Ratings & Reviews

Nicole did such a great job with making my custom cherry chip birthday cake pops! She was fast and completed the order on short notice and even delivered it! The cake pops where delicious!

I got the box with churro, smores, blueberry lemon, strawberries and cream, caramel apple and pumpkin chai latte flavored ones. OH MY GOSH, they are amazing! The pumpkin chai latte ones are absolutely divine! Not dry, the pumpkin is nice and flavorful and the chai spices aren’t overpowering. I highly recommend them!

Every single treat we have purchased, or luckily been around to taste test, has been loved by the whole family. Cake pops in lots of different yummy flavors, frosted sugar cookies, chocolate chip cookies, lemon cookies, and birthday cakes! All wonderfully delicious & packaged with care. 😋

Nic of Time Bakery did an incredible job on my daughter’s graduation party’s cake pops with last minute notice! I was scrambling to get a cake pop person at the last minute. I gave Nicole inspiration photo’s and she was able recreate exactly what I was looking for in days. She suggested a nice mix of popular flavors and they were devoured! Great flavor and beautiful design. I highly recommend Nic of Time Bakery!!

Nicole is seriously AMAZING! Not only is she so easy to work with and order from but her work is truly amazing! She has made multiple custom orders of cake pops for different occasions for my family! My absolute favorite ones to date are the special order for Rapunzel cake pops for my daughters birthday this past weekend! Nicole is seriously so talented and I highly recommend her for your baking needs!

Nicole puts so much effort, care and love into each and every order. They’re baked to perfection, always so cute and delicious! Love being able to support someone local and know that I’m 100% getting my moneys worth! Will forever use her for my baked good needs!

Nicole made the most perfect birthday cake & cake pops for my daughter’s 8th birthday party! I sent an inspo picture and she was spot on! The vibrant colors were perfect for her Labubu party theme!

Nicole was amazing to work with! Fast, easy process and the cake pops were even better!!

My daughter wanted to take a treat to her class for her birthday celebration. Nicole knocked the assignment out of the park! My daughter wanted Rapunzel cake pops and they were absolutely PERFECT! The detail on the cake pops were unbelievable! If you’re looking for custom cookies or cake pops I highly recommend Nicole from The Nic of Time Bakery! ❤️

The cake pop was incredible, easily one of the best I’ve ever had and the packaging was just as thoughtfully done. It really stood out.

Theses cake pops are always so cute and on time❤️❤️

The Key Lime Pie Cake Pops were great. The kids loved them! My personal favorite were the Raspberry Macarons. They somehow tasted even better the next day! Magic! Everything was packaged up quite nicely and delivered in the Nic of Time.

Nicole took the time to accommodate and make amazing sugar free cookies! Highly recommend :)

Nicole made my daughters smash cake for her 1st birthday. It turned out beautiful and was SOOO yummy!!!

The cake pops were DELICIOUS! Not to mention she went above and beyond on the display and the design to make it super special for my girlfriend’s birthday. Couldn’t recommend The Nic of Time Bakery enough!

I ordered all 4 flavors and I'm glad I did, because they're all amazing!! Definitely recommend.

Nicole makes the best cookies. They are soft and have the best flavor. She is very friendly and goes above and beyond with her delivery. Thank you for making cookies for my family this holiday season.

These Christmas cookies are the best! The flavor was amazing and they were nice and soft. The frosting was tasty. Gabe and Adriana had fun frosting and decorating them. Thanks for rescuing me in the Nic of time!!

The perfect cookie from flavor, to soft and chewy!

Probably the best molasses cookies I’ve ever had. Very professional presentation and the individually wrapped cookies are a nice touch.

These have to be some of the best cookies I’ve ever had. You can tell she puts love into each cookie! Our favorite has to be the ginger molasses! My boys loved the cookie decorating kit!!! We look forward to ordering more in the future!!

These cookies were outstanding. The ginger molasses had the perfect spice, the snickerdoodle was soft and flavorful, and the chocolate was a hit with everyone. These were clearly made with care! So glad we found this small business—everything we tried was amazing!

Nicole puts noticeable effort into every single cookie she bakes. The packaging is professional and absolutely adorable. The cookies are to die for and are the perfect sweet treat. Nicole has put everything she has into launching this business and wants nothing more than to bring a smile to you and your family and friends with tasty cookies. You will not be disappointed!

These homemade oatmeal raisin cookies are incredible. They’re perfectly soft and chewy, with just the right amount of raisins in every bite. The flavor is warm, the texture is spot-on, and they taste like something made with real care. Easily some of the best oatmeal raisin cookies I’ve had.