Ratings & Reviews

We had a baker cancel an order 2 1/2 days before a 20th anniversary event. We needed 200 custom cookies. The Cookie Jar was able to pick up the order and have them ready and Individually bagged in time for the event. They made a custom logo and a sunflower cookie. The cookies looked perfect and tasted great. Highly recommend.

This shop was amazing. I needed cookies last minute for my 1 year olds birthday. She was recommended to me by a few people on Facebook and I reached out. She was happy to take the order, accommodated my requests and design inspo, even asking for me to send a copy of the invite so she could incorporate the theme, and the cherry on top? These cookies were DELICIOUS! And adorable to boot. 10/10, will order from her again!

Amazing cookies! They were super cute and tasted amazing!

Ordered graduation and tennis cookies and they were better than imagined. Almost too good to eat - but guests loved them. Will absolutely order again!

Jen did an amazing job on our cookies

The Cookie Jar sugar cookies are by far the best. They always look amazing too. Highly recommended!

Very friendly and professional! The cookies came out so cute! Definitely will be ordering from her again!

Wonderful cookies, beautifully designed and personalized. Great to work with and price point was perfect for our budget.

She did an amazing job! She delivered pretty much exactly what I wanted and they tasted delicious! Thank you so much!

10/10!! Amazing owner, beautiful cookies, very affordable!

the best cookies! Reasonably priced for the quality of taste and design. I’m not typically a royal iced sugar cookie fan but these are fantastic!

So thankful I came across The Cookie Jar on Facebook because they did not disappoint!! From start to finish was nothing but great customer service. The cookies turned out better than I could have imagined!! Highly recommend for anyone needing some cute sweet treats!

Beautiful cookies for Life of Showgirl release weekend! They were so yummy and had wonderful flavor!!

I ordered some Taylor Swift themed cookies to surprise my daughter and they were an absolute hit! Jen knocked these out of the park!

The “sweet treats” for elementary staff members were a hit! Delicious and so very cute! Everyone had a smile!

We ordered some special order cat cookies for our little man’s birthday this past May and they were delicious, and adorable! They were a big hit at the birthday party!!! We are excited to now get to share some really cute back to school cookies for our first day of school!!!

The cutest cookies made for the perfect little gift! Thank you!! 💕💕💕

The cookies turned out exactly like the inspo photo I sent in and were a big hit for the party! The girls loved them and we will definitely use your service again in the future!

I reached out to see if she could possibly make Alani cookies for my daughter's 13th bday and that's exactly what she did! They turned out so cute and very yummy!

We have bought cookies from The Cookie Jar before a few times and every time they're beautifully decorated and so good! And Jennifer is so easy to work with! We will continue to buy fun cookies from The Cookie Jar!