Ratings & Reviews

I am no longer embarrassed to admit I am a coffee and bourbon snob--and I appreciate the artistry and provenance of both. But when it comes to baked goods, I am even more critical since I am gluten-intolerant and keep pastries/cookies to an absolute minimum in my diet. So when I have them, they have to be exceptional because, for me, they are a true luxury. And that's why I intend to be a regular customer at The Forgotten Flour in Bloomfield. Jill's peanut butter cookies are simply sublime--and I plan to work my way through the rest of her offerings in short order. She knows how to make gluten-free taste seriously yummy. And if you aren't gluten-free, you should try these baked goods anyway to understand that when gluten-free products are made by an artisan baker like Jill, what you simply get is awesomeness.

Jill is wonderful! She was able to deliver to our event venue and help set up the food trays. She provided a variety of savory and sweet bites to accommodate all appetites for a large event. While all of the products are gluten free, they appealed to everyone- no one missed the gluten!

I LOVE the forgotten flour! We found her cookies at a cafe we frequent so when it was time for our wedding (and cookie table) we knew we had to get some. We were able to have baked goods all individually wrapped and I was thrilled that there was an option for gluten/dairy/and nut free (EVERYONE deserves a cookie). One of our guest came up and was crying because it was the first time she knew she could partake in a cookie table. Thank you so much!

I’ve had a variety of gluten-free and dairy free products and you can taste the difference between them and regular pastries. The cookies that I purchased didn’t have that grainy,gritty taste that you often find in GF products. Man, you couldn’t tell the difference. Not only were they scrumptious and delicious they were a party hit. I highly recommend The Forgotten Flour pastries for every type of event and I’ll be there often. Sweet tooth just got even better. If you have events, make sure you include these pastries won’t go wrong and you serve everybody’s dietary needs. They have the secret sauce to the GF pastry puzzle.

I have ordered a few different cookies and treats over the last few months. They have all been amazing and the prices are also so much more reasonable than normal gluten free things. A must hit spot for gluten free folks!

This was our 2nd order from Jill. We had the brown butter expresso cookies and they were perfectly complimented by the sprinkle of salt on top. Of course the coffee cheesecake mini cupcakes were to die for and the muffins were moist and delicious.

These are hands down the best gluten free cookies I’ve ever gotten from a bakery. The gobs, oatmeal cream pies and Christmas cookies were all amazing. The customer service was also top notch. We will definitely be repeat customers many times over.

Bought holiday cookies for my sister with Celiac and she loves them! So delicious. Can’t wait to come back and get more treats for her!

We ordered two dozen spiced ginger molasses cookies and they were absolutely perfect for the holiday season. So delicious, and even better knowing they’re completely safe for someone with celiac disease since this is a dedicated gluten-free bakery. When the storefront wasn’t open for pickup, our order was delivered to us quickly and seamlessly. Such an easy, wonderful experience — I would always recommend The Forgotten Flour!

I ordered the Christmas variety platter. First, it was very carefully and festively packaged. I had mine delivered and communication by the driver Mike was great. He gave me an initial eta, then updated throughout the day. As for the cookies -- awesome! I got them for my niece who is extremely gluten insensitive. She said they were absolutely delicious and very flavorful. Bottom line, Jill has a great thing going here and I'm glad I found her and The Forgotten Flour. The cookies are worth every.single.penny. I haven't tried her other creations (which look amazing), but it's only been 24 hours since we got the cookies, lol. Highly recommend!

I picked up trays of gluten free holiday baking. It all came beautifully wrapped. Everything was so well made and so delicious. Forgotten Flour is a treasure!

Baked goods from The Forgotten Flour are amazing! These tasty treats do NOT need a qualifier like, "they're good considering their Gluten Free." They are simply delicious! Jill goes out of her way to provide the highest quality baked goods and over the top service. Highly recommend!

I am absolutely addicted to the maple pecan bars currently being offered at Commonplace Coffee, so I placed my first online order earlier this week. She went out of her way to deliver my order even earlier than expected. The cupcakes look absolutely delicious. :) very highly recommend!

ordered a cookie tray from jill everyone in the family loved it the cookies were gone highly recommend

The pumpkin roll was perfect and the sprinkle cookie has amazing texture, not sandy or bland

Shipped all the way from PA to MO the cookies and cakes were amazing. Friends and family were thrilled, thanks!!

The pumpkin roll was delicious and helped me enjoy my first Thanksgiving having Celiac Disease. Thank you! 🙂

The box was put together so thoughtfully and everything was delicious. A majority of the people who enjoyed the treats are not gluten free and no one could tell the difference. The maple pecan bars are a personal favorite!

Thank you so much for making it possible for me to truly enjoy a delicious GF Thanksgiving dessert!

I got the Gather & Graze Sampler Box for Thanksgiving, and it was gorgeous, delicious, and perfect! I will 100% be ordering from The Forgotten Flour again in the future, and I am recommending this bakery to all friends and family. Each item in the box was exquisitely flavored, and the seasonal decoration items were remarked upon by all our guests for their incredible cuteness. The Pecan Maple Bars and the Pumpkin Rolls were considered absolutely exceptional by all, and everything also was also remarked upon as being of the highest quality and best flavors!!

The two holiday dessert boxes I ordered were beautifully decorated and included a great assortment of cookies, cheesecake bites and pumpkin roll slices. The owner was kind and easy to work with. The few things I’ve tried so far have exceeded all expectations! Will definitely order something again in the future!

I have Celiac’s and I have never had a gluten free pumpkin roll. It’s the best pumpkin roll! Thank you so much!

My family and I are not even gluten free but adore forgotten flour. We were introduced to the baked goods by having them at our local coffee shop. We started having the treats- and my two year old just adores them that when we were planning Thanksgiving he insisted on “oatmeal sandwiches” the oatmeal cream pies. And although we are not gluten free family- we ordered so many for Thanksgiving and I’m looking forward to serving to my guests. They are so good!

1) Extremely fast with orders… I ordered Sunday before Thanksgiving and it was all ready by Tuesday! 2) Extremely delicious!

The owner is so nice and helpful, as she answered all my questions professionally and kind!

The flourless chocolate cake with raspberries was exquisite. My husband said it was the best cake he ever tasted.

My one relative has Celiac’s but I didn’t want to buy two types of cupcakes. No one could tell the difference from these and gluten-containing cupcakes! Jen was very wonderful and will be buying more from her soon!

The cookies and cake was amazing! They were also so beautifully decorated. Thank you!!

Jill , You are so talented and such a wonderful baker , your gluten free is excellent , I personally don’t need gluten free but your stuff is the best ! Xoxo 😘

The blueberry muffins are delicious! They are moist, light, fluffy and bursting with flavor in every bite. One of the best gluten free muffins I have eaten. Thank you for making a wonderful product!

My partner is celiac so we keep a gluten-free house, which has led to my abandonment of all gluten pastries. Thankfully we found Jill and The Forgotten Flour. Her baking skills are incredible and we are so happy to have found a baker that can produce our favorite desserts in a safe, zero cross-contamination kitchen.

Jill, made the best cookies for our party that were Gluten, Dairy, and Nut free!! The ones that had those allergies just kept raving about how good those cookies were! Use Jill for all your cookie needs!

The cake was super cute and spooky, exactly what I asked for as I am born on Halloween. The cake was moist, buttercream was smooth, and decorations were lovely! I also got a bonus gob and bar to try and they were delicious as well. We will be back!

I needed to accommodate multiple allergies for an event - and Forgotten Flour was on it! The cupcakes were delicious and beautiful, and the owner was communicative. I would definitely recommend them for other events!

Jill did an amazing job with my order ! Her presentation, professionalism is out of this world! 100% highly recommend! 10/10

Best gf goodies in Pittsburgh!

We ordered and loved the chocolate chip cookie cake. It was a hit, and the perfect size for our party of eight. We are also fans of espresso and tried the espresso cheesecake cups, and they did not disappoint. The best ever. We will be ordering again! It’s so great that our whole family has all of these incredible and delicious gluten-free options.

Everyone absolutely loved the cupcakes

Genuinely so impressed with this bakery time and time again. If I didn’t know better I would be triple checking the label because everything is that good ❤️

This was my first purchase, and I can't recommend them enough! The cookies were delicious, and Jill was on top of communicating updates about my order. 10/10!

amazing never had gf food like this before

My son came home and I got the gobs and more oatmeal creme pies. He was in heaven. Thank you again Jill.

You’ll never miss the flour. The cookies are excellent and Jill is super sweet to work with. Very responsive. Cookies tasted great and beautifully decorated.

I am so excited to have found such a kind, attentive, and caring baker! I have so many allergies it is always a challenge to stay safe. I ordered a Halloween themed birthday cake, sprinkle cookies, lemon-lavender cookies and peanut butter and jilly cookies!! I went all in on my first order and I am so glad that I did!! I will be a regular customer now!! The cookies are the best I have ever had and so flavorful!! I can’t believe they are all safe for me lol gluten free, dairy free, other long list of allergies- free!! I always say “if it tastes good it’s probably too good to be true and I’ll get sick” that’s not the case with the forgotten flour!! 100/100!! Gold stars!!! ⭐️ thank you again and again for helping make my birthday so special!! 🎃👻🖤

A while back I discovered a little gem while I was scrolling through social media for gluten-free baked goods. I decided to take a chance and order one thing to try. That order turned into another with two things to try, and then the next order turned into more! I now order anytime I need bakery treats for an event or when I want a sweet treat. I have never been disappointed in anything I received! I have served these gluten-free baked goods to countless people, not letting them know they were gluten-free! And of course, they got rave reviews. Jill was also very accommodating when I ordered while I was going through chemo. Making arrangements to meet my daughter to deliver my orders for me when I could not get out! I highly recommend any of their treats! Not only are you supporting local small business, but you’re supporting a woman owned local small business!

The cookies were fabulous, and the customer service was top notch.

It was absolutely Delicious!!!! Amazing & I will get it again!

The cake was so scrumptious and tasty, moist, gorgeous! Love this bakery. Ordering was so personable and easy. Delivery was timely and the customer service is exceptional! Can’t wait to use the Forgotten Flour again!!!!

Great service - amazing products

Picked up a few sweet bites for a cocktail party and put them out with the apps—people went absolutely crazy for them! Everything was a hit, and the gluten-free ladies were over the moon. Lemon bars for days!!!!!

I recently tried both the seven layer bars and the gobs and they were absolutely phenomenal. They were not dry or crumbly.. truly delicious! I will definitely be ordering these again

Everything I have ordered so far has been delicious. The chocolate chip cookies are the perfect consistency. Service is great too. Even when not open we got our order delivered!

Jill has the best gluten free baked goods in Pittsburgh. She is so easy to work with and very accommodating for special orders. Loved the cupcakes. Also delicious cookies and other treats when you stop in the store! Would highly recommend!

Ordered the brown butter espresso cookies and chocolate chip cookies- they were both delicious!!! Can’t wait to order more!!!

I ordered a dozen chocolate cupcakes, and they were as tasty as they were pretty!! The frosting has a really good balance of sweetness and creaminess, and the cake wasn’t dry at all, which is an especially big accomplishment with gluten free baking. These were also really affordable compared to other gluten free cupcakes in the area, but they don’t taste like a budget option!

Everything Jill touches is incredible. All of my non-GF friends and family agree, these are the best baked goods around!

It’s not everyday that you find Gluten free treats that are actually delicious - like wait in line good but these are it. AND to top it off Jill is an awesome human that’s so deserving of being seen and honored for the heart she puts into her food and spreads everywhere she goes. She’s also willing to ship which is HUGE for a girly that’s not local to Pittsburgh.

I ordered a carrot cake and the toffee cookies for a birthday party and I was so thrilled with how delicious both were. Many people commented that they didn't believe that it was GF (but it was!) Just FYI, there is an extra charge to use your credit card and I wish I had known that, as I would have paid cash.

Such a cute little store with delicious treats! Everything is made fresh daily. The owner, Jill, is a burst of fresh energy. Don’t miss out on this new neighborhood gem in Bloomfield!

Can't even tell the difference that they are gluten free. Best cookies I've ever had

Everything is so delicious here!! So many desserts I haven’t been able to have for years, I’m finally able to have and they taste delicious. Tried the cookie cake for my birthday this year and it was phenomenal! I highly recommend The Forgotten Flour!

We found out about The Forgotten Flour weeks before it opened and got a pre-order of vanilla cupcakes, peanut butter cheesecake bites and tasty cookies. All of these were amazing and delicious. We got a repeat order of the vanilla cupcakes just the other day, and who knows what we'll get the next time? We don't go vegan or gluten-free unless what we're eating just happens to fit one of those categories, but these treats are delicious with no 'buts' or other exceptions. The textures are perfect, everything is tasty and the proprietor is nothing less than a super woman! I don't know how she does it! Five stars, four thumbs up and ten golden flour sifters to The Forgotten Flour!!

We order the brown butter espresso cookies and they were so good. We will definitely come back to try more items!

If you are looking for some absolutely delicious gluten free treats in Pittsburgh, you have to check out The Forgotten Flour!

I was so happy to find this new gluten free bakery in Bloomfield! The baked good are so delicious and Jill was great to work with - placed a special order for a wedding weekend! They opened just in time for us!!

The most amazing desserts I have ever had! better than non GF! I can’t wait to order again 🥰

I ordered salted caramel cookie and also a chocolate brownie cookie. They were both amazing. They delivered them right to my house what more could you ask for a great cookie delivered to your house at a great price by a wonderful girl.

As a Celiac, I've scoped out MANY gluten free treats, and the Forgotten Flour has some of the best. I particularly love their chocolate chip cookies. The Valentine's and Easter's baskets were amazing - it was wonderful to be able to try so many gluten free goodies at once :)

Love this bakery, delicious and fresh! They even deliver and the packaging is beautiful!

I am absolutely thrilled with the Easter basket! There’s a nice variety of things included and it’s a great way to try a lot of different cookies. Everything I’ve tried so far has been excellent (and my gluten eating fiancé agreed)!! I am so excited to have a local dedicated GF bakery that’s actually as good as a gluten-ful bakery! Will definitely be ordering again!!

I ordered a flourless chocolate torte for Easter and it was amazing!! Everyone loved it!! It was so dense and creamy!!

Jill did a great job with the Easter Basket, we ordered some other items all GF and all delicious, would definitely recommend for yummy sweet treats!

The cookies and Easter basket I ordered from forgotten flour were even better than expected! The lavender cookies are so soft and delicious. The Easter basket was full of an assortment of treats, the perfect Easter gift! Jill even delivered my order directly to me which was unexpected and such a nice touch. I will be letting all my gluten free friends know about this new bakery! Thank you!

The Forgotten Flour is the best gluten free bakery in Pittsburgh! Check them out!!

My daughter and husband both have celiac, so our household has been gluten free for at least 12 years now. It was our first time ordering. The Easter basket was amazing with so many delicious treats and a great variety. We also ordered classic chocolate chip cookies and sugar cookies. They are fantastic! I can't wait to order treats again.

It can be difficult to find gluten free desserts, especially ones that taste great.. the espresso cheesecake bites are amazing and perfect. They make you wonder if they are actually gluten free. I really look forward to trying more of their products! Jen was super nice and made the order and pick up super simple.

Friendly, accommodating, and communicative. This place is great! I was finally able to get my girlfriend some sweets that work with her allergies. She said they are the best shes had. Thanks!

Everything looked great and my daughter loved it!

I am ordered a gift box of cookies for Valentines Day. I expected a pink box of treats but received a gorgeous display of gluten free goodies! Everything tasted as good as it looked!

This bakery was such a great find, and I would highly recommend them! The cookies are delicious, and the sweetheart boxes exceeded our expectations. Every single treat was amazing, and the packaging was perfection. The cookies are fresh and soft, not crumbly and they taste like regular non GF ones…even better! This is by far the best gluten free bakery that we have found. We are lucky to have The Forgotten Flour as a new addition to the Pittsburgh area!