Ratings & Reviews

Still not over how perfect these cookies were for our gender reveal. Not only were they absolutely beautiful and matched our theme perfectly but they tasted just as amazing as they looked. Every single detail was done with so much care and you can truly tell the love that went into making them. They were such a special part of our day and everyone kept talking about how good they were! Thank you so much for helping make our gender reveal even more memorable we will 100% be ordering again 🤍

The online process to order is so easy - I loved the option to add in inspiration pictures! I got a fast response and exactly what I was hoping for . The cookies looked great and tasted even better. I did a set of cupcakes and they were delicious! I highly recommend and will be ordering again :)

Great flavor and quality. They get better every order!!!

5 stars! Everything about my experience with Tabitha & Sugar Coated Creations was amazing! The ordering process, the communication, & the pick up all went so smoothly which is great during an already busy time! Not to mention how kind Tabitha is & you can tell she truly cares about making sure you have the perfect sweet treats for your event. Couldn’t be happier 🥰

The cut out cookies for my daughter’s graduation party turned out super cute and we received multiple compliments on them. They were all gone before the end of the party!

I would totally recommend ordering from her again! The website was super easy to use. We did graduation cookies for my sons party. She made us sugar cookies and chocolate chip. They were a huge success with everyone! So delicious! Only had a few left to bring home for us after! Thank you again!!!

I would highly recommend Sugar-Coated-Creation WNY. The cookies were beautiful and DELICIOUS! They were a big hit at the party..will order again....Thank you Tabitha

Tabitha made cookies for my daughter’s graduation party. The not only did they look amazing but tasted amazing! Can’t wait to order again!

Tabitha was very professional & accommodating when setting up the request order. Her delivery of the order was on time and staff loved the homemade taste of the cookies. It was a very successful experience and a pleasure working with Tabitha!! Thankyou!

I recently ordered a custom Fire Department-themed cookies from Sugar Coated Creations WNY for our annual awards banquet, and the experience exceeded all expectations. From the start, Tabitha was a pleasure to work with—professional, attentive, and incredibly creative. She offered several design options and truly brought my vision to life. The final product was not only visually impressive but also absolutely delicious. It was clear that great care and craftsmanship went into every detail. The cookie was a hit at the event and added a special touch that everyone appreciated. I highly recommend Sugar Coated Creations WNY for any special occasion. Their combination of professionalism, fair pricing, and outstanding quality makes them a top choice for custom treats.