Ratings & Reviews

Absolutely amazing! Just like the inspo picture!

Evalyn knocked this theme out of the park with the custom cookie cake and beautiful cookies to match! Thank you!

Not only are her cakes beautiful they are extremely delicious!!

Wonderful customer service! Both her cakes and cookies are just as delicious as they are beautiful!

We had the cutest and most yummy cupcake cake! It tasted as good as it looked! She worked with us on pick up due to winter weather challenges! Will order again!

They matched the theme perfectly! Everyone loved the design and taste. Would definitely order from here again!

She was so easy to work with, her system is so easy and mainstream. She's easy to get in touch with and delivered way over my expectations! I've never had a cake with such amazing taste and so moist! Will definitely be ordering again from The Cherished Cookie!

This cake was awesome! Had great flavor and was a huge hit at my daughter’s birthday party. I would definitely recommend trying out the cakes.

The cake we ordered was dancing fruit for my nieces 1st birthday the cake was so moist fresh and good and the frosting and filling was 2 die for I highly recommend cherished cookie for all events that your bring desserts 2 definitely will be a routine costumer

Per usual, she cooked (or baked ;) ), or whatever the kids are saying nowadays. These cookies have amazing flavor and are always decorated beautifully. No sacrificing for good-tasting or beautiful cookies, with The Cherished Cookie you always get both! Thank you so much!

I ordered cookies for my Sister’s baby shower and they were beyond beautiful and delicious. We will definitely be ordering again!

Loved the taste, texture, and they were beautiful 😍 everyone enjoyed them and asked where I got them!! 100% recommended

I didn’t have anything set in stone for what I wanted, and trusted she would come up with a great design and she did just that! Beautiful cookies!

We had so many compliments on the cookies!! I had lots of people asking where we got them, they are so good!! We’ve tried a few other places and haven’t been super impressed with the taste, but yours are not only delicious but so professionally made! We will be back ALOT! 🤩

I placed an order for some basic filler cookies while I was in town visiting family. And she upgraded my order for free and decorated them for my baby girl who’s in the way. The details were amazing and so beautiful, and the cookies were delicious. Very satisfied and highly recommend!

Very friendly to work with and always delivers! She has surpassed my vision for multiple parties and my guests are continuously impressed with the detail work that goes into each cookie ❤️ Highly recommend to anyone!

So easy to work with, answered all my questions, responded promptly every time I messaged. The cookies were beautiful and tasted delicious! We got lots of compliments on them! We added them to the party favor bags and it was the perfect touch. I loved getting the mock up of them before hand as well to make sure I didn’t want to change anything!