Ratings & Reviews

I ordered a carrot cake for my birthday and it came out amazing! Jessie is the sweetest & is always making sure her orders come out nothing short of amazing! She makes the ordering process so simple and the orders always come out great! She’s the best in the gluten free game & her treats are the best!

All i can say is wow!!! If i didn't let anyone know they would have never know the cakes were gluten free!!!!! What an amazing addition to Adams! The cakes were beautiful and taste so good!

We ordered a beautiful cake for our daughters 16th birthday party. We sent her theme inspo photo and a photo from another cake Jessie made before and she nailed it! The cake was not only beautiful in which many people at the party thought it was fake, but was so delicious and people couldn't believe it was gluten free!!

The shire cottage bakery are the best Whoopie pies ever! The only place we buy them from. We’ve tried others, but there is absolutely no comparison. She’s very accommodating and all around awesome!

The Shire Cottage Bakery quickly became our favorite place to get our sweet treat fix! Jessie is a magician at creating exceptionally beautiful and tasty treats! It’s such a rarity to be able to find gluten and dairy free baked goods but with Shire Cottage Bakery you wouldn’t even be able to tell the difference. Her gluten and dairy free carrot cake has become a must for special occasions! My husband says it’s the only cake he wants to eat. We can’t recommend her enough!

Jessie made ‘It Takes a Village’ themed cookies for our baby shower and they came out amazing!! She truly went above and beyond with the all of the details and packaging!

We chose Shire Cottage Bakery as they have the best desserts, regardless of the fact that they are allergy friendly. We ordered a small dairy free and gluten free wedding cake, and it was amazing! Jessie decorated the cake beautifully to match our floral arrangements. We also got macarons and whoopie pies which were a massive hit with our guests. Our only regret was not saving more for ourselves to enjoy. 10/10 communication and efficiency! Would highly recommend!!!

Most amazing baked goods ever!! Her cakes and cupcakes are so rich and moist and her frosting is just the right amount of sweetness!!!!

Our new business Mazzeo’s Italian Market & Deli is proud to carry these amazing Gluten Free products

Will use this bakery again and again!

We held a breakfast party for our Yoga Communities for their dedication, support and care for us and for each other. Connecting with Jessie via email was so easy, making my planning and decision making effortless. On pickup day Jessie brought the scones, muffins, cookies, and lemon bars out to my car and answered all my questions about storing them for the event the next day. As people arrived they walked past the food table in awe. Everything was beautifully displayed and luscious to eat. We prepared for 40 people and almost everything was gone by the end of our gathering. Everything Jessie made was delicious; many folks asked for her contact information, and many more wanted to know when we were going to have another breakfast party! 5 Stars and over 40 happy faces!! Thank you Jessie !

We ordered a chocolate cake for our anniversary. Jessie has excellent customer service, and the cake was well decorated and super delicious! We would definitely order from here again. Highly recommend!

Been a customer of Shire Bakery for about 4 to 5 years now for every celebration including weddings, engagement parties, birthdays, holidays and sometimes I just need some Cupcakes/Cookies. Jessie is aways so accommodating , top notch! I highly recommend Shire Bakery!!!

The cake was absolutely perfect. Decorated so delicately and my mom LOVED it! Jessie is easy to work with and will make your gluten free cake dreams come true.

BEST gluten free baked goods I've ever had! Jessie is amazing to work with and prices are reasonable. We serve her breakfast muffins to our guests in the morning.

Jessie's made-from-scratch gluten-free cupcakes were absolutely divine! From the moment we took a bite, we were blown away by how moist and fluffy they were. The flavor was perfectly balanced, with just the right amount of sweetness, and the frosting was rich without being overpowering. It’s clear a lot of care and attention went into making these, and they were a true indulgence for everyone, as some of us even had 2! I’d highly recommend these to anyone craving a decadent treat!

Jessie made a wonderful mini cake and dozen cupcakes for our daughter’s 21st Birthday. Delicious!! Thank you

I ordered a Fourth of July cookie platter and it was so delicious! A great variety of flavored cookies, brownies and whoopie pies. All things I have received from Shire Cottage Bakery have been incredible. So happy to have a gluten free bakery near home!

We love Shire Cottage Bakery! Her macaron cookies are the star of our afternoon tea series, and she has made amazing custom designed cookies and cakes for Susan B. Anthony's Birthday each year.

We ordered cookies for my son’s first birthday. A “one happy camper theme” - they were decorated beautifully, and were delicious! Will defintley be coming back for all of our cookie needs!