups (2 Dozen)
Mini cookie cups with buttercream frosting on top 1-3 different colors Basic sprinkles/glitter 1 order = 2 dozen
Starting at $40.00
click for description
Personalized Ghost Kid
Cute personalized ghost kid In a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Personalizable - girl or boy ghost, add a name on there as well Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$8.00
click for description
Sugar Cookie Sample
Interested in purchasing a dozen (or a couple) sugar cookies from me but wanting to see if they taste as good as they look first? I got you! $4 for 1 full sized sugar cookie (sugar cookie with my plain white almond/vanilla icing) or $4 for 3 mini sugar cookies with icing Unfortunately I don’t offer samples for gluten sensitive cookies at this time Specialty flavors are not available for samples
$4.00
click for description
Personalizable Trick Or Treat Ghost
Personalizable trick or treat ghost In a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Personalizable- add a name on the ghost Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$8.00
click for description
Personalizable Candy Corn
Personalizable candy corn In a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Personalizable- add a name on the candy corn Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$7.00
click for description
PYO Halloween Cookie
Paint your own (PYO) Halloween themed cookie Comes with an edible paint palette and brush Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Images will vary - will be halloween themed Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$6.00
click for description
Standard Cookie Decorating Kit
Standard cookie decorating kit 6 vanilla bean sugar cookies in various Halloween themed shapes 3 bags of vanilla almond royal icing 1 decorating scribe 1 container of Halloween themed sprinkles Instruction sheet
$20.00
click for description
Deluxe Cookie Decorating Kit
Deluxe cookie decorating kit 12 vanilla bean sugar cookies in various Halloween themed shapes 5 bags of vanilla almond royal icing 2 decorating scribes 2 container of Halloween themed sprinkles Instruction sheet
$40.00
click for description
Mystery Dumpling Surprise
1 mystery dumpling cookie in a box Comes in various colors and designs - will you get the golden dumpling? Golden dumpling will also come with a surprise coupon Standard vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing Not personalizable
$8.00
click for description
Halloween Presale 2026
Mini Ghost 4 Pack
Mini ghost 4 pack 4 mini ghost cookies in a cute cookie sleeve Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$12.00
click for description
Spooky Cookie
Spooky Cookie Long cookie in a cute cookie sleeve Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$7.00
click for description
You’ve Been Boo’d
You’ve been boo’d single cookie Festive cookie in a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$6.00
click for description
Personalized Ghost Kid
Cute personalized ghost kid In a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Personalizable - girl or boy ghost, add a name on there as well Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$8.00
click for description
Personalizable Trick Or Treat Ghost
Personalizable trick or treat ghost In a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Personalizable- add a name on the ghost Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$8.00
click for description
Personalizable Candy Corn
Personalizable candy corn In a bag with a bow Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Personalizable- add a name on the candy corn Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$7.00
click for description
PYO Halloween Cookie
Paint your own (PYO) Halloween themed cookie Comes with an edible paint palette and brush Comes with a gift tag Cookie backer/bow and gift tag may vary depending on availability Images will vary - will be halloween themed Heat sealed/ingredients labeled on back Not customizable Standard flavor - vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing
$6.00
click for description
Standard Cookie Decorating Kit
Standard cookie decorating kit 6 vanilla bean sugar cookies in various Halloween themed shapes 3 bags of vanilla almond royal icing 1 decorating scribe 1 container of Halloween themed sprinkles Instruction sheet
$20.00
click for description
Deluxe Cookie Decorating Kit
Deluxe cookie decorating kit 12 vanilla bean sugar cookies in various Halloween themed shapes 5 bags of vanilla almond royal icing 2 decorating scribes 2 container of Halloween themed sprinkles Instruction sheet
$40.00
click for description
Mystery Dumpling Surprise
1 mystery dumpling cookie in a box Comes in various colors and designs - will you get the golden dumpling? Golden dumpling will also come with a surprise coupon Standard vanilla bean with vanilla almond royal icing Not personalizable
$8.00
click for description
Custom Sugar Cookies
Custom Sugar Cookies
Handpiped custom sugar cookies for any occasion! 3.5-4 inches Prices starting at $50 per dozen (refer to pricing sheet in my highlighted section or message me for better guidance) Individually wrapped and heat sealed with ingredients labeled on back
Starting at $50.00
click for description
Mini Custom Sugar Cookies
Handpiped custom sugar cookies for any occasion! Mini 2-2.5 inches 2 dozen minimum if only ordering minis Prices starting at $36 per dozen (refer to pricing sheet in my highlighted section or message me for better guidance) Individually wrapped and heat sealed with ingredients labeled on back
Starting at $36.00
click for description
100% Printed Sugar Cookies
100% printed sugar cookies using my edible ink cookie printer - prints directly onto cookies Great for logos or photos! No handpiped details, must be all printed 3.5-4 inches Individually wrapped and heat sealed with ingredients labeled on back
Starting at $45.00
click for description
PYO Cookie
Paint your own cookies Any printed outline design you’d like on a cookie, sold à la carte, comes with edible paint palette and brush Available for pickup on weekends only - perfect activity for kids!
$6.00
click for description
Sugar Cookie Sample
Interested in purchasing a dozen (or a couple) sugar cookies from me but wanting to see if they taste as good as they look first? I got you! $4 for 1 full sized sugar cookie (sugar cookie with my plain white almond/vanilla icing) or $4 for 3 mini sugar cookies with icing Unfortunately I don’t offer samples for gluten sensitive cookies at this time Specialty flavors are not available for samples
$4.00
click for description
Cookie Cakes
Cookie Cake (8 Inch)
cookie cake with buttercream frosting. Can personalize with different colors, and can add either mini sugar cookie toppers or full sized sugar cookie toppers to personalize. Mini sugar cookie toppers: $3 per cookie Full sized sugar cookie toppers: $4.50 per cookie Comes with buttercream frosting border (naked) or can cover top in frosting no additional charge Thick cookie Cookie cake: $35 Can do either circle or heart shaped, 8 inch. Add a second tier for additional $20 Servings: 8-10
Starting at $35.00
click for description
Cookie Cake (9x13 Rectangle)
cookie cake with buttercream frosting. Can personalize with different colors, and can add either mini sugar cookie toppers or full sized sugar cookie toppers to personalize. Mini sugar cookie toppers: $3 per cookie Full sized sugar cookie toppers: $4.50 per cookie White chocolate lettering included to personalize/add message Cookie cake: $55 Rectangle Add a second tier for additional $40 Cake can have frosting around the border (naked) or entire top frosted Servings: 15-20
Starting at $55.00
click for description
Drop Cookies
Large Bakery Style Cookies
1 dozen large bakery style cookies (4 oz)
$36.00
click for description
Cafe Style Cookies
1 dozen cafe style cookies (standard size) 2.5 oz
$24.00
click for description
Cookie Bars
Cookie bars - thick cut cookie bars, 12 ct
$36.00
click for description
Cookie Cups (2 Dozen)
Mini cookie cups with buttercream frosting on top 1-3 different colors Basic sprinkles/glitter 1 order = 2 dozen
Starting at $40.00
click for description
Cupcakes
Cupcakes
$36 a dozen $46 a dozen for deluxe Includes 2-3 colors Add special piping for +$5 per dozen Add cupcake toppers starting at $10 per dozen Add mini sugar cookie toppers starting at $36 per dozen Includes basic sprinkles/glitter 1 flavor per dozen
Starting at $36.00
click for description
Mini Cupcakes
$36 per 2 dozen $46 per 2 dozen for deluxe Includes 2-3 colors Add special piping for +$5 per dozen Add cupcake toppers starting at $10 per dozen Includes basic sprinkles/glitter 1 flavor per 2 dozen
Starting at $36.00
click for description
About
Buttercream Creations LLC
Licensed Cottage Home Baker based in San Tan Valley, AZ. Custom sugar cookies, treats and more!
Capabilities & Pricing
50% of amount due a week before order pickup and the other 50% is due the day of pickup before you come to pick up.