Ratings & Reviews

Thank you for taking my silly little idea and turning it into the cutest, most delicious cake! Will be ordering again!

The cake was absolutely perfect! Great icing and moist cake- everyone loved it!! Made my daughter’s 16th birthday so special! 🩷

I ordered 7 dozen mini cheesecakes and a “cheeseburger” cake for my husband’s 30th birthday, and everything was incredible! The guests were raving over the taste and presentation all evening long. Tonya was also amazing to work with and brought my vision to life. I highly recommend her for any occasion!

From the second I messaged Tonya about a cake idea I had in mind she replied very quickly and has been nothing but polite and professional. The cake turned out fantastic and the flavor was even better!! I had ordered a banana nut cake and it was delicious! Will definitely order from her again.

Ordered a custom cheesecake for my birthday & she literally made my dreams come to life, I cannot recommend Youngstown bake enough!!

I ordered the cheesecake minis, cupcakes, and buckeyes for Easter. Everything was delicious and decorated so cute and festive. I will definitely be ordering for more holidays and special occasions in the future.

Youngstown bake makes the most delicious cheesecakes and she is so responsive to messages and questions. My go-to for all my party treats!

Everything I have ordered has been delicious and beautifully prepared and packaged. A wonderful addition to any occasion.

I was lucky enough to get a Cadbury Egg Cheesecake for Easter—wow! Rich, creamy, and absolutely delicious. Youngstown Bake never disappoints. Amazing creativity and consistently great customer service!

I ordered a Peanut Butter Oreo cheesecake for my partners birthday and it was so delicious! Everyone LOVED it, and she even made the cutest topper for it!

I recently ordered Lemon Raspberry mini cheesecakes and also bought baked goods from the cooler at Wedgewood pizza. Everything was so fresh and delicious! The buckeyes were amazing. Tonya has a real talent and will custom make whatever you want!

Youngstown Bake ALWAYS delivers delicious treats. Ive ordered a lot different items and I have never been disappointed. If you need any baked goods, look no further. I know i will never order from anyone else!

Top notch for all your sweet treats! From cookies to cakes, Youngstown Bake is always my first choice. Everything is consistently fresh, delicious, and beautifully made. You can tell she puts a lot of care into what she does. Highly recommend for anyone looking for amazing baked goods!

The cake was alot bigger then I thought!!! It was super moist and decorated perfectly. Will use Youngstown Bake in the future!

Just picked up my recent pumpkin cheesecake order — IN FEBRUARY— and everything was perfect! The process was smooth from start to finish, and the cheesecake itself was fresh, rich, and incredibly delicious. You can really taste the quality in every bite. Highly recommend!

Wow! Tonya was great, from starting the order process to the drop off! The cheesecake melts in your mouth- so delicious! Thank you so much!

Hands down the BEST!! I'll make the hour+ to get such great quality product. The Big Deborah was a big hit for sure!

The cheesecake was to DIE for!!!! All homemade! The ordering process was easy online! Pick up arrangements were very accommodating and easy. I want to try so many other flavors and can’t wait to order another one! I highly recommend!

Excellent communication. Delivered exactly what I wanted & so delicious!

Tonya really Knocked it outta the park with my son’s Ghost Busters birthday cake. And I threw in an extra small cake to my order, last minute, and Tonya out did herself on that one as well. Beautiful cakes that taste better than they look, which I didn’t think was possible because of how beautiful they are. If you need someone for your next cake order, Tonya is your girl! You won’t be disappointed!

Very happy with the cookie kit I ordered for my nephew. He had the best time decorating his cookies!

AMAZING!!! Looked great and tasted even better!!! Definitely would recommend!!!

Words can’t describe the taste of these cheesecakes! Every bite took me back to when my mom used to bake cheesecakes and with every bite the flavors are incredible. I will be ordering from Youngstown Bake from now on.

Beautiful cheesecake, that tastes even better! Ive purchased several items and I am never left disappointed!

Bought this sampler because I’ve always wanted to try all the flavors but am so picky with my cheesecake. This flight was perfect! The flavor variety has something for everyone. The cheesecake itself is moist and has the perfect hint of sweetness and perfect amount of crust ratio. My family and I all had a taste testing and were not disappointed at all! 10 out of 10 highly recommend! Absolutely delicious.

Excellent. Everyone loved them!!!

The cheesecake flight was absolutely amazing!

This was my first time ordering I saw the cheesecake which is my absolute favorite and let me tell you it did not disappoint the flavors were amazing and so creamy and so worth every penny !!Already to order my next 12 !!

Beautiful cake and it was delicious too. My daughter absolutely loved it!

The Biscoff cake was absolutely amazing! It got nothing but compliments on both the look and taste! Thank you for bringing my vision to life. I will definitely be ordering again!

I ordered a dozen buckeye mini cheesecakes and a dozen cherry mini cheesecakes. Packaging was secure and presentation was flawless. I took them to a party and people raved about how delectable they were. So glad I ordered them and will definitely place future orders!

Best cupcakes around, & will continue to buy them for every event!! So pretty, & always delicious! 😋

Had two birthday cakes done for my kids both came out wonderfully, tasted amazing, the decorations in the cake were very detailed which we loved, and the frosting is amazing too!! Would highly recommend for anyone for a cake , or any type of desert you won’t regret it !! Can’t wait to order again ❤️

I got a dozen white chocolate raspberry mini cheesecakes. They were awesome. They were fresh and packaged well. The whole family loved them especially the chocolate crust! Well worth the purchase!

Best chocolate peanut butter cheesecake ever! So good

This cheesecake is so addicting. It has a buckeye for every slice of cake. My husband loved it. She even made a cute Happy Birthday sign that stands up on the cake. Worth every penny!