Ratings & Reviews

29 Ratings
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Keirstin Barnhart
Verified Order
14 days ago
AmazonPeggy Hensel
Verified Order
16 days ago
The lemon blueberry scones were amazing and we also got the cinnamon raisin bread that was just as good. Will order again!
Amazing sourdough Alaina
Verified Order
16 days ago
Ordered cinnamon raisin sourdough loaf and it is amazing!! Baked perfectly I could eat the whole thing in one sitting!
Amazing!Kelly Murrer
Verified Order
22 days ago
My first time ordering and the best sourdough bread and cookies I have ever tasted.
Cheddar sourdough and cookies! Robin Hanson
Verified Order
23 days ago
Bread and cookies are delicious. Worth every penny. Communication with Sydney also great.
Wonderful! Teri Livermon
Verified Order
23 days ago
Easy ordering, easy pick up and the best sour dough bread! The mini cinnamon raisin bread is amazing!
ExcellentChristy C
Verified Order
28 days ago
Amazing bread and cookies !!! Superior communication and order was ready so quickly. Check Sydney’s Sourdough out- you will not be disappointed. Would give10 stars if I could !!!
So good!Amber Holt
Verified Order
about 1 month ago
10/10! Absolutely loved what we ordered! Everything was fresh, delicious, and beautifully presented. Will definitely be ordering again soon, I highly recommend!
Best Sourdough baked goods in the 757!!!Caroline Anderson
Verified Order
about 1 month ago
We have ordered the sourdough bread, several cookies, and scones. They have all been extremely delicious. The orders get fulfilled very quickly and to perfection. All of it was gone in just two days! The Onion Gouda sourdough is amazing as a bacon grilled cheese. My family just can’t get enough and we will be a constant customers of Sydney. Hoping she opens a bakery in the future! 😁
Paula Collier
Verified Order
about 1 month ago
So yummy! Perfect snow storm snacks.Patti
Verified Order
2 months ago
Sydney's communication was amazing, pickup was easy, and let me tell you... the sourdough bread and cookies were so yummy! Who needs dinner when you have oatmeal raisin cookies and black pepper parmesean sourdough bread?!
DeliciousValia Maloney
Verified Order
2 months ago
All of Sydney’s breads are absolutely amazing and I’m completely obsessed
Sydney's Sourdough!Caitlin
Verified Order
2 months ago
Delicious! Can't wait to try other flavors!
Bread & CookiesRenee Weeks
Verified Order
3 months ago
We have tried both the bread and cookies simply AMAZING!
Seriously so goodS Thomas
Verified Order
3 months ago
I purchased the chocolate chip Cookies and the original sourdough. Honestly I’m not sure which I liked better! The bread was some of the best I’ve ever had! Can’t wait to try the other flavors!
Verified Order
3 months ago
Beautiful Sourdough!Lauren Wheeler
Verified Order
3 months ago
I ordered four mini loaves: Rosemary, Gouda, Chocolate Chip, and Cheddar. Every single one was delicious. The texture is tender and soft on the inside with that perfect sourdough structure. The savory loaves are flavorful without being heavy, and the chocolate chip is just the right amount of sweet. You can tell a lot of care goes into Sydney’s sourdough. Absolutely delicious and we will be ordering again!
THE BEST!!!Kathy
Verified Order
3 months ago
This bread is top shelf. I served it at Christmas & everyone complimented it! I particularly like that it is cooked just right; the middle is soft and the crust is not hard & brittle like store bought! Sydney has the secret and talent for baking bread!!!
Verified Order
3 months ago
Best Sourdough on the East coast? KP
Verified Order
3 months ago
Somehow this bread has Bay Area attitude while sitting comfortably in Yorktown, VA, minding its own business and pretending it hasn’t seen the Golden Gate. Bold tang, chewy center, crust that fights back a little. The fact that this loaf exists in Yorktown, VA feels illegal, but I’m not asking questions. I’m just eating it. Pick a flavor, get a plain loaf, get the cookies, (seriously get all the cookies so I can’t), everything is absolutely delicious.
🍞Sarah B.
Verified Order
3 months ago
Order 3 loafs of Jalapeño Cheddar and Sourdough mini. Ordering online was easy! I was email quickly that my order was received, 2nd email for invoice and when it was completed. I also got a text when it was ready for pickup. Thank you Sydney! Keep it up girl!
Bread and cookies Maria Littreal
Verified Order
3 months ago
I have purchased from Sydney multiple times and her baked goods are consistently delicious. I would highly recommend!!
Kaleigh Browder
Verified Order
3 months ago
Sydney’s sourdoughSusan Shaw
Verified Order
3 months ago
These breads Sydney makes are delicious and so many different kinds. Almost too pretty to eat. She also has the best homemade cookies. 5 stars from me
CookiesKamron Glauben
Verified Order
3 months ago
Very delicious
Sydney's Sourdough Maria
Verified Order
4 months ago
Sydney is a great baker. Her cookies and bread are delicious. We are repeat customers. Highly recommend!
Verified Order
4 months ago
The best sourdough ever! Jenna Dye
Verified Order
4 months ago
Have ordered cookies and bread multiple times now. It is truly the best sourdough I’ve ever had in the cookies just fall apart in your mouth. They’re so delicious! Highly recommended Sydney’s Sourdough!
Fresh and toastyElizabeth
Verified Order
4 months ago
Appreciate the ease of online ordering and communication! It’s soft and delicious. Would order again!