Ratings & Reviews

The cake pops tasted so good. My family was impressed with the flavor and presentation of them. I also accidentally dropped the boxes from the wind and they held up after the drop they still looked great. Thanks for awesome cake pops. I will definitely order again sometime.

The cutest cake pops for my little guys big day! Loved the look and the taste was exceptional! 10/10 would recommend!

Best CakePops we’ve ever had. They are a must try!

I ordered some cake pops for the holiday and they were SO good!! (Chocolate, vanilla, and red velvet!) Not too mention they were decorated so cute, it was almost hard to justifying eating them! Great communication and on time, just like she promised :)

Brought a Christmas treat box to my in laws and it was gone in no time! The Biscoff toffee bark was a family favorite! Maggie did an excellent job! Will order all my holiday treats from The Cookie Jar!

Quality on-point!

Wonderful presentation and delectable sweets! Would highly recommend!

I brought an order of cake pops to my middle school church group and they were all obsessed! "These are SO good!" "Way better than Starbucks cake pops!" "They're so pretty!" A girl to her dad at pickup.. "Dad, we Need to go to this bakery!" (I gave them your FB page info) Needless to say, I'd purchase again in a heartbeat! Super fast service and great communication as well!

Maggie’s treats have been amazing! I’ve done both preordering and the porch pop up. Both have been easy to navigate AND so delicious. Highly recommend!!!

Bought a Boo Box for my wife for Halloween! She’s going to love it!

Kids LOVED the pops! Thank you!!

Pumpkin pie cake pop was amazing!

So cute and tastes great! Way better then the chain coffee shop ;)

Always the cutest presentation and the treats are always 10/10. Highly recommend

As a small business owner giving back to the community can be tough and at times may be not on people’s radars. Thank you for supporting our teams! Thank you for making a difference, no donation is ever taken for granted. Thank you for doing something different and thinking outside the box! We look forward to other opportunities to work together!

Absolutely delicious! The cookies and bars were so good—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. They were a hit with everyone! On top of that, the experience was just as sweet—super easy to work with, friendly communication, and everything went smoothly from start to finish. Highly recommend!

My husband and I enjoy having treats around, but I don’t enjoy baking. Since I don’t get to Fargo as often as I should, I place a large order with a variety of treats from the Cookie Jar. When I get home, I divide the order and freeze part of it, bringing out different treats each day! Everything the Cookie Jar makes is excellent and freezes well. My husband especially enjoys the Chex Mix. The Cookie Jar is definitely my go to place for the treats my husband and enjoy!

Absolutely the most delicious treats! So accommodating with what the bride wanted. Everyone was raving about the delicious smores bars and brookies! I will definitely order again.. .even if just for myself! Lol

Well my birthday came around again this year and my supervisor purchased an assortment of bars, cookies and other goodies from the cookie jar. I usually don’t enjoy people knowing my birthday but I am glad they did. The baking Maggie does is superb. Great mix of flavors and they were just wonderful. Be careful, you can’t eat just one or at least I can’t.

everything we've gotten from The Cookie Jar has been amazing. We had the peanut butter cookies recently and took them with us on vacation - they were gone before we were unpacked and everyone was looking for more. Planning my next order and telling everyone I know about The Cookie Jar.

First time trying the trail mix and puppy chow and have to say they are both delicious. I’m picky with my puppy chow and this passes A+ 😋

We received four packs of the Smoked Trail mix and it's delicious! The smokey flavor is subtle and just right. The seasoning is spot on, and the packaging is really professional and well done. Can't wait to order more!

Bought the bundle to take to the lake this weekend and my family immediately opened and demolished everything! Next time I’ll buy more! Everything we have tried from The Cookie Jar has been amazing! Thanks Maggie, happy to continue to support your “sweet” business! 💕

The smores brownies were excellent. Very fresh and great tasting. Would highly recommend them.

Received Brookie and brownies in nice box with a bow. Presentation and flavors were great. Also had some smoked check mix, in which the smoke flavor with identifiable without being overwhelming

I LOVE EVERYTHING I get from the cookie jar. And im soo picky cause usually I can do it better... lol but everything she does, blows my mind! Thank you so much!

Amazing! I couldn’t say anything better about this pack of bars! Excited to for my friends to try the best treats in town! Thank you!!!

If I could rate 100 stars out of 5, I would! The treats are so delicious and unique. The smoked trail mix is also one of a kind, and definitely addicting! Yummy!

I can't wait to share the party box this weekend! I tried one of the brownie cake pops and they were amazing!

10/10 on all the bars! Packaged so cute for my 4th of July party!

The cutest little cake pop I’ve ever seen. My granddaughter love them!

Bought truffles at the last pop up and they were delicious 10/10

The cake pops that The Cookie Jar made for my daughter’s graduation open house were perfect! They tasted great and were displayed so adorably! Thank you so much!

Bought a bag at Kindred Days and wish I would have bought more bc we have been craving it since! Will be placing an order for more. My suggestion, BiGGER BAGS!

I got appreciation gifts so didn’t try them but they sure look good and the presentation is spot on! So cute! Thanks again!

I ordered custom cake pops for my son’s birthday and they turned out great! Pricing was in my budget and flavor was excellent. Maggie was great at commutation and made the whole ordering process a breeze. Would recommend for sure!

Bought the smoked snack mix for a poker night! All the guys loved it! Would highly recommend!

Ordered some Brookies for a client meeting and was not disappointed. Our team raved about how good they were and got little done in the meeting. :)

The Cookie Jar has become a fast-favorite for a sweet treat! The price is right, service is excellent and the desserts are the best in town! Only regret when I ordered for Teacher Appreciation week, is not thinking I’m a teacher (in some aspect, teaching/raising your children counts, right?!) and ordering for myself! Can’t wait for my next order!

What a great experience! Easy ordering, easy pickup! Treats were great too! Will be ordering again soon!

The Carrot Cake Bars were delicious! The crunch on top put it over the top 10/10. I also ordered a dozen of the truffles and they were great! Couldn’t stop after just 1. Order and pick up were easy too! Would highly recommend!

The Cookie Jar has made ordering special occasion treats so easy! I ordered several different cookies and bars for my sister’s bridal shower and they were great! Everyone was raving about them! Maggie is my favorite baker by far. Communication is amazing! I couldn’t say better things! Would highly recommend!

OMG! Guys the treats look AMAZING! SO CUTE! I can't wait to serve to my family tomorrow! Thank you for offering an affordable fun menu! I will definitely be a repeat customer🩷

The Cookie Jar's baked goods are so delicious! The treats are delightfully packaged and decorated. It is the perfect way to give yourself a little pick me up!

Gave my daughters all the Mother’s Day cookie cups and they were a success! They all loved them!

Bars were so good! Ordering and pickup was a breeze! Thank you!

We will be ordering again! One pan of bars didn’t even make it to Easter, our family gobbled them up instantly!

The chcolate chips cookies are my favorite! Keeping an eye on your pop up calender for sure!

I recently orders some cookie boxes for my employees after trying 1 at the porch Pop ups. Was a huge hit with my staff! Supporting small and local is important! Will be ordering more soon!

Ok so I love gems. When I say gems I mean trading cards. Many years ago for Christmas, my parents gifted me a wax box of 1996 skybox emotion gems. Yeah to say I was excited was an understatement. So I was ripping packs like there was no tomorrow that night. Can you guess what I pulled?! Yeah that’s right a Michael Jordan N-Tense insert! Pretty much got so excited I almost crapped my britches. Needless to say all these years later I was debating sending them in to get graded. Well I didn’t cause I found an effin soft corner so I knew that would knock it down a few grades and daddy can’t have that. Well I put in a magnetic that someone could argue is the best in the entire hobby……..oh and those cookies were superb I guess!

Peanut butter and chocolate always goes good together, but the star of this cookie is the waffle cone. The waffle cone adds another layer of texture that makes it fun to eat. This is a wonderful cookie! The flavors blend very well together and it just makes you want more. 5 stars!

The Chocolate chip reminded me of my grandmas! So good and fresh!

Wow wow wow! Got a cookie box over the weekend and they were delicious!!