The Sweet Spot Eatery

Hey, I’m Chelsey — mom of five, dessert maker, and the person behind The Sweet Spot Eatery. I bake made-to-order cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, and custom desserts for birthdays, celebrations, and special moments. Order ahead and pick up fresh and delicious treats without the chaos. We can’t wait to bake something sweet for you!

📍 4847 Route 81, Unit B, Greenville, NY 12083

🕘 Wednesday – Sunday: 8AM – 4 PM

At The Sweet Spot Eatery, we specialize in made-to-order desserts designed for birthdays, celebrations, and special events.

Custom Cakes:

• Sizes: 6”, 8”, 10”, and 2-Tier

• Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Funfetti, Lemon, Strawberry, Marble, Oreo, Cannoli, Lemon Blueberry

• Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Ganache, Cannoli Cream, Fruit Fillings (seasonal)

• Designs: Customized within our style; exact replicas of photos are not guaranteed

• Starting prices: 6” $45 | 8” — $55— | 10” — $70| 2-Tier — $120

• Advance notice required; availability is limited

Wedding Cakes:

• Custom designed to match your theme

• Complimentary tasting for engaged couples (includes two cupcakes — one for the bride, one for the groom)

• Date confirmation, deposit, and signed agreement required

• Pricing based on size, design complexity, and serving count

Cupcakes & Cookie Cakes:

• Sold by the dozen (cupcakes) or whole (cookie cakes)

• Available flavors vary weekly

• Orders must be placed at least 48 hours in advance; items within 48 hours may be fulfilled with what’s available in the display case

Cheesecakes:

• Sold whole only

• Flavors: Classic, Chocolate, Strawberry Swirl, Oreo, Salted Caramel, and seasonal flavors

• Advance notice required

All items are made-to-order to ensure freshness. Grab-and-go items are available in-store only. Thank you for supporting our small, family-owned bakery!