Ratings & Reviews

If you’re looking for the ultimate chocolate cookie experience, look no further than Tameika’s Cookie Jar LLC. These cookies don’t just deliver — they overdeliver, and my students can prove it. The s’mores cookies are pure nostalgia in every bite. Gooey marshmallow, rich chocolate, and these disappear the fastest, every single time. The double chocolate cookies are for the serious chocolate devotee. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or just treating yourself, Tameika’s Cookie Jar LLC never fails to impress. I’ve brought them to my students on multiple occasions, and the reaction is always the same — pure joy and immediate requests for more.

Do not hesitate to place your order. The cookies were a surprised for my daughter. Everyone in the family got to taste them and are asking for more. It was individually wrapped. It was the perfect gift because the cookies were heart shaped. Everyone in the family fell in love with them. The box that they came in was a beautiful Valentine's day box. Perfect gift with great flavor. It was a hit.

Tameika’s Cookie Jar is an absolute must-try! Every cookie tastes homemade with so much love and care baked into each bite. They’re perfectly soft, fresh, and full of rich flavor—not overly sweet, just right. You can tell quality ingredients are used, and the attention to detail really shows. The variety is amazing, and each flavor stands out on its own. Whether you’re grabbing cookies for yourself, your family, or a special occasion, they always hit the spot. On top of that, the presentation is beautiful and the service is just as sweet as the cookies themselves. Highly recommend Tameika’s Cookie Jar to anyone looking for delicious, comforting treats that feel like home. I’ll definitely be coming back for more! 🍪

The service, quality, and love that is felt from this company is top tier. The cookies are delicious and creative. I’m looking forward to your growth!

I ordered the assorted dozen of cookies to be delivered. The website is very user friendly and very easy to maneuver and place the order. I was concerned that I may not receive them in enough time to contribute to the sweets table for Thanksgiving. The owner assured me that I would receive them on Tuesday, and I did! I had to sample one, the Butter Pecan flavor melts in your mouth. A slight crisp on the outside, soft and moist on the inside. I am sure my family will love them. Place your order, you will not be disappointed. Thank you for the delicious cookies and your attention to details, very impressed!

We compared these cookies with other big brands we found these cookies were top shelf also

Ordering from Tameika’s Cookie Jar was an absolute pleasure. The process was quick, simple, and stress-free from start to finish. The cookies themselves were outstanding — fresh, flavorful, and crafted with care. Each bite was a reminder of the quality and attention to detail that went into them. I couldn’t be more impressed with both the product and the service. Tameika’s Cookie Jar delivers excellence in every way, and I highly recommend them to anyone looking for delicious cookies and a seamless ordering experience.

Every order has been perfection! From the flavor options to the packaging!

Theses cookies have a way of making you like flavors that you may not have liked before when made elsewhere. All delicious, great value and service overall

Made an order for custom decorated sugar cookies and they were the most fresh and moist decorated cookies I have tasted!! I will be ordering soon again! Thank you!!

We ordered for an event at work and everyone loved each variety of cookies purchased. Highly recommended.

These are the BEST cookies ever! Crispy on the outside, gooey in the middle, and totally addictive. One bite and you’ll be hooked! 🍪🔥

These cookies were an absolute hit with our teachers and scholars! From the first bite to the last crumb, every cookie delivered on flavor, freshness, and that perfect homemade touch. Whether it was classic chocolate chip or a fun, colorful surprise, each one disappeared faster than we could unwrap them. Thank you for the sweet treat—our staff and students are still raving about them!

I just wanted to write to thank you for the amazing cookies that you made for us. My husband love the Oatmeal Raisin.(it reminded him of his grandma’s recipe)Not only were they perfect, but they were delicious, too. I so appreciate all of your attention to detail and beautiful work! We are looking forward to order some more soon.🙏🏾🙏🏾

The cookies were delicious. The cookies went fast, we got 2 dozen and they last like 1/2 hour. Everyone was very happy. Great flavor and great service! THANK YOU SO MUCH

Awesome cookies, everyone loved them. Will definitely order again 🙌

Got to try Tameika's cookie jar sugar cookies and they are delish! Also,loved the box details and careful packaging to keep you cookies fresh 😍 you can tell they are packed with love! 💞 Thanks!

It was really good cookies Love it

Moist, soft perfect cookies. Worth every penny.

The best cookies. I ordered these cookies for my daughter’s birthday party and they were a success. My favorite one was the chocolate …. So yummie. Thank you so much. I can’t wait for my next order .

I ordered the cutest teacher appreciation gifts! No stress for me and happy teachers! My kids were so happy to deliver them too!

I just want to say thank you for these amazing cookies.. my boys love them and will definitely recommend them.. I can’t wait to put in my next order.

The best cookie I have EVER had!!!

Omg! These things are sooooo delicious and moist. I need a least a dozen a month just have for my personal use!

The cookies from Tamika’s cookie jar were nothing short of amazing! I ordered the sugar cookies with the candy sprinkles, the ones with the icing and also the chocolate chip. They were soft, and tasted delicious. The decorations on each cookie were precise and absolutely adorable. The packaging the cookies arrived in were secure and decorated for the occasion. I will be ordering again!! Thank you 💖

These cookies were moist, filled with lots of chocolate chips. I enjoyed every morsel! Excellent taste; just the right amount of sweetness to have you craving for more. Will definitely order from the “Tameika’s Cookie Jar” again!

My husband took your homemade sugar & chocolate chip cookies to church and the entire 2 dozen was gone in 10 minutes!