The Sticky Spoon

Hi! Welcome to The Sticky Spoon, a small-batch cookie business specializing in thick, NYC-style stuffed cookies. What started as a love for baking and creating sweet treats for family and friends quickly grew into a passion for sharing something sweet with my community.

From my OG Brown Butter Chocolate Chip to creative stuffed flavors and seasonal releases, every cookie I make is from scratch with lots of love. I offer individual orders, party & event packages, pop-ups, wholesale and fundraising options, plus rotating flavors throughout the year.

The Sticky Spoon has grown so much from where it started, and I’m so excited to continue creating new flavors, meeting new customers, and seeing where my little cookie business takes me. 🤍

Mahalo for supporting local 🫶🏻

Xoxo, Steph (your favorite stuffed cookie dealer)

ORDERING SCHEDULE

• Public meetups available in Wahiawa or Mililani.

• Pickup is available on base.

• We are closed on Sundays.

Orders may close early once weekly capacity has been reached.

COOKIE PRICING

NYC Stuffed Cookies — $6 each

Mini Stuffed Cookies — $4 each

FLAVOR MENU

Our flavor lineup rotates regularly and features a mix of signature favorites and seasonal creations.

For the latest menu, flavor drops, market dates, and special releases, follow us on Instagram:

@thestickyspoon_

CUSTOM FLAVOR REQUESTS

Custom flavors are available for event orders and bulk orders only.

Minimum order requirements:

• 1 dozen mini cookies

OR

• 6 NYC stuffed cookies

Additional custom flavor fees may apply depending on ingredients and flavor complexity.

PARTY & EVENT ORDERS

Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, corporate events, graduation parties, and dessert tables.

• Minimum 7-day notice preferred

• 50% non-refundable deposit required to secure your date

• Final payment due before pickup or delivery

• Availability is limited and dates are booked on a first-come, first-served basis

PICKUP & DELIVERY

Local pickup is available in Wahiawa or Mililani.

Delivery is available for an additional fee of $5 per 5 miles from Wahiawa.

Detailed pickup and delivery information will be provided once your order is confirmed.

ADDITIONAL POLICIES

• No refunds. All sales are final.

• No same-day orders.

• Orders are not confirmed until payment arrangements have been made.

• Due to the nature of custom baked goods, all sales are final.

• Menu items and availability may change based on ingredient availability and demand.

• If order is not picked up within 24hours of scheduled/agreed pickup time, a new invoice & payment will need to be completed. This ensures the quality of my product is up to my standard when delivered and consumed.

Thank you for supporting The Sticky Spoon.🍪🌺