🎉 Our September cookies will be leaving soon! The last day to order your PB + J (nut-free optional), S’mores, Biscoff and/or Apple Pie cookies is September 20th with the final pickup date being Tuesday September 23rd. Order by this Saturday before these 4 delicious cookies say “bye”! 🍂
×

Bake Me Pretty

Verona, New Jersey

(1)

Shop the Menu

SEPTEMBER Cookies: Box Of 4 Jumbo or 16 Minis

$15.00

click for description

Half Dozen (6) Classic Cupcakes

$22.00

click for description

One Dozen (12) Classic Cupcakes

$40.00

click for description

DIY Cookie Decorating Kits

$12.00

click for description

6” 3-Layer Round Cake

$65.00

click for description

8” 3-Layer Round Cake

$85.00

click for description

About

Hi! I’m Rachel, the owner and baker behind Bake Me Pretty.

My sweet tooth started young—I took my very first baking class back in elementary school, then rediscovered my love of the whisk while home from winter break in college. Over the years, I’ve taken countless classes—from online courses to one-on-one sessions with professional bakers to hands-on workshops at the Institute of Culinary Education. Add in years of baking for fun, friends, and family, and here I am: completely self-taught and now living my dream.

In early 2024, I turned that “one day” dream into reality. I earned my Food Protection Manager certification and became a licensed Cottage Food Operator—meaning I’m permitted by NJ law to bake and sell directly from my home kitchen. Before this big shift (and before becoming a mom of two girls), I spent nearly 15 years working in mental health. But I knew it was time to follow my passion—and hopefully inspire my girls to do the same one day. In addition, starting September ‘25, I’ll also be baking out of a commercial kitchen under my retail license…so many exciting things ahead!

I believe in balance—both in life and in food. My motto is “Life is short…eat the cake (or at least bake it).” I’m a summer fanatic, 80s music lover, and firm believer that desserts should be fun, delicious, and made for everyday enjoyment. Whether you’re treating yourself or surprising someone special, my goal is to bring joy through sweet treats that feel indulgent yet approachable.

Alongside food safety, I take taste and quality very seriously. Since NJ law prohibits certain ingredients like dairy and eggs in specific products—and knowing how common allergies are—I set out to perfect vegan cake and buttercream recipes. After plenty of testing (and tasting), I found ones so good that even die-hard dessert lovers are shocked they’re vegan.

I’m so happy to be doing what I love most and would love to bake up something sweet for you! 🩷

Offerings

Cake Pops Cupcakes Cakes Cakesicles DIY Cookie Decorating Kits

Policies

Typical lead-time needed: 3 days

🎉 News, Events & Happenings 🎉

❤️ Bake Me Pretty now bakes up 4 new, seasonal and delicious cookies each month…weekly baking means you can order a fresh box for every weekend! 🍪 ❤️ Bake Me Pretty’s Mobile Cake Bar is arriving in October…Stay tuned for more details!🍁 ❤️ Upcoming Events and Where We’ll Be: •10/25/25: Verona Fall-o-Ween

Full List of Cake/Buttercream and Filling Flavors

All products are EGG-FREE, DAIRY-FREE and (optionally) NUT-FREE FULL LIST of CAKE FLAVORS: •Biscoff •Chocolate •Cookies & Cream •Sprinkles •Strawberry •Pink Velvet •Vanilla *Pistachio (contains nuts) •Spiced Chai Latte (seasonal) •Pumpkin Spice Latte (seasonal) •Gingerbread (seasonal) •Chocolate Peppermint (seasonal) FULL LIST of BUTTERCREAM FLAVORS: •Vanilla •Chocolate •Strawberry •Cookies & Cream •Spice •Sprinkles •Pistachio (contains nuts) •Cookie Butter •Lemon FILLING FLAVORS •Fruit Preserves •Crushed Cookies •Graham Crackers •Salted Caramel •Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread •Nut Spread (peanut, hazelnut or pistachio) •Chocolate Ganache •Sprinkles

Order Info

Bake Me Pretty requires 7 days for any customized order and full payment is required by 5 days prior to order date. Orders are not considered confirmed until full payment is received. Rush orders may be requested (please note, this is not guaranteed) for an additional fee. Please include your requested pickup/delivery date at checkout.

Refunds And Policy

•Full payment is due on or before 5 days before pickup date. Any cancellation, change or request for refund after this date will not be issued as we have begun to purchase and prepare for your order. •Once your order is received, all information with pickup time/location are in the confirmation email. Orders are not considered official until full payment is received.

Contact and Follow

We’d love to connect with you! If you have any order requests or questions, please reach out! Phone/Text: 973-508-7099 Email: rachel@bakemepretty.com

Follow us!