Featured Products
Spell Sampler
(4 cookies) A magical mini assortment—perfect for first bites and flavor experiments.
$10.00
The Enchanted Dozen
(12 Cookies) A full spellbook of sweetness—twelve decadent cookies conjured to share (or not).
$25.00
About
Welcome to The Sugar Spell 🔮 A cottage bakery weaving magic into cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and enchanting seasonal creations. Summon a sweet spell today.
Follow along for treat drops, seasonal menus, and all things sweet & spellbound.
Capabilities & Pricing
✨ The Sugar Spell – Capabilities & Pricing ✨
🧁 Cupcakes
Available in all core + seasonal flavors
• Half a Coven (6) – $18
• A Dozen Wishes (12) – $28
🍪 Cookies
All flavors available year-round unless marked seasonal
• Spell Sampler (4) – $10
• Witch’s Half Dozen (6) – $15
• The Full Spellbook (10) – $20
• The Enchanted Dozen (12) – $25
Seasonal flavors currently available:
🧹 Cookiewitches (Cookie Sandwiches)
Each includes 2 sandwich cookies / 4 cookies total
• The Cookiewitch Duality – $11
🍰 Cakes: Loaf Cakes
✨ Mini Loaf Cakes (also available as cupcakes)
Mini loaves can be ordered in sets of 4 or 12:
• 4 Mini Loaves — $16
• 12 Mini Loaves — $48
🍰 Cakes: Bundts, Rings & Minis
All Bundt / Ring cakes can be ordered in full size or mini size.
• Oreoboros Ring – Cookies & Cream
• Bananza Pudding Ring – Banana pudding Bundt
• Strawberry Starlight Ring – Strawberry spellcake
• Chocromancer Ring – Deep chocolate spellcake
• Celestial Vanilla Halo Cake – Vanilla enchantment
• Cider Circle – Spiced apple cider Bundt
(Pricing varies by size — full, mini, or custom orders. Message for quotes.)
🍥 Cinnamon Rolls
Spellbound Swirls (Cinnamon Roll Cups)
• 4 for $12
• 6 for $18
• 12 for $30
🍌 Banana Bread
The Bananza Spell
• $8 per loaf
🥧 Pies – 9 inch
Seasonal holiday pies available now:
• Harvest Hex – Pumpkin Pie – $25
• The Sugar Spell – Sugar Cream Pie – $25
• Apple Crumble Afterspell – Apple Crumb Pie – $25
• Coconut Cauldron – Coconut Custard Pie – $25
🧙♀️ Large Orders & Catering
If you need larger quantities than what is listed above such as office boxes, party trays, event catering, or bulk mixed orders
✨ Just message me!
I’m happy to accommodate custom large orders with advance notice.
📍 Pickup & Delivery
Pickup
Free in Muncie, IN.
Pickup times vary based on the chosen day.
Address is provided after payment confirmation.
Delivery
• Muncie — $3 (Free for orders $35+)
• Yorktown, Albany, Daleville — $5
• Fishers, Noblesville, Carmel — $5 (Free for orders $50+)
Delivery is available on select days depending on order volume.
✨ Message to confirm availability.
Policies
Cookie Flavors
🍊 Tangerine Treasure
A soft citrus cookie studded with creamy white chocolate and finished with a bright orange glaze. Sweet, smooth, and refreshing, this cookie balances rich white chocolate with vibrant tangerine flavor for a perfectly sunny bite.
🌫️ Phantom Veil
A delicate vanilla sugar cookie with soft winter spices and a sugar “veil” that melts like snowfall. Light, airy, and hauntingly sweet.
🍪 The Chip of Fate
A brown butter chocolate chip cookie crafted with fate in mind, crispy edges, chewy centers, and loaded with rich semi-sweet chips. Every bite feels like destiny.
🍪 The Caramel Curse
A wickedly soft snickerdoodle with a caramel twist these cinnamon-swirled cookies are packed with gooey caramel bits that melt into golden pockets of sweetness. Each bite is buttery, warm, and enchantingly chewy. Beware… you will fall under its spell.
🍪 The Nutty Charm
Sugar-dusted and packed with personality this cookie is stuffed with a velvety peanut butter center and topped with a little peanut charm. A spell for peanut butter lovers.
🍪 Oreoboros
A mystical take on cookies & cream this cookies and cream cookie is soft, decadent, and filled with whipped Oreo buttercream. The cycle of sweetness never ends.
🍪 The Smorceror
Gooey, graham, and glam. This cinnamon graham based cookie is packed with chocolate and toasted marshmallow magic. A campfire spell in cookie form.
🍪 The Triple Hex
Inspired by Neapolitan ice cream, this enchanting trio swirls chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla cookie dough into one delightful cookie. It’s a triple threat of flavor.
🍪 The Red Ritual
A crimson-hued cookie born from midnight magic this red velvet delight is soft, rich, and packed with velvety white chocolate chips. Familiar yet mysterious, it’s a decadent twist on a classic that’ll leave you enchanted after the first bite.
🍪 The Oatkeeper
A cookie worth guarding. ✨ This maple brown sugar oatmeal cookie hides a rich, gooey brown sugar filling at its heart. Soft, chewy, and warmly spiced with cinnamon, it’s the perfect mix of nostalgic comfort and magical indulgence.
Cupcake Flavors
✨ Celestial Vanilla
A celebration written in the stars ✨ Soft vanilla confetti cake filled with colorful sprinkles, topped with a swirl of creamy vanilla buttercream. A cosmic twist on a classic favorite.
✨ Spellcaster’s Spice
Warm spices swirl through a tender cake, conjuring cozy autumn flavors in every bite. Finished with a smooth frosting that’s as comforting as a charm spell.
✨ Strawberry Starlight
Bright strawberry cake crowned with a swirl of strawberry buttercream. Sweet, fresh, and shimmering with a starry touch — a burst of berry magic.
✨ Sunspire
Inspired by golden honey buns, this cupcake glows with cinnamon sugar swirls, a honey glaze soak, and a drizzle of vanilla sweetness. A warm, radiant treat that shines with every bite.
Cake Flavors
✨ Cider Ring
A spellbound take on the classic apple cider donut 🍎✨ This bundt-style cake is infused with spiced apple cider, brushed with a golden cider glaze, and dusted with cinnamon sugar. Soft, fragrant, and enchanting — the perfect autumn centerpiece.
Cookiewitch Flavors
🧹 Cookiewitches
• Pumpkin Charm 🎃
Two Wicked Harvest cookies joined with cinnamon buttercream — pumpkin pie spice wrapped in a cozy autumn spell.
• Fatebound ✨
Two Chip of Fate cookies bound with a swirl of vanilla buttercream — a destined match of soft chocolate chip cookies and creamy frosting, written in the stars.
• OuroButter 🐍🥜
Two Oreoboros cookies bound with creamy peanut butter icing — a bewitching blend of cookies & cream and peanut butter in one enchanting bite.
• Crimson Binding 🔮
Two Red Ritual cookies sealed with cookies & cream icing — rich red velvet and creamy filling united in one decadent spell.
Powered by
