Ratings & Reviews

My third time ordering, and I've never been disappointed. Thanks for the amazingly decorated cake! Everyone loved it!

Received a yummy caramel cake. It was pretty and very yummy!

If you ever need a cake for any occasion I highly recommend Wild Heart Bake Shoppe ! The taste is superb! You will be licking the plate !'

GORGEOUS cookies, amazing service and completely affordable for such attention to detail! You can’t go wrong ordering from Wild Heart Bake shoppe 💛

I was referred to this sweet lady to make me some baby girl shower cookies. Girl … did she ever! I’ve seen many of these cookies here & there. I’ve never seen such attention to detail! Dainty, colors are absolutely perfect! I sent pictures of some I thought I liked. These were so much prettier & perfect. The ordering process was easy, payment was easy and pick up date & time were as promised! This is my first grand… these cookies are so precious & special! Thank you for making this day so perfect!

We had an excellent experience with Wild Heart! Our usual baker had a last-minute family emergency, and Wild Heart stepped in on short notice. They did an incredible job — from the presentation to the taste to the customer service, everything was top-notch. We couldn’t be happier and will definitely be returning!

I love the cookies I get from here! Everyone always says how great they look and love the taste of them!

I absolutely love Wild Heart Bale Shoppe! She has been doing my cookies over three years and she never disappoints! Customer service is great, prices are great, always nails my vision and never any issues!

I waited until the last minute and they came through for me even though they were going out of town! The cookies looked excellent and tasted amazing as well! Definitely give 5 stars and definitely recommend!

The cookies were so beautiful and tasted amazing! My grad loved them and so did our guest!!!

This is our 2nd time using Wild Heart and we will be ordering again. Her attention to detail in designs is amazing. Everyone was asking where we got the cookies made! Taste did not disappoint either- great flavor and still soft on the inside.

I can’t say enough good things about Hilary! She has done multiple orders for me over the years—everything from birthday cakes to special event treats—and every single time she absolutely knocks it out of the park. Her creations don’t just look stunning (seriously, Pinterest-worthy!), they taste just as incredible. You can tell she puts so much care and attention into every detail. She’s reliable, talented, and just a joy to work with. Highly recommend her to anyone who wants beautiful, delicious baked goods that truly wow!

I have used Hilary multiple times. Her cookies are to die for and beautifully decorated!! Highly recommend

Hilary made me a red velvet 30th birthday cake and I must say it was the BEST cake I have ever had. I sent her an inspiration picture and she nailed it and made it even cuter than I asked for! Highly recommend her and all her cakes and desserts! She also delivered the cake to me and that took so much off my plate as I was planning on having a big party at my home. Thank you, Hilary! Will be ordering again soon!

I have not purchased a cake or cookies but I have tasted them when a friend ordered them. The cookies tasted amazing and were absolutely adorable!

I ordered cookies for my daughter in laws bridesmaids to enjoy as they were getting ready on the big day! The cookies were beautiful and so yummy! The color was exactly the color of the dresses and added such a cute touch to the wedding day!

We ordered a smash cake, cupcakes, cake pops and cookies for our grandson’s first birthday. Everything far exceeded our expectations. We provided pics of what we had in mind and what we picked up was even better than the provided pics. Everything tasted great and there was not one crumb left.

Hilary and I discussed a concept for a Snow White themed cake and she knocked it out of the park! I’m an event planner and Hilary’s cake was the absolute highlight of an already amazing event! She was so personable, professional, and just wowed the client and her guests with her creativity!! I cannot wait to work with Hilary and Wild Heart Bake Shop again! People still talk about the cake months later!!

I have ordered cookies several times and each time they are amazing! Great customer service and she is always very friendly. I recommend her to everyone looking for sweet treats! 💕

Hilary makes the best desserts!! They look amazing, but taste even better. I’ve ordered for my birthday and for my sister in law’s baby shower and she doesn’t disappoint. We’ve gotten so many compliments on the desserts she’s made. She’s definitely the person I go to whenever we have events. 10/10 recommend!