The Sugar Coop Cookies
Featured Products
12 Days of Christmas Cookie Advent Calendar- Mean One Calendar
$40.00
click for description
Custom Order Request
click for description
12 Days of Christmas Cookie Advent Calendar- Gingerbread Calendar
$40.00
click for description
Back To School
One Smart Cookie Set
$10.00
click for description
Back To School Pencil Set
$10.00
click for description
O-Fishally Back Cookie Set
$10.00
click for description
4- Pack Mini School Supplies
$10.00
click for description
5-Pack Mini Goldfish
$12.00
click for description
Backpack And Notebook Cookie Set
$10.00
click for description
Grade Cookie With Apple And Pencil Balloons
$6.00
click for description
Hello Grade Cookie
$6.00
click for description
4-Pack Mini Apples
$10.00
click for description
Custom Apple With Worm Cookie
$6.00
click for description
About
The Sugar Coop custom sugar cookies designed to elevate every celebration! From baby showers and weddings to birthdays, graduations, and more.
Each order is fully customizable and thoughtfully hand-crafted, featuring soft, made-from-scratch sugar cookies decorated with royal icing. Beautiful, delicious, and created fresh for your special event.
Hello! I'm Jenna. A mom to five children and a wife. I have been decorating cookies from time to time, but really dove in in 2025. I can be quite the perfectionist, but that just means your cookies are always my best. I love Halloween and also enjoy sewing, crafting, hiking, traveling and spending time with my family.
All cookies are baked and decorated in my home kitchen following the Ohio Cottage Laws. Cookies are labeled and individually packaged for freshness and ensure you get the best tasting cookies.
Local pickup in Wooster, Ohio.
Capabilities & Pricing
Basic Package ($45/DOZEN)
Up to 4 colors, basic shapes and simple details, including letters, numbers and lines.
No hand piped characters or logos.
The Next Level ($55/DOZEN)
Up to 6 colors, intricate shapes and detailed designs, characters, including letters, numbers and lines.
Cookies for both packages are 3.5”-4” in size. Minimum 1 dozen to order.
Mini Cookies (2”)- ($25/ Dozen)
Up to 5 colors, basic shapes and simple details. Great for gifts and holidays. Can be packaged in a sleeve of 4 or individually wrapped.
Minimum 2 dozen to order.
Add Ons:
Hand painted designs- $10 a dozen
Metallics- $5 a dozen
Once you have contacted me, I will draw up a mock up for approval. Once approved, an invoice will be sent.
Your event will not be held and cookies will not be baked until payment is made. I require payment at least one week before event. No order will be fulfilled without payment.
Please order at least 2 weeks in advance of event.
Due to the custom nature of each order and the time reserved for preparation, all sales are final. Cancellations are not eligible for refunds once payment has been made and the order is confirmed.