Decorated sugar cookies are $95 per dozen, with a one dozen minimum per order.
Why are custom cookies so expensive?
Every order from Sweet Scarlet is completely custom. From the very first idea to the final ribbon on the box. You’re not simply purchasing a dozen cookies; you’re investing in hours of design, artistry, baking, and hand-crafted detail created just for your celebration.
Design & Planning.
Every order begins long before the mixer turns on. I spend time discussing your vision, researching inspiration, creating a cohesive color palette, sketching concepts, designing custom layouts, selecting fonts, and digitally planning every cookie so the finished set tells a beautiful story.
Made Completely From Scratch.
Each cookie is baked from scratch using premium ingredients, including real butter, high quality vanilla, and carefully selected ingredients that create the soft, flavorful cookies Sweet Scarlet is known for. Dough is mixed, rolled, chilled, hand-cut, baked, and cooled before the decorating process even begins. Every icing color is mixed by hand, and multiple consistencies are prepared to achieve different decorating techniques.
Hand Decorated, One Cookie at a Time
This is where the magic happens. Every cookie is individually flooded, dried, piped, detailed, and finished by hand. Crisp lettering, clean line work, dimensional details, hand-painted accents, and intricate designs all require patience, precision, and many hours of focused work. Depending on the complexity of the design, decorating alone can take anywhere from several hours to an entire day.
Beautifully Packaged
Presentation matters just as much as taste. Each cookie is individually heat sealed to lock in freshness with the ingredients listed on the back. They are carefully arranged in bakery boxes, cushioned for safe transport, and finished with thoughtful packaging so your order arrives looking as beautiful as it tastes.
From the initial design consultation to the final packaged box, every dozen represents many hours of work and years of experience. My goal is to create cookies that become part of your celebration… not just dessert, but edible artwork that people remember.
What flavors do you offer?
I offer four different flavors to choose from.
Basic Batch:
🍨 Sometimes the classics really are the best. A soft, buttery vanilla sugar cookie topped with our signature vanilla icing. Simple, sweet, and never boring.
🍫 Death by Chocolate:
Deep, rich chocolate flavor with all the fudgy goodness of a brownie, finished with our signature vanilla icing.
🖤 Milk & Cookies:
Cookies & cream, but better. A buttery sugar cookie loaded with real crushed Oreos and topped with smooth vanilla icing. Like your favorite after-school snack all grown up.
🥳 Party Cake:
Every day deserves a celebration. A birthday cake–flavored sugar cookie with colorful sprinkles baked right into the dough, finished with our signature vanilla icing.
What is the minimum order?
One dozen cookies.
How far in advance should I order?
I recommend ordering 2-4 weeks in advance at least. Popular holidays book quickly, so the sooner, the better!
Where are you located?
I’m a licensed home baker located in Lithia, FL.
Do you deliver?
Porch pickup is available for all orders. Orders of 5 dozen or more are eligible for delivery within Tampa and surrounding areas (Brandon, Riverview, Lithia, Valrico, etc.)
Do you ship?
No. At this time, I offer local pickup and qualifying local deliveries only.
Can I see a mock up before my order is made?
Yes! Digital mock-ups are available for a $25 graphic design fee and includes one round of revisions before I begin decorating.
How do I place an order?
Simply complete the order request form on my website. You can also find the link to order in my bio on my social media pages. (Instagram & Facebook)
Once I review your request, I’ll confirm availability and send an invoice.
When is payment due?
Full payment is required to reserve your order date. Dates are not held until payment is received.
Do you accommodate allergies?
My cookies are made in a home kitchen where common allergens (including wheat, eggs, dairy, soy, and nuts) may be present. I cannot guarantee an allergen free product.
How should I store my cookies?
Cookies can stay fresh for up to two weeks in their heat sealed packaging at room temperature. They can also be frozen for up to three months.
What happens if I need to cancel?
Because each order is custom made, cancellations are handled on a case by case basis. Please see my Terms & Conditions for full details.