Ratings & Reviews

I ordered dental-themed cookies from Stirring Up Sweets for our endodontic office to share with our referring practices. The cookies were absolutely perfect! Not only were the cookies designed with incredible attention to detail, but they also tasted amazing. The packaging was equally beautifully and notably handled with care, making a great first impression. The entire ordering process was smooth and professional, and the final product exceeded our expectations. I’m looking forward to placing another order.

Absolutely delicious and beautifully made! These cookies are hands-down some of the best I’ve ever had—soft, flavorful, and made without seed oils, which is rare and such a huge plus. I ordered both vanilla and chocolate flavors, and each one was fresh and perfectly baked. The decoration matched my request exactly, adding a personal and polished touch. I couldn’t be happier with how they turned out. Highly recommended!

Alyssa from Stirring Up Sweets was delightful to work with. Her work is amazing. I had purchased some gorgeous Nativity cookies to give as gifts at Christmas last year and I knew right away that I would order from her again. I just received my custom cookie order for my daughter’s wedding shower and they are stunning! Alyssa does very beautiful, detailed work and she creates exactly what you ask for. She was actually able to put a Bible verse from Proverbs in a script font in our chosen colors on each cookie and then wrapped them individually in lovely drawstring bags. We will be giving these as a gift to our guests so they will go home with Scripture. I am very impressed with Alyssa’s talent. I recommend her to anyone wanting delicious, professional, custom deserts or cookies as gifts or for your next event! Thank you Alyssa!

I recently ordered an assortment of treats from Stirring up Sweets, and everything was absolutely perfect. I got cupcakes, pretzel rods, chocolate-covered Oreos, cake pops, and chocolate-covered marshmallows — and not only did they taste amazing, but the presentation was stunning! Each item was beautifully designed with incredible attention to detail. You can really tell that a lot of care and creativity goes into Alyssa’s work. The flavors were just as impressive — rich, fresh, and not overly sweet. The cupcakes were moist and flavorful, the cake pops had the perfect texture, and the chocolate-covered treats had that perfect snap. If you’re looking for a dessert table showstopper or just something delicious to treat yourself or your guests, Stirring Up Sweets is a must-try. I’ll definitely be ordering again!

These custom cookies are a delightful treat! Perfectly baked with a soft, chewy center and crisp edges, they’re as beautiful as they are delicious. The designs were spot-on, tailored to my request. Fresh, creative, and delivered with care. Highly recommend for any occasion!"