Your next dessert obsession is waiting inside.
Cupcakes
Our cupcakes are available by preorder and baked in limited quantities. Orders must be placed at least 48 hours prior to the requested pickup date. Orders placed within 48 hours will be fulfilled with flavors currently available in the display case. Cupcakes are sold by the dozen unless otherwise noted. Available flavors include: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Funfetti, Strawberry, Lemon, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Carrot and Salted Caramel. Flavor availability may vary by week and season. Cupcakes can be filled for an up charge . Simple frosting and standard decorations are included. Custom toppers, themed designs, or color-specific requests may be subject to additional charges. Pickup is available during regular business hours only. Flavor requests are honored based on availability at the time of production.
Starting at $30.00
Wedding Cake Inquiry
Reserve your wedding cake consultation and start planning your dream cake. Our custom wedding cakes are designed to reflect your style, flavors, and theme. Orders require advance notice, and availability is limited. Please submit your inquiry with your preferred wedding date, estimated guest count, and any inspiration or design ideas. After your inquiry is received, we will contact you to confirm availability and schedule your complimentary tasting, which includes two cupcakes β one for the bride and one for the groom β showcasing up to three flavors. Final pricing is determined by cake size, design complexity, and serving count. Exact replicas of inspiration photos are not guaranteed. β’ Tastings are complimentary once the inquiry is confirmed. β’ Wedding cake orders require signed confirmation and deposit to secure your date. β’ Colors, decorations, and designs may vary slightly based on availability and production.
2-Tier Custom Cake
Our 2-Tier Custom Cake is perfect for milestone celebrations and events requiring additional servings. This cake includes two stacked tiers with filling and buttercream frosting, coordinated in design and customized within our style. Exact replicas of inspiration photos are not guaranteed. Available Cake Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Funfetti, Lemon, Strawberry, Marble, Oreo, Cannoli, and Lemon Blueberry. Available Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Ganache, Cannoli Cream, and seasonal fruit fillings. Flavor and filling availability may vary. Specialty flavors and fillings may be subject to additional charges. Starting at $120 Final pricing is determined by tier sizes, design complexity, and serving count. Orders require advance notice and are accepted based on availability. Wedding cakes should be ordered through the Weddings category.
Starting at $120.00
10β Custom Cake (Serves 20β28)
Our 10β Custom Cake is ideal for larger celebrations and events. This cake includes two layers with filling and buttercream frosting, customized within our design style. Exact replicas of inspiration photos are not guaranteed. Available Cake Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Funfetti, Lemon, Strawberry, Marble, Oreo, Cannoli, and Lemon Blueberry. Available Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Ganache, Cannoli Cream, and seasonal fruit fillings. Flavor and filling availability may vary. Specialty flavors and fillings may be subject to additional charges. Starting at $70. Orders require advance notice and are accepted based on availability. Pickup is available during regular business hours only. Design complexity, toppers, and specialty decorations may affect final pricing.
Starting at $70.00
8β Custom Cake (Serves 12β18)
Our 8β Custom Cake is ideal for birthdays, celebrations, and special events. This cake includes two layers with filling and buttercream frosting, customized within our design style. Exact replicas of inspiration photos are not guaranteed. Available Cake Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Funfetti, Lemon, Strawberry, Marble, Oreo, Cannoli, and Lemon Blueberry. Available Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Ganache, Cannoli Cream, and seasonal fruit fillings. Flavor and filling availability may vary. Specialty flavors and fillings may be subject to additional charges. Starting at $55. Orders require advance notice and are accepted based on availability. Pickup is available during regular business hours only.
Starting at $55.00
6β Custom Cake (Serves 8β10)
Two layers with filling and buttercream frosting. Decorations customized within our style. Starting at $45. Advance notice required. Exact replicas not guaranteed. Available Cake Flavors: Vanilla Chocolate Red Velvet Funfetti Lemon Strawberry Marble Oreo Cannoli Lemon Blueberry Available Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla Buttercream Chocolate Buttercream Cream Cheese Frosting Chocolate Ganache Cannoli Cream Fruit Fillings (seasonal) Flavor and filling availability may vary. Specialty flavors and fillings may be subject to additional charges.
Starting at $45.00
About
Hey, Iβm Chelsey β mom of five, dessert maker, and the person behind The Sweet Spot Eatery. I bake made-to-order cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, and custom desserts for birthdays, celebrations, and special moments. Order ahead and pick up fresh and delicious treats without the chaos. We canβt wait to bake something sweet for you!
π 4847 Route 81, Unit B, Greenville, NY 12083
π Wednesday β Sunday: 8AM β 4 PM
Capabilities & Pricing
At The Sweet Spot Eatery, we specialize in made-to-order desserts designed for birthdays, celebrations, and special events.
Custom Cakes:
β’ Sizes: 6β, 8β, 10β, and 2-Tier
β’ Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Funfetti, Lemon, Strawberry, Marble, Oreo, Cannoli, Lemon Blueberry
β’ Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Ganache, Cannoli Cream, Fruit Fillings (seasonal)
β’ Designs: Customized within our style; exact replicas of photos are not guaranteed
β’ Starting prices: 6β $45 | 8β β $55β | 10β β $70| 2-Tier β $120
β’ Advance notice required; availability is limited
Wedding Cakes:
β’ Custom designed to match your theme
β’ Complimentary tasting for engaged couples (includes two cupcakes β one for the bride, one for the groom)
β’ Date confirmation, deposit, and signed agreement required
β’ Pricing based on size, design complexity, and serving count
Cupcakes & Cookie Cakes:
β’ Sold by the dozen (cupcakes) or whole (cookie cakes)
β’ Available flavors vary weekly
β’ Orders must be placed at least 48 hours in advance; items within 48 hours may be fulfilled with whatβs available in the display case
Cheesecakes:
β’ Sold whole only
β’ Flavors: Classic, Chocolate, Strawberry Swirl, Oreo, Salted Caramel, and seasonal flavors
β’ Advance notice required
All items are made-to-order to ensure freshness. Grab-and-go items are available in-store only. Thank you for supporting our small, family-owned bakery!
Policies
Allergy Notice
π¨ Allergy Notice
Please inform us of any allergies when placing your order. While we take every precaution, our kitchen handles nuts, dairy, eggs, and gluten.
Deposits, Payments, Cancellations
A deposit of 50% is required to consider this an order. The remaining amount is due the day of pick up.
Deposit is due 48 hours after invoice has been sent.
All deposits are non - refundable. There will be no credit given if order is cancelled within 5 days before due date.
Delivery Terms
Wedding Cakes:
Delivery and setup are required and included for all wedding cakes. This ensures proper handling, setup, and presentation on your special day.
β’ Birthday & Celebration Cakes:
Delivery is optional and available for an additional fee. Delivery pricing varies based on distance and will be confirmed prior to fulfillment.
β’ Pickup Orders:
Customers are responsible for safe transport of all pickup orders once they leave the bakery. We are not responsible for damage that occurs after pickup.
β’ Delivery Timing:
Delivery times are scheduled in advance and are subject to availability. Specific delivery time requests are not guaranteed unless confirmed in writing.
β’ Venue Coordination:
For wedding deliveries, we will coordinate directly with the venue when possible to ensure a smooth setup.
Photography
We respect all of our clients! We will not disclose the identity of our clients in photos of the after product without permission. We do however, reserve the rights to photograph baked goods and use those photos on our website and social media!
Ordering
After your order is placed it doesnβt confirm your order is received and placed. Please wait for an invoice and or email from us to confirm your order has been received!
Powered by
