Ratings & Reviews

I highly recommend Tiffany’s Treatery! For anything but especially the brand new homemade oatmeal creme pies. We got those this weekend and yum! Oatmeal creme pies are a nostalgic treat for me. So when I saw that Tiffany Tosh had made homemade ones- sign me up! They are perfect with a cup of coffee. I cannot wait to order some in fall with all the warmth and cozy vibes. They are so good!

We got some of all Tiffany’s items and they were all just as expected and just as delicious!! Highly recommend!!!

The items I’ve gotten from Tiffany have all been delicious. You can tell that she loves what she’s doing and she gives attention to detail. I also love that she’s very generous with the blueberries in her muffins.

The muffins were wonderful! So yummy! Will definitely order more in the future.

Everything is absolutely delicious but the bread is next leave. Best sour dough I have ever had in 60 years.

The blueberry muffins that I ordered were SO good, the raw sugar sprinkled on top was a wonderful.

I ordered 3 dozen cookies and I couldn’t keep my hand out of the box! They absolutely melt in your mouth 🩷 10/10