After much thought and many heartfelt conversations, we want to share that Bakery 404 will be closing its doors on April 1, 2026 as our family prepares to move out of state. 💛 What started as a small passion project turned into something so much more because of this incredible community. Your support, kind words, orders, and encouragement have meant the world to our family. Being part of your birthdays, celebrations, holidays, and everyday moments has truly been an honor. We are deeply grateful for every single person who supported Bakery 404 along the way. You helped turn flour, butter, and sugar into something meaningful. 🥐✨ We’ll be baking and sharing a few more things between now and closing day, so stay tuned if you’d like to grab some final treats before we go. From the bottom of our hearts—thank you for supporting our little bakery dream. 💛
×

Bagels

Sourdough Bagel (4-pack)
Sourdough Bagel (4-pack)

🥯 Sourdough Bagels (Classic, Artisan)

Hand-crafted sourdough bagels made with long-fermented wild yeast for a deep, complex flavor and chewy texture. Boiled then baked for that classic bagel crust, with a tender, airy interior. Naturally leavened, easier to digest, and made in small batches for maximum freshness.

Perfect toasted with cream cheese, butter, or your favorite sandwich fillings.

$10.00
click for description
Sourdough Bialy (Dozen)
Sourdough Bialy (Dozen)

A flavorful cousin of the bagel — soft, chewy, and baked (never boiled) — each one has a savory center that’s impossible to resist.

✨ Available in:

🧄 Garlic & Cheese Blend

🧈 Garlic Butter, Olive & Cheese

🌿 Pesto & Cheese

Each bialy is made from our signature sourdough for that perfect tang and texture. Perfect for breakfast, lunch, or an anytime snack.

$24.00
click for description