Ratings & Reviews

The art on the cookies is great and customer service was great.

We were thrilled with the looks of these cookies. Absolutely stunning and well made. I know these will be the perfect gift for my coworker!

Absolutely love the Super Bowl and Buccees cookies that I had made. They are all so yummy and beautiful. Caitlin is wonderful to work with and look forward to more.

The Cookie Momster helped me last minute and did a fantastic job! The cookies look amazing and the presentation was beautiful! I will definitely be using her services again!

Beautiful and delicious! We love to order these for our events!

These Elf on the Shelf cookies are so cute and the perfect way to bring back the yearly tradition! Thank you so much! I can't wait to see their faces in the morning! Cookies for Breakfast!!

Absolutely amazing experience and the cookies were stunning to view and delicious!! Thanks again for helping make the party a success!

An absolutely amazing experience and the cookies are delicious. I cannot wait to work with The Cookie Momster again!

Beautifully decorated and taste wonderful!

The CookieMOMster made adorable cookies in the theme of our conference. They were adorable and tasted great, definitely at hit at our booth. We will order again for other events. Thank you for helping make our event a success!

They nailed it! My daughter didn’t really have an exact idea of what she was wanting so we sent Caitlin our invitations and a few cookies she had liked and all we had to say was WOW! They absolutely rocked it! Better than we could have imagined. We are already planning another party just to order some more cookies!!

My cookies are perfect! I love them. So happy they’re individually wrapped. The best!

I don’t know how The Cookie Momster gets so much detail into such a small cookie but our monster truck cookies for my son’s 3rd bday turned out amazing! Can’t thank her enough!

i got the cutest cookies ever for a cowboy themed bachelorette party, they’re going to be such a hit!!!

Extremely helpful with finding and coming up with designs, made this process super easy and super fun! Not only do they look amazing, but they taste even better!! Hard to find both. More orders coming soon!!

Caitlyn’s so easy to work with. I gave her some ideas and let her be creative. The cookies were not only beautiful, but they were delicious!!!

We loooove these cookies! They are beautiful and delicious. She was super accommodating and efficient. Thank you!

My daughter loved her birthday cookies!!!Super cute and supper yummy!!!

Had the best experience with Caitlin! Sent her a photo with our vision and she went even above & beyond! Very impressed! And they were very tasty as well 😊

Cookies were such a hit at our event! Ordering was easy peasy! We will definitely be ordering again!!

I’ve ordered from Caitlyn twice and she always does an amazing job! She’s easy to communicate with and responds in a timely manner. It was easy to order and pay and the cookies were ready and beautifully wrapped for easy pick up! Highly recommend!

Cait always brings my crazy cookie ideas to life! Will never order cookies from anyone else!

Not only are the cookies each an artistic masterpiece but they are yummy. She’s my go to for every event!!

The Cookie Momster Always comes through with the most creative and cutest cookies! They taste delicious and Caitlin is so easy to work with. I’ve ordered multiple times and orders are always completed on time and the presentation is beautiful!

My cookies were exactly what I wanted and simply adorable! I can’t wait to show them off at my baby shower! Thank you so much!

Loved the cookies for my husband’s surprise birthday party! She took my ideas and ran with it. Tasted good and looked so amazing!

Super cute cookies exactly what we envisioned!! Our daughter was so happy!!

Cait goes above and beyond with each cookie order I receive. She NEVER disappoints and is always right on the mark with taste and design. Highly recommend.

Caitlin went above and beyond my request for girly Bluey cookies for my daughter’s 3rd bday. They were adorable and tasted so yummy too! Highly recommend!!

Caitlin with CookieMomster makes the most detailed, beautiful, delicious cookies! She has made cookies for me on 2 occasions and both times they have been perfect! She is so easy to work with and is quick to respond to any texts or messages. I will definitely order from her again!

THEY ARE PRETTY & TASTE EVEN BETTER! I ordered cookies for my daughter’s shower and I didn’t know what I wanted, sent Caitlin the invite and she worked her magic to make the most beautiful set of cookies. They were so pretty, I felt bad eating them!! Can’t wait to order again 🤍

Best cookies ever! So beautiful I almost didn’t eat them, but boy am I glad I did! Amazing work Cookie Momster!

Caitlin made the most gorgeous cookies l could have ever asked for! They were a huge hit at my sister in laws engagement dinner! I can’t wait to use her in the future.

I just picked up my order from The Caitlin and i am blown away. She took the inspiration pictures my daughter sent and completely knocked it out of the park. They are gorgeous and taste even better. It’s hard to find cookies that are both pretty and yummy but they did it & we will be ordering again soon!